Alcohol In Food: Safe For Kids?

Many people enjoy cooking with alcohol to enhance the flavour of their dishes. However, when children are involved, it can be tricky to know whether it is safe to serve them food cooked with alcohol. The general consensus is that as long as the dish is cooked correctly and most of the alcohol has been cooked off, it is safe for children to consume. However, there are varying opinions on the matter, with some people preferring to avoid giving their children any food containing alcohol. The amount of alcohol left in a dish depends on various factors, including the cooking method, the strength of the alcohol, and the length of cooking time. It is recommended to simmer or boil dishes containing alcohol for at least 2.5 hours to ensure most of the alcohol has evaporated.

Alcohol in food for kids: safe or not?

Alcohol is often used in cooking to intensify the flavours of a dish. Wine, for example, is commonly used in sauces, stews, and marinades, as well as for deglazing pans. While this can add depth and complexity to the flavour profile, it raises the question of whether it is safe for children to consume these dishes. After all, alcohol has the potential to intoxicate and impair judgement, and its consumption is regulated for a reason. So, what are the facts?

Firstly, it is important to note that the amount of alcohol in a dish after cooking depends on several factors, including the cooking method, the strength of the alcohol, and the cooking time. Alcohol has a lower boiling point than water, so it does not need to be boiled vigorously for it to evaporate. Simmering a dish containing alcohol for a sufficient length of time can significantly reduce the alcohol content. For instance, simmering a pasta sauce with 12% wine for 15 minutes can reduce the alcohol concentration to less than 1%.

However, it is worth mentioning that alcohol does not completely evaporate during cooking, and some will remain in the dish. The longer the cooking time, the more alcohol evaporates, and the lower the alcohol level becomes. According to the USDA, cooking, simmering, or boiling a dish with wine for more than 2.5 hours is necessary to remove most of the alcohol. Additionally, the serving size portion makes a difference. For a child who eats very little, the amount of alcohol consumed would likely be negligible.

While some people may be comfortable with small amounts of alcohol in their children's food, assuming that it is infrequent and harmless, others may prefer to avoid it altogether. It is a personal choice that depends on individual beliefs and comfort levels. For those who wish to avoid it, there are alternatives, such as using non-alcoholic wines or beers, wine vinegar, or other substitutes.

Ultimately, the decision to allow children to consume food containing alcohol rests with the caregivers. Caregivers should consider factors such as the child's age, the amount of alcohol in the dish, and the frequency of consumption. While small amounts of alcohol in cooked dishes are generally not considered harmful, it is essential to use appropriate cooking methods to minimise the alcohol content and prioritise the safety and well-being of the children.

Cooking methods to reduce alcohol content

Alcohol does evaporate without heat, and a significant amount also burns off during the cooking process. However, the amount of alcohol that remains in a dish depends on several factors, such as the cooking method, the cooking time, the size of the pan, and the number of ingredients in the recipe.

To reduce the alcohol content in a dish, one can consider the following cooking methods:

• Long simmering in a wide pan: Simmering a dish for an extended period in a wide pan with a large surface area can effectively reduce alcohol content. This method allows for more alcohol to evaporate compared to baking or cooking in a smaller pan.
• Stirring during cooking: Recipes that involve stirring can promote evaporation and lead to lower alcohol retention.
• Removing the lid: Cooking with the lid off can help release steam and facilitate the evaporation of alcohol.
• Cooking at a high temperature: Cooking at a sufficiently high temperature can ensure that the alcohol burns off.
• Substituting with non-alcoholic beverages: Using non-alcoholic wines, alcohol-removed wines, or non-alcoholic beer can be an alternative to reduce alcohol content.
• Reducing cooking time: Quick cooking methods, such as flambéing, may not burn off all the alcohol, so longer cooking times can be beneficial.

It is worth noting that while these methods can reduce alcohol content, they may not entirely eliminate it. The original amount of alcohol added, the cooking technique, and the duration of cooking all play a role in the final alcohol concentration. Therefore, it is essential to consider these factors when preparing dishes, especially when serving them to children.

Alternatives to alcohol in cooking

Alcohol is often used in cooking to add flavour to dishes. However, there are many reasons why one might want to avoid using alcohol in cooking, such as serving the food to children, or cooking for someone who is in recovery and avoids all alcohol. Here are some alternatives to alcohol in cooking:

Vinegar

Vinegar is a good substitute for wine in cooking, as it is alcohol that has oxidised, giving it a similar flavour to wine. It is best to use a vinegar made from the wine you are replacing, and it may need to be diluted with water or stock. Depending on the wine and the dish, a pinch of sugar may also be needed.

Fruit Juices

Fruit juices are a good non-alcoholic equivalent of wine. Grape juice is a common substitute, but apple juice can be used for white wines, adding a sweet acidity without overpowering the dish. Lemon and lime juices can also be used, adding a subtle flavour.

Chicken or Pork Stocks

Chicken or pork stocks can be used as a replacement for wine, but you may need to use more to get the desired flavour.

Non-alcoholic Beer

Non-alcoholic beer can be used as a substitute for beer in cooking. When being used as a meat tenderiser, root beer or cola can be used.

Alcohol-free Extracts

Alcohol is often used in extracts as a preservative to maintain the aroma and taste of the original ingredient. However, alcohol-free extracts can be used as an alternative. For example, vanilla extract can be used in place of bourbon, and almond extract can be used instead of Amaretto.

Coffee

Coffee can be used as a substitute for coffee liqueurs. Espresso or strong coffee can be used, as well as coffee extract or coffee syrup.

These are just a few examples of alternatives to alcohol in cooking. It is important to note that the substitution may depend on the specific dish and desired flavour profile, so experimentation may be needed.

History of alcohol in children's food

Alcohol has played a significant role in human history, and its consumption, especially in the form of beer and wine, was common for much of this history. This was partly due to the contaminated water supplies, which made alcoholic beverages a safer option. For instance, the Mayflower shipped more beer than water when travelling to the New World in 1620. Alcohol was also an effective source of energy and generally improved the quality of life.

In the Middle Ages, beer and ale were important dietary staples, particularly for the common people, as grain made up a substantial part of their diet. These \"small beers\" were mildly alcoholic but could be consumed in large quantities without causing drunkenness. They were also consumed for their nutritional content. At mealtimes, people of all ages, including children, drank small beer. In the 18th century, small beer continued to be consumed by children, as it was considered safer than water. Erasmus Darwin, in his 1797 publication, wrote that "water is preferable" for robust children, while "small beer" is better for weaker ones.

Historically, children often drank what their parents did, including alcohol, which may have been diluted. In the 16th century, the average consumption of beer and ale in Coventry, England, was about 17 pints per person per week. In the 18th century, large educational institutions like Eton, Winchester, and Oxford University even ran their own breweries.

The production of alcoholic beverages likely has a long history, with evidence suggesting that fermented beverages existed as early as the Neolithic period (around 10,000 BC). The oldest verifiable brewery was found in a cave near Haifa, Israel, with traces of 13,000-year-old wheat and barley-based alcohol believed to be used for ritual feasts.

In the 1920s, a shift occurred, and beverage companies began producing and marketing drinks specifically targeted at children. For example, Edwin Perkins of the Perkins Products Company marketed Kool-Aid, which was advertised in children's magazines and offered gifts in exchange for empty packages.

Cultural perspectives on alcohol in food

Alcohol has been a part of human history for millennia, with the production and consumption of alcoholic beverages dating back to ancient civilizations. Drinking customs vary significantly across cultures, with each society ascribing its own unique set of meanings and values to the act of drinking.

In many Western societies, raising a toast with an alcoholic beverage during celebrations or milestones is commonplace. In contrast, Japanese culture favors the practice of 'nomikai', drinking parties among colleagues or friends, reflecting their communal approach to drinking. Similarly, some Native American societies have historically limited and regulated alcohol consumption through community norms.

Religion also plays a significant role in shaping cultural perspectives on alcohol in food. Many religions, including certain sects of Christianity, prohibit or advise against alcohol consumption. However, other religions, such as the Sufi Bektashi Order, Alevi Jem ceremonies, Shinto, Thelema, Vajrayana Buddhism, Vodou, and the Jewish Kiddush, incorporate the spiritual use of alcohol into their practices.

Cultural norms surrounding alcohol consumption can also influence the perception of drinking in front of children. A study comparing Australia, Finland, and Norway found that Australians were more accepting of drinking in moderation in front of children, while Finns and Norwegians were less supportive. These differences may reflect broader historical and cultural norms, as well as varying expectations of women and men as primary caregivers.

Marketing and advertising strategies also play a role in shaping cultural attitudes toward alcohol. Targeted marketing can influence alcohol consumption within specific communities, and the relationship between discrimination, stigma, and alcohol use is well-established.

Frequently asked questions