Removing Alcohol From Vanilla: Boiling Point Tips

Vanilla extract is a common ingredient used in baking to add a rich, deep flavour to cakes, cookies, and cupcakes. It is usually added towards the end of the cooking process to prevent the alcohol in the extract from evaporating and taking the vanilla flavour compounds with it. However, in some cases, the alcohol taste in vanilla extract can be overpowering, and some people may prefer to reduce it. While it is challenging to completely remove the alcohol from vanilla extract, there are a few methods that can help reduce its presence, such as simmering it in milk or burning it off with a direct flame. Additionally, alternatives such as vanilla sugar, vanilla powder, or alcohol-free vanilla flavouring can be used as substitutes.

How to boil the taste of alcohol out of vanilla

Simmering in milk for 20 minutes

Simmering in milk is a popular method for reducing the alcohol content in vanilla extract. However, it's important to note that simmering may not completely eliminate the alcohol. The effectiveness of this method depends on various factors, including the initial amount of extract used and the duration of simmering.

To begin the process of simmering vanilla in milk, combine vanilla extract with milk in a suitable cooking vessel, such as a saucepan or a pan. The amount of vanilla extract added should be relatively small, as a teaspoon of extract is typically sufficient for a single cup of milk. This proportion ensures that the vanilla flavour is not overpowering and allows for better control over the reduction of alcohol.

Once the vanilla extract and milk are combined, place the vessel on a stovetop and adjust the heat to a level that maintains a gentle simmer. It is crucial not to let the mixture come to a full boil, as this can affect the texture and flavour of the milk. Maintain the simmer for approximately 20 minutes, stirring occasionally to prevent scorching and promote even cooking.

During the simmering process, the alcohol in the vanilla extract will gradually evaporate, reducing its concentration in the milk. However, it is important to note that not all the alcohol will cook out, and a portion of it, typically between 15% to 50%, may remain even after the specified time. This residual alcohol content is due to the affinity of alcohol for water, making it challenging to completely "boil off" low alcohol concentrations.

After simmering for 20 minutes, the milk will be infused with the flavour of vanilla, creating a subtle hint of sweetness. At this point, you can adjust the flavour by adding sweeteners like maple syrup or honey to suit your taste preferences. This method of simmering in milk is particularly useful for preparing vanilla-flavoured milk or creating a base for desserts or baked goods that require a creamy vanilla flavour without an overpowering alcoholic taste.

Boiling directly over a gas flame

Boiling alcohol directly over a gas flame is a method that has been used to burn off the alcohol in vanilla extract. Vanilla extract is made by dissolving important compounds in alcohol, which is why it has such a strong taste. The boiling point of alcohol is 78°C (173°F), so holding a small quantity of vanilla extract at a temperature between 80°C and 100°C will burn off some of the alcohol content.

One method that has been suggested is to take a tablespoon of the extract and put it in a spoon, then hold it directly over the flame of a gas burner. The vanilla will boil and eventually ignite. It is important to note that this method does come with risks, as you are dealing with an open flame and a flammable liquid.

This method will burn off some of the alcohol, but it is not easy with standard kitchen hardware, as it is difficult to maintain the temperature within the desired range. It is also worth noting that boiling the vanilla extract will likely cause some of the more complex flavours to evaporate, which may negatively impact the overall taste.

If you are looking to completely remove the alcohol content from vanilla extract, it may be best to opt for an alcohol-free alternative, such as vanilla powder, essence, sugar, paste, or pudding mix.

Using alcohol-free vanilla flavouring

If you want to avoid the taste of alcohol in your cooking, it is best to opt for an alcohol-free vanilla flavouring. Vanilla extract, by definition, contains a minimum of 35% alcohol by volume, and the flavour compounds are suspended in this alcohol.

Alcohol-free vanilla flavouring is derived from real vanilla beans and grown in places like Madagascar. It is a great alternative to vanilla extract, with the same rich, warm taste. It is perfect for any recipe that calls for vanilla extract, especially no-bake items like smoothies, ice cream, or frosting. It can also be used in baking cakes, cookies, and pastries.

Some popular brands that sell alcohol-free vanilla flavouring include Simply Organic and Watkins. Simply Organic's vanilla flavouring contains less than 0.5% alcohol by volume, which is suspended in a mixture of water and vegetable glycerin. Watkins has been a popular choice for generations and delivers a rich, classic flavour in an alcohol-free formula.

If you are unable to find alcohol-free vanilla flavouring, you can try other alternatives such as vanilla beans, vanilla sugar, vanilla powder, vanilla essence, or vanilla paste. Vanilla sugar, in particular, is a popular choice, as the alcohol smell evaporates over time, resulting in a good flavour.

Using vanilla beans instead of extract

Vanilla beans are a great alternative to vanilla extract. They are the fruit of an orchid and are considered one of the most costly spices, second only to saffron. The beans should be soft, oily, and have a strong vanilla aroma. Avoid beans that are dry and brittle.

To use vanilla beans, you need to cut them open and scrape out the seeds, also known as vanilla bean caviar. This caviar can then be rubbed into sugar and added to recipes that call for sugar or vanilla. You can also make a paste by mixing the caviar with a teaspoon of hot water, which can then be added to recipes.

When substituting vanilla beans for extract, there is no exact conversion, and the amount of beans used will depend on personal preference. However, as a general rule, one teaspoon of vanilla extract can be substituted for one whole vanilla bean. If you are using dried beans, you may need to soak them in a hot liquid for 15-90 minutes to rehydrate them before use.

Diluting with water and reducing

Vanilla extract is a common ingredient in baking, adding a rich and deep flavour to cakes, cookies, and cupcakes. However, the alcohol in vanilla extract can sometimes leave a bitter taste or overpowering boozy flavour.

One method to reduce the alcohol content in vanilla extract is to dilute it with water and then reduce the mixture by boiling. However, this method is not particularly effective, as water has a higher boiling point than alcohol. As a result, you will mostly boil off the water, only reducing the alcohol content slightly. In addition, the heat required for this process may cause the more complex flavours of the vanilla to evaporate, resulting in a deterioration of the overall flavour.

To attempt this method, you can dilute the vanilla extract with water and heat it to a temperature between 80°C and 100°C. Maintaining the temperature within this range can be challenging with standard kitchen equipment, and you will need to ensure that the temperature does not exceed 100°C.

It is important to note that the major components of vanilla extract have high melting and boiling points, so reducing the alcohol content through boiling may not be a feasible option. Additionally, the alcohol in vanilla extract is inherent, as it is used to dissolve the important compounds, and complete removal of alcohol may not be possible.

If you are looking for an alcohol-free alternative, there are several options available, including vanilla powder, vanilla essence, vanilla sugar, and vanilla paste. Alternatively, you can make your own vanilla extract using vanilla beans and food-grade vegetable glycerin, which is a sweet, low-calorie substitute for alcohol.

Frequently asked questions