Ethyl Alcohol Vs. Methanol: What's In Your Hand Sanitizer?

The COVID-19 pandemic has made hand sanitizers a necessity. However, not all hand sanitizers are safe for use. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has found that many hand sanitizers, especially those imported from Mexico and other countries, contain traces of methanol, a toxic substance that can be absorbed through the skin or ingested. On the other hand, ethyl alcohol and isopropyl alcohol are the two most common active ingredients found in hand sanitizers, and they are both effective at killing germs. This article aims to discuss the differences between ethyl alcohol and methanol in hand sanitizers and provide information on their safety and effectiveness.

The dangers of methanol in hand sanitizers

Since the COVID-19 pandemic, the use of hand sanitizers has become increasingly common as a means of preventing the spread of the virus. However, the widespread use of commercial disinfectant products has led to concerns about the dangers of methanol-containing hand sanitizers. Methanol, or methyl alcohol, is a toxic chemical that can be found in hand sanitizers, particularly those imported from Mexico and other countries. While methanol belongs to the same category of alcohol as ethyl alcohol and isopropyl alcohol, it is chemically distinct and significantly more toxic.

Methanol can be absorbed through the skin or inhaled as vapors, and it carries serious health risks. Symptoms of methanol poisoning include dizziness, headaches, weakness, nausea, vomiting, visual disturbances, and loss of consciousness. High levels of methanol toxicity can even lead to blindness, neurological dysfunction, and death. The dangers of methanol poisoning are particularly acute for young children, who may accidentally ingest hand sanitizers, and for adolescents and adults who intentionally drink these products as an alcohol substitute.

To address these concerns, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued warnings about toxic hand sanitizers containing methanol and expanded its list of hand sanitizers to avoid. The FDA recommends consumers choose hand sanitizers containing at least 60% ethyl alcohol or isopropyl alcohol, which are both effective disinfectants and antiseptics. These types of alcohol are safer for the skin and are not associated with the severe health risks posed by methanol.

It is important for consumers to carefully read the labels of hand sanitizer products and ensure they are purchasing from reputable manufacturers. While hand sanitizers can be an effective alternative to hand washing in certain situations, it is crucial to prioritize the safety and well-being of individuals, especially children, by selecting products that do not contain harmful substances like methanol.

Ethyl alcohol and isopropyl alcohol as safe alternatives

Ethyl alcohol and isopropyl alcohol are both effective alternatives to methanol in hand sanitizers. Both types of alcohol are used as disinfectants and antiseptics, killing bacteria, viruses, and other germs. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends using hand sanitizers with at least 60% alcohol content, which can be either ethyl or isopropyl alcohol.

Methanol, on the other hand, is a toxic alcohol that has been found in some hand sanitizers, particularly those imported from outside the United States. Its high toxicity can lead to serious health issues, including dizziness, headaches, nausea, and even blindness or death in severe cases. The CDC reported cases of methanol poisoning associated with the ingestion of alcohol-based hand sanitizers, resulting in fatalities and permanent vision loss.

Ethyl alcohol, often listed as ethanol on product labels, is generally considered superior to isopropyl alcohol by the World Health Organization (WHO). It is less damaging to the skin and is effective at killing a wide range of viruses, including the virus that causes COVID-19. A 2017 study found that isopropyl alcohol caused more skin damage compared to ethyl alcohol, making ethyl alcohol a better choice for frequent use.

Isopropyl alcohol, commonly known as "rubbing alcohol," is also an effective alternative to methanol. It has disinfectant and antiseptic properties and is commonly used in healthcare settings. While it may not be as effective against certain types of viruses, it is still capable of killing germs when used in concentrations of 60% or higher.

Both ethyl and isopropyl alcohol can be safely used in hand sanitizers, provided they are used correctly and are not ingested. It is important to always read the labels of hand sanitizers to ensure they contain the recommended amount of these safe alternatives to methanol.

The effectiveness of hand sanitizers with 60% or more alcohol content

Hand sanitizers are used to avoid common infectious illnesses and have become a necessity due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends that hand sanitizers contain at least 60% alcohol to be effective. The CDC also reported cases of methanol poisoning associated with drinking alcohol-based hand sanitizers. Therefore, it is important to choose a hand sanitizer that contains ethyl or isopropyl alcohol.

Both ethyl and isopropyl alcohol are effective at killing germs when used in concentrations over 60%. They are commonly used as disinfectants and antiseptics. Studies have found that both alcohols are most effective at killing germs when diluted with water to about 70%. Ethyl alcohol may cause less skin damage. However, it is still dangerous to ingest products containing either type of alcohol that are not meant for consumption.

The FDA has found that many hand sanitizers imported from Mexico and other countries contain traces of methanol, which is chemically different from ethyl alcohol or isopropyl alcohol and has higher toxicity. Methanol can be absorbed through the skin and can cause symptoms such as dizziness, headaches, weakness, nausea, and vomiting. High levels of methanol toxicity can lead to blindness and death.

To ensure the effectiveness of hand sanitizers, it is important to check the labels and choose products that contain at least 60% alcohol, preferably ethyl or isopropyl alcohol. Washing hands with soap and water is still recommended as the best defense against COVID-19 infection, but when soap and water are not available, hand sanitizers with 60% or more alcohol content are an effective alternative.

The toxicity of methanol when absorbed through the skin or ingested

When ingested, methanol can cause an altered or decreased level of consciousness, poor or no coordination, vomiting, abdominal pain, and a specific smell on the breath. Long-term outcomes may include blindness and kidney failure. As little as 10ml of pure methanol when drunk can cause blindness, and 15ml is potentially fatal. Methanol poisoning often occurs from drinking contaminated alcohol or methanol-containing products, such as windshield washer fluid.

Methanol can also be absorbed through the skin, especially in children, and can cause toxicity. Methanol vapours can be inhaled and absorbed into the bloodstream, and it can also enter the body through the eyes. Skin contact with methanol liquid can cause skin irritation and absorption. Chronic exposure can lead to dermatitis and conjunctivitis.

The treatment for methanol poisoning includes fomepizole or ethanol, which act as antidotes. Sodium bicarbonate can be given for metabolic acidosis, and hemodialysis can remove methanol and formate from the blood. Folinic or folic acid is also administered to enhance the metabolism of formate.

The symptoms of methanol poisoning

While ethyl alcohol and methanol are both types of alcohol, they are chemically different. Methanol is more toxic and can be dangerous if absorbed through the skin, inhaled, or ingested.

Methanol poisoning can occur through ingestion, inhalation, or skin absorption. Symptoms of methanol toxicity may include dizziness, headaches, weakness, nausea, vomiting, visual disturbances, and loss of consciousness. High levels of methanol toxicity can lead to blindness, kidney failure, and even death. Survivors of severe methanol poisoning may suffer from permanent blindness or neurological impairment.

Initial symptoms of methanol poisoning may resemble ethanol intoxication, with a latent period of 4-12 hours before the onset of metabolic acidosis and associated symptoms. Visual impairment may begin as early as 8-12 hours after exposure, with blurred vision, decreased visual acuity, and a sensation akin to "being in a snowstorm."

If you suspect methanol poisoning, it is important to seek immediate medical attention and contact Poison Control for expert advice.

Frequently asked questions