Transforming Secondary Alcohols: Synthesis Of Alkyl Halides

The conversion of secondary alcohols to alkyl halides is an important concept in organic chemistry. This process involves treating secondary alcohols with HX (HCl, HBr, or HI), resulting in a mixture of products from SN1 and SN2 pathways. While this reaction is not commonly used in practical applications due to challenges in preserving stereochemistry, it serves as a valuable educational tool for understanding carbocation rearrangements. The SN1 mechanism is particularly relevant, as it involves the formation of carbocations, which can undergo shifts to achieve a more stable state. This understanding of carbocation stability and rearrangements is essential in the context of secondary alcohol conversion to alkyl halides.

Using HX to convert secondary alcohols to alkyl halides

Converting secondary alcohols to alkyl halides using HX is a process that involves several steps and considerations. Here is a detailed explanation of the process:

Understanding the Process

The conversion of secondary alcohols to alkyl halides using HX involves treating the secondary alcohol with hydrohalic acids (HX), such as HCl, HBr, or HI. This treatment initiates a reaction that leads to the formation of an alkyl halide and water. The reactivity of these hydrohalic acids decreases in the order HI > HBr > HCl, with HF being generally unreactive due to its instability and fast reactivity rate.

Reaction Mechanism

The reaction mechanism involves the formation of a carbocation intermediate. Specifically, the secondary alcohol undergoes protonation, resulting in the loss of water. This is followed by a hydride shift, leading to the formation of a secondary carbocation. Subsequently, the carbocation reacts with a nucleophile (a halide ion), completing the substitution and forming the alkyl halide product.

Stereochemistry Considerations

When converting secondary alcohols to alkyl halides, stereochemistry becomes a crucial factor. Chiral secondary alcohols tend to produce a racemic mixture of alkyl halides when reacted with acids. This is because the planar geometry of the carbocation intermediate leads to racemization, resulting in a mixture of stereoisomers. To control the stereochemistry, strategies such as using mesylates, tosylates, SOCl2, or PBr3 can be employed to enforce the SN2 mechanism and prevent rearrangements.

SN1 and SN2 Pathways

The conversion of secondary alcohols to alkyl halides can proceed through both SN1 and SN2 pathways. While primary alcohols typically follow the SN2 pathway, secondary alcohols exhibit a mixture of products from both mechanisms. In the context of SN1 reactions, carbocation rearrangements are common, and the stability of carbocations increases with the number of attached carbons.

Practical Considerations

While the conversion of secondary alcohols to alkyl halides by HX is an important concept in organic chemistry, it is generally not a practical process in the laboratory, especially when preserving stereochemistry is a concern. Other methods, such as using SOCl2 or PBr3, are often preferred for converting primary and secondary alcohols to alkyl halides while controlling the stereochemistry.

SN1 pathway and carbocation rearrangements

The conversion of secondary alcohols to secondary alkyl halides by HX is an excellent opportunity to bring up the subject of carbocation rearrangements. This falls under the purview of the SN1 pathway. Carbocations are unstable, electron-poor species, and their stability generally increases with the number of attached carbons, which serve to donate electron density.

The basic premise is that if a carbocation can rearrange to give a more stable carbocation, it will. Carbocation rearrangements can happen via either hydride or alkyl shifts, technically referred to as 1,2-hydride or 1,2-alkyl shifts. In the case of a hydride shift, a hydrogen atom with its electrons migrates to the atom with the empty orbital (the carbocation). In an alkyl shift, the entire alkyl group with all of its electrons migrates from one atom to another. While it may seem like the positive charge is moving, it is actually the groups that are shifting around, and the new position of the carbocation is a consequence of that shift.

An example of a favourable rearrangement is when a secondary carbocation is adjacent to an "allylic" or "benzylic" hydrogen. In this case, the rearrangement results in a secondary carbon which is stabilized by resonance. Another example is when there is a secondary alcohol adjacent to a strained ring, such as cyclobutane. Once the secondary carbocation is generated, a bond in the strained ring migrates, leading to expansion of the ring by one. This is particularly favourable in the case of cyclobutane to cyclopentane since cyclobutane is highly strained whereas cyclopentane has minimal ring strain.

It is important to note that SN1 reactions scramble the stereochemistry of anything they touch. For example, if a chiral alkyl halide is used, it is racemized into the corresponding alcohols. Achiral alkyl halides can also produce a pair of diastereomers in SN1 reactions.

Using thionyl chloride to convert alcohols to alkyl chlorides

Thionyl chloride, or SOCl2, is a reagent used to convert alcohols to alkyl halides. This conversion proceeds through an SN2 mechanism, specifically via substitution, in which the hydroxyl group (OH) in the alcohol is replaced by a chlorine atom (Cl) from the thionyl chloride molecule.

The reaction can be broken down into two steps. Firstly, the oxygen atom of the alcohol attacks the sulfur atom in SOCl2, displacing a chloride ion. This converts the alcohol into a good leaving group. Secondly, the chloride ion attacks the carbon atom in an SN2 fashion, resulting in the cleavage of the C-O bond and the formation of the alkyl chloride. The byproduct of this reaction is HCl and sulfur dioxide gas, which bubbles away.

It is important to note that the stereochemistry of the reaction may vary depending on the solvent used. While it is commonly taught that SOCl2 leads to complete inversion of configuration, in reality, it depends on the choice of solvent. Different solvents can result in either straight inversion or a mixture of retention and inversion.

When using thionyl chloride to convert secondary alcohols to alkyl chlorides, the reaction can be taught as a classical SN2 with inversion or through an SNi mechanism with retention. The SNi mechanism is particularly relevant when discussing the conversion of secondary alcohols, as it describes the experimental results more accurately.

Thionyl chloride is a useful reagent in organic synthesis due to its ability to convert alcohols into alkyl halides, which are versatile compounds that can be further transformed into a wide range of products. Additionally, thionyl chloride can also convert carboxylic acids into acid chlorides, expanding its utility in synthetic applications. However, caution must be exercised when handling thionyl chloride due to its pungent and nauseating odour, similar to that of phosgene.

Using hydroxides to convert secondary alkyl halides to alcohols

Alcohols can be converted to alkyl halides by treating them with HCl, HBr, or HI, which fall under the term "HX" where X is a halide. This results in the formation of alkyl halides.

Now, to convert secondary alkyl halides back to alcohols, we can use water (hydrolysis). This is preferred over hydroxides because hydroxides are strong bases and will cause the E2 elimination reaction to predominate. The reaction with water proceeds via an SN1 mechanism because water is a poor nucleophile. The SN1 reaction is a stepwise mechanism that proceeds via a carbocation intermediate. The formation of carbocations indicates the following possibilities:

• If a chiral alkyl halide is used, it is racemized into the corresponding alcohols.
• Whenever possible, a rearrangement will occur. For example, a secondary carbocation may convert into a more stable tertiary carbocation.

It is important to note that the SN1 reaction is generally avoided for secondary alkyl halides if stereochemistry preservation is a concern. This is because the reaction proceeds through a flat carbocation, which can lead to mixtures of stereoisomers.

Additionally, secondary alkyl halides can undergo both SN1 and SN2 reactions. However, using a strong base like the hydroxide ion will favor the E2 elimination reaction. Therefore, if the goal is to convert secondary alkyl halides to alcohols, water is the preferred solvent over hydroxides.

Using water to convert secondary alkyl halides to alcohols

The conversion of secondary alcohols to secondary alkyl halides by HX is an excellent opportunity to bring up the subject of carbocation rearrangements. Carbocations are unstable, electron-poor species, and their stability generally increases with the number of attached carbons, which serve to donate electron density.

In the lab, the treatment of secondary alcohols with HX leads to a mixture of products from SN1 and SN2 pathways. For practical purposes, it is generally not a useful process, especially if you want to preserve stereochemistry.

However, it is important to note that using a hydroxide to convert a secondary alkyl halide to an alcohol is not the best option. This is because they are strong bases, and the E2 elimination predominates. Therefore, the reaction with water (hydrolysis) is preferred. The reaction, in this case, goes via an SN1 mechanism because water is a poor nucleophile.

Recall that the SN1 reaction is a stepwise mechanism that goes via a carbocation intermediate. The formation of carbocations indicates a couple of possibilities:

• If a chiral alkyl halide is used, it is racemized into the corresponding alcohols.
• Whenever possible, a rearrangement will occur.

For example, let's consider the reaction of (R)-2-bromobutane with water. The reason for forming two enantiomers is the planar geometry of the sp2-hybridized carbocation.

Overall, while the conversion of secondary alcohols to alkyl halides can be complex, using water as a solvent through an SN1 mechanism is the preferred method for converting secondary alkyl halides to alcohols.

Frequently asked questions