Weed Vs. Alcohol And Cigarettes: Which Is Safer?

The use of weed to replace alcohol is a growing trend in the United States. While both substances are habit-forming, alter thinking and coordination, and have addiction potential, the risks of regular cannabis use appear to be lower than those of alcohol use. Alcohol is linked to weight gain, violent crimes, and chronic diseases, and can negatively impact the brain and most organs in the body, including the heart, liver, and pancreas. On the other hand, studies suggest that regular marijuana smokers have a slightly reduced risk of obesity, and there is no link between cannabis and violent behaviour. Furthermore, no deaths from marijuana overdoses have been reported, while more than 30,000 Americans died from alcohol-induced causes in 2014. However, it is important to note that the science of cannabis is less understood due to its mostly illegal status, and that the way a person consumes weed can significantly impact its short- and long-term effects.

Is weed better for you than alcohol and cigarettes?

Addiction and overdose risk

While both alcohol and weed have addiction potential, the risk of addiction appears to be lower with weed. According to the criteria for dependence in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, approximately 9% of those who experiment with marijuana will become addicted, compared to 23% for alcohol. The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA) reports that alcohol use disorder affects 15 million people in the United States, while data suggests that 30% of those who use weed may have some degree of "marijuana use disorder".

Withdrawal symptoms are also associated with both substances. For alcohol, these can include nausea, sweating, shaking, and headaches. For weed, while there is no clear evidence of physical withdrawal symptoms, some people may experience emotional dependence, with difficulty functioning without it.

The risk of overdose also differs between the two substances. Alcohol use disorder is a factor in 40% of violent crimes, and excessive drinking has been linked to a shorter lifespan. In 2014, more than 30,000 people in the US died from alcohol-induced causes, not including drinking-related accidents or homicides. On the other hand, there have been zero documented deaths from marijuana use alone, and it is not associated with an increased risk of certain cancers that are tied to smoking cigarettes.

The way weed is consumed can also impact the risk of overdose. Smoking weed can be harsh on the lungs, and marijuana smoke may be more harmful than tobacco smoke due to the way it is inhaled. However, there are other consumption methods such as edibles, topicals, and tinctures that do not carry the same risks as smoking.

In conclusion, while both alcohol and weed have addiction and overdose risks, the available evidence suggests that the risks may be lower with weed. However, it is important to note that the science of cannabis is still evolving, and more research is needed to fully understand the long-term effects of both substances.

Short-term effects

The short-term effects of weed and alcohol differ from person to person. The way you feel when intoxicated depends on how much of the substance you consume. While one person might feel relaxed while drunk, another might feel restless.

Both weed and alcohol can cause intoxication, which impairs cognitive and psychomotor performance. A study of experienced airplane pilots showed that their performance on flight simulator tests was impaired for up to 24 hours after smoking a single marijuana cigarette.

Weed and alcohol also have similar effects on reflexes and judgment. However, the feeling of intoxication differs between the two substances. Getting drunk or high can feel similar to some people, while others describe the sensations as very different.

Both substances can also leave you feeling worse for wear the next day, although this is more likely to happen with alcohol. A hangover can include symptoms like headaches and diarrhea.

The immediate effects of weed can vary quite a bit from person to person. Some possible short-term effects of weed include:

• Increased heart rate, which could negatively affect the heart in the short term
• Short-term memory loss
• Inability to concentrate
• Increased appetite
• Altered thinking and coordination
• Impaired driving ability

It is important to note that the way weed is consumed can also impact its short-term effects. For example, smoking weed can be rough on the lungs, but this risk doesn't apply to edibles.

Long-term health effects

The long-term health effects of weed and alcohol differ from person to person. While the science of cannabis is murkier due to its mostly illegal status, it is clear that both substances can be habit-forming and have the potential for misuse and addiction. However, the risk of addiction appears to be lower for weed than for alcohol. According to the criteria for dependence in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, approximately 9% of those who experiment with marijuana will become addicted, while for alcohol, that percentage leaps to 23%.

Excessive alcohol use is linked to serious health issues, including liver disease, pancreatitis, heart damage, stomach and digestive issues, central nervous system damage, erectile dysfunction, and infertility. It is also a factor in 40% of violent crimes, and a study found that the rates of mental and physical abuse were higher on days when couples drank. Alcohol use can also negatively impact brain function and most organs in the body, including the heart, liver, and pancreas.

The long-term effects of weed are not as clear, but so far, the general long-term effects associated with weed include brain development issues. However, it is important to note that the way weed is consumed can impact its long-term effects. For example, smoking weed can be rough on the lungs, and marijuana smoke may be more harmful than tobacco smoke as users hold the hot smoke in their lungs longer to maximize their high. On the other hand, other consumption methods such as edibles or topicals do not carry the same risks as smoking.

In terms of risk of death or overdose, research suggests that marijuana may be less of a health risk than alcohol. There have been zero documented deaths from marijuana use alone, and no deaths from marijuana overdoses have been reported. In contrast, more than 30,000 Americans died from alcohol-induced causes in 2014, and the number of alcohol-related deaths would be closer to 90,000 if drinking-related accidents and homicides were included.

While there is no clear-cut answer for which substance is better for one's health, marijuana does not pose the same serious health dangers as excessive alcohol consumption. It is important to exercise caution when consuming either substance, as both carry risks.

Weight gain

The relationship between weed and weight gain is complex and not yet fully understood. While some people associate weed with weight gain due to increased appetite and food enjoyment, also known as the "munchies", studies have shown that long-term marijuana users tend to have lower body mass indexes (BMIs) than non-users. This could be due to several factors. Firstly, marijuana may increase metabolism and reduce energy storage, leading to lower BMI. Secondly, some experts suggest that people who use cannabis may consume less alcohol, thereby reducing their calorie intake from alcoholic drinks. Additionally, weed can help reduce stress and improve sleep, both of which can contribute to weight management. However, the specific effects of weed on weight may depend on various factors, including the strain of marijuana, the method of consumption, and individual differences in metabolism and eating habits.

It is important to note that the health implications of weed go beyond weight gain or loss. Smoking weed can damage the lungs and airways, leading to respiratory issues such as airway inflammation and chronic bronchitis. Additionally, there are potential psychological effects, including the risk of dependence and, in some cases, psychosis or mania-like symptoms in individuals with bipolar disorder. Furthermore, the long-term effects of weed on brain development are still being studied, with some research suggesting a link between weed consumption during adolescence and potential brain development issues later in life.

When comparing weed to alcohol and cigarettes in terms of weight gain, it is worth considering the overall health impacts of each substance. Alcohol consumption is associated with long-term effects such as liver disease, pancreatitis, heart damage, and stomach and digestive issues when used heavily or over an extended period. It can also impact fertility in both men and women. On the other hand, cigarettes are known to cause significant harm to the lungs and increase the risk of various types of cancer. While weed may not carry the same weight gain concerns as alcohol or cigarettes, it is essential to acknowledge its unique set of risks and side effects.

Overall, while weed may not directly cause weight gain and could potentially contribute to weight loss through various mechanisms, it is not recommended as a weight-loss strategy due to the potential health risks and the limited research on its long-term effects. Maintaining a healthy diet and exercising remain the safest and most proven methods for achieving and maintaining a healthy weight. Consulting with a healthcare professional is always advisable before considering any substance that may impact your health.

In conclusion, the relationship between weed and weight gain is intricate and not fully understood. While weed may influence metabolism, appetite, and other factors related to weight, it is essential to approach it with caution due to its potential health risks. Maintaining a healthy lifestyle through proper diet and exercise remains the most recommended approach to weight management.

Driving risks

When comparing the effects of weed, alcohol, and cigarettes on driving ability and road safety, it is important to consider the immediate and long-term impacts of each substance. While alcohol and cigarettes have long been legal and widely available, weed is gaining attention for its potential benefits and lower risk profile.

Weed, alcohol, and driving are a dangerous mix. Alcohol impairs several critical driving skills, including reaction time, coordination, and judgment. Even small amounts of alcohol can significantly impair driving ability, and the effects are immediate. On the other hand, weed can also impair driving ability, but the effects are more complex and vary depending on the individual and the specific cannabis product used. THC, the primary psychoactive component in weed, can affect coordination, reaction time, and judgment, similar to alcohol. However, the degree of impairment varies and may not be as immediate or obvious as with alcohol. Some studies suggest that weed's impairing effects on driving may be less severe or shorter-lasting than alcohol, especially with experienced users or when CBD is also present, as it can counteract some of THC's effects. Nonetheless, driving under the influence of weed is unsafe and illegal in most places.

The effects of weed on driving can depend on several factors, including the method of consumption. For example, smoking or vaping weed can lead to a more immediate and intense high, while edibles can take longer to take effect and the high may last longer. Regular users may develop a tolerance to some impairing effects, but it is unclear if this reduces driving impairment. Mixing weed with alcohol or other drugs can also enhance impairment and increase the risk of accidents.

Cigarettes, while not directly impairing driving skills like alcohol or weed, still pose risks. Smoking cigarettes while driving can be a dangerous distraction, especially when lighting up or disposing of ashes and butts. Also, the addictive nature of cigarettes may lead to risky behaviors, such as driving faster to finish a cigarette before it burns out or making impulsive decisions to ensure a continuous supply of cigarettes.

In terms of long-term effects, alcohol and cigarettes are associated with significant health risks that can indirectly impact driving ability over time. Excessive alcohol use can lead to liver damage, neurological impairments, and increased risk of certain cancers, all of which may affect driving ability in the long term. Cigarette smoking is a leading cause of lung cancer, heart disease, and respiratory issues, which can reduce overall health and stamina, potentially impacting driving performance and increasing the risk of accidents due to fatigue or illness.

While weed may not have the same immediate and obvious impairing effects on driving as alcohol, it is not without risks. Regular weed use can lead to a level of tolerance and dependence, and long-term effects on cognitive function and mental health are still being studied. Additionally, the illegal nature of weed in many places may contribute to unsafe procurement and use practices, such as driving under the influence to avoid detection or consuming unknown or unpredictable weed products. Overall, while weed may present some advantages over alcohol and cigarettes in terms of immediate impairment, safe driving requires abstinence from all impairing substances.

Frequently asked questions