Cheap Alcohol: Why Hangovers Hurt More

There are many myths surrounding hangovers, such as the order in which you drink different types of alcohol affecting the severity of a hangover, but the only way to completely avoid a hangover is to not drink at all or to keep alcohol intake to a minimum. While there is no scientific evidence to support the claim that higher-quality alcohol will give you less of a hangover, there are some factors that can influence the severity of a hangover. The amount of alcohol consumed is one factor, as drinking to intoxication will almost certainly result in a hangover. Another factor is congeners, which are compounds produced during the fermentation process that can affect the taste and flavour of a drink. Researchers have found links between congeners and worse hangovers, as they may slow down the breakdown of ethanol in the body and trigger stress responses. However, it is important to note that hangovers are highly individual, and the definition and measurement of hangover severity are challenging due to the varied symptoms experienced by different people.

Congeners and their effect on hangovers

Congeners are complex organic molecules produced during the fermentation or distillation process of alcohol. They are byproducts of the process by which sugars are converted into ethanol.

Scientists have found a wide variety of congeners in alcohol, and researchers believe they may be linked to hangovers. Congeners may cause alcohol and its byproducts to remain in the body for longer, contributing to hangover symptoms. They may also stimulate the body to release stress hormones, such as norepinephrine and epinephrine, which can lead to inflammatory responses and fatigue.

The amount of congeners in a drink is thought to be one of the most important factors in determining whether a particular type of alcohol will cause a worse hangover. For example, brandy, which has been shown to cause the most hangover symptoms in one study, typically contains significantly more congeners than vodka, which is less likely to cause sickness.

However, it is important to note that hangovers are complex and can vary greatly from person to person. The only guaranteed way to avoid a hangover is to abstain from drinking or keep alcohol intake to a minimum.

The role of acetaldehyde in hangover intensity

Alcohol metabolism, primarily by the liver, creates the toxic compound acetaldehyde, which is a short-lived byproduct. Acetaldehyde contributes to inflammation in the liver, pancreas, brain, gastrointestinal tract, and other organs. It also contributes to the intensity of a hangover. However, the amount of acetaldehyde produced in the liver during ethanol metabolism far exceeds any amount present in the beverage. Therefore, the impact of acetaldehyde in alcoholic drinks on hangover intensity is negligible.

Acetaldehyde is a normal byproduct of ethanol metabolism. Ethanol is produced during the fermentation process, which involves converting sugars into ethanol using different strains of yeast. However, ethanol is not the only byproduct of fermentation, as other compounds called congeners are also formed. Congeners are present in alcoholic beverages in varying amounts, depending on the original sugar or carbohydrate sources used in production. For example, cereal grains used in beer production and grapes used in wine production can introduce congeners.

Congeners have been linked to worse hangovers. They may affect the body's ability to break down ethanol efficiently, causing alcohol and its byproducts to remain in the body for longer. This can contribute to hangover symptoms. Additionally, congeners may stimulate the release of stress hormones, such as norepinephrine and epinephrine, leading to inflammatory responses that result in fatigue and other hangover symptoms.

While the presence of congeners can influence hangover severity, it is important to note that hangovers are complex and multifaceted. They result from a combination of factors, including alcohol consumption, dehydration, individual differences, and the varied symptoms they produce. Ultimately, the only way to completely avoid a hangover is to abstain from alcohol or drink in moderation.

Alcohol placebo causing hangovers

The idea that higher-quality alcohol leads to less severe hangovers is a myth. While it is true that poorly distilled spirits can contain trace amounts of toxic alcohols like methanol, propanol, and butanol, there is little evidence to support the claim that these substances contribute to or worsen hangovers. Hangovers are caused by the toxic byproducts of alcohol metabolism, the most notable of which is acetaldehyde.

Acetaldehyde is produced in the liver when it breaks down ethanol, the type of alcohol present in all alcoholic beverages. Since the amount of acetaldehyde produced during metabolism far exceeds the amount found in distilled spirits, the type of alcohol you consume is largely irrelevant when it comes to hangovers.

That being said, congeners, which are compounds produced during the fermentation or distillation process, have been linked to worse hangovers. Congeners can affect the body's ability to break down ethanol, causing alcohol and its byproducts to remain in the body for longer. They may also stimulate the release of stress hormones, leading to fatigue and other hangover symptoms. However, it's important to note that hangovers are caused by drinking too much alcohol, regardless of the type of drink.

To test the impact of congeners on hangovers, a study could be designed where a large set of subjects consume either a low-congener drink, a high-congener drink, or a non-alcoholic placebo. By self-reporting their hangover intensity, the subjects could provide insight into whether congeners play a significant role in hangover severity.

In conclusion, while certain congeners may contribute to more severe hangovers, the only way to completely avoid a hangover is to abstain from alcohol or drink in moderation.

Brandy, red wine, and rum causing worse hangovers

It is a common misconception that the quality of alcohol is responsible for the severity of hangovers. While there may be some truth to this, other factors, such as the type of alcohol, the presence of congeners, and individual factors like allergies, also play a significant role.

Brandy, red wine, and rum are often associated with particularly nasty hangovers. This is mainly due to their high levels of congeners, which are chemical byproducts of the fermentation process. Congeners contribute to the flavour and colour of a drink, but they are challenging for the liver to break down, leading to more intense hangover symptoms. Red wine and other dark drinks, including brandy, have higher concentrations of congeners, which may explain why they tend to cause worse hangovers.

Additionally, brandy and red wine contain high levels of fusel alcohol, a type of alcohol that is harder for the body to metabolize, further contributing to the severity of hangovers.

The order in which alcohol is consumed also plays a role. Starting with drinks that have a higher alcohol content, like brandy or rum, and then moving on to beer or lighter drinks, can lead to a worse hangover. This is because the body struggles to process the harder alcohol as efficiently as the night progresses.

Another factor specific to red wine is its high levels of tannins and flavonoid phenolic compounds. These compounds might contribute to the intensity of red wine hangovers, although more research is needed to confirm this.

While there is no definitive answer as to why brandy, red wine, and rum may cause worse hangovers, it is likely a combination of these factors. Individual factors, such as allergies or sensitivities, can also influence the severity of a hangover, making it difficult to pinpoint a single cause.

No cure for hangovers except time

While there are many purported remedies for hangovers, there is no scientifically proven cure for a hangover other than time. The body needs time to clear the toxic byproducts of alcohol metabolism, rehydrate, heal irritated tissue, and restore immune and brain function to normal. Drinking coffee, taking a shower, or having another alcoholic drink the next morning will not cure a hangover. However, over-the-counter pain relievers like ibuprofen can help reduce body aches and headaches, but caution should be exercised as combining alcohol with certain painkillers can be harmful to the liver and stomach.

The severity of a hangover depends on several factors, including the amount of alcohol consumed, the presence of congeners, and individual differences. Congeners are compounds produced during the fermentation or distillation process, and their presence can affect the taste and flavour of the beverage. While ethanol (ethyl alcohol) is the primary byproduct of fermentation, congeners are also formed. The breakdown of congeners in the body can compete with the breakdown of ethanol, causing alcohol and its byproducts to remain in the body for longer, contributing to hangover symptoms. Additionally, congeners may stimulate the release of stress hormones, leading to inflammatory responses and fatigue.

The types of alcoholic beverages consumed can also impact the severity of a hangover. For example, a report in the British Medical Journal found that brandy produced the most hangover symptoms, followed by red wine, rum, whiskey, white wine, gin, and vodka. Inexpensive red wines, in particular, have a reputation for causing sickness, although the specific cause is unknown. Wines from regions with variable climates may contain more hangover-inducing compounds during certain seasons.

While there is no guaranteed way to avoid a hangover, some strategies can help minimise the symptoms. These include drinking in moderation, avoiding drinking on an empty stomach, alternating alcoholic drinks with water to prevent dehydration, and getting plenty of sleep after drinking. Ultimately, the best way to prevent a hangover is to abstain from drinking alcohol or to keep alcohol intake to a minimum.

Frequently asked questions