Alcohol Vs Alkenes: Higher Oxidation State?

Oxidation and reduction reactions are common in organic chemistry, and they always occur together. Oxidation involves the loss of electrons, while reduction involves the gain of electrons. When a carbon atom loses a bond to hydrogen and gains a bond to another carbon atom or a heteroatom, it is considered an oxidative process. Conversely, when a carbon atom gains a bond to hydrogen and loses a bond to another carbon atom or a heteroatom, it is considered a reductive process. Alcohols and alkenes are functional groups that can be interconverted through the addition or elimination of water. While the conversion of alcohol to alkene involves the oxidation of one carbon atom, another carbon atom is reduced, resulting in no net change in the oxidation state of the molecule. Therefore, the oxidation state of alcohol is not higher than that of alkenes, and they are considered to be in the same oxidation state.

Alkenes are less oxidised than alkynes

This difference in oxidation state also explains why alkenes react better in oxidation reactions than alkynes. The higher the oxidation state, the more reactive the molecule. This is because molecules with higher oxidation states have a greater electron density, which makes them more likely to undergo reactions.

It is important to note that the oxidation state of a molecule can change during a reaction. For example, when an alcohol is dehydrated to form an alkene, one of the two carbons loses a C-H bond and gains a C-C bond, resulting in oxidation. However, the other carbon loses a C-O bond and gains a C-C bond, resulting in a reduction. Overall, there is no change in the oxidation state of the molecule.

In general, oxidation is a thermodynamically more favourable process than reduction due to the higher bond strength of C-O versus C-H. This can be observed in the human body, where sugars (alcohols) are ascending the oxidation ladder to become carbon dioxide, releasing energy in the process.

Oxidation state of alcohols vs alkenes

Oxidation and reduction reactions are common in organic chemistry, and they always occur together. When a carbon atom loses a bond to hydrogen and gains a bond to another carbon atom or a heteroatom, it is considered an oxidative process. This is because hydrogen is the least electronegative element. Conversely, when a carbon atom gains a bond to hydrogen and loses a bond to another carbon atom or a heteroatom, it is considered a reductive process.

Alcohols and alkenes are functional groups that can be interconverted through the addition or elimination of water. When an alcohol is dehydrated to form an alkene, one of the two carbons loses a C-H bond and gains a C-C bond, which is considered an oxidation. However, the other carbon loses a C-O bond and gains a C-C bond, which is considered a reduction. Therefore, the overall oxidation state of the molecule remains unchanged during this interconversion. This is because, in the case of alkenes, one carbon is in an oxidized state, and the other is in a reduced state.

The interconversion between alcohols and alkenes can be further understood by examining the number of bonds to hydrogen atoms. Methane, with four C-H bonds, is highly reduced. Moving up the oxidation scale, we find methanol, followed by formaldehyde, formate, and finally, carbon dioxide at the highly oxidized end. Alkanes are highly reduced, while alcohols and alkenes are one step up on the oxidation scale. This is because alkanes have three C-H bonds, while alcohols and alkenes have two C-H bonds.

It is important to note that the oxidation state of a molecule can be changed through vertical reactions, while horizontal reactions involve the interconversion of functional groups without altering the oxidation state. For example, alkanes can be oxidized to form alkenes, and alkenes can be converted into primary or secondary alcohols. However, the conversion of an alkene to an alcohol does not change the oxidation state of the molecule, as it is a "horizontal" reaction.

Interconversion of alcohols and alkenes

Alcohols and alkenes can be interconverted through the addition or removal of water in a process known as hydration and dehydration, respectively. This process involves the breaking and formation of specific bonds in the molecules. During dehydration, an alcohol molecule loses a hydrogen atom, forming a double bond and resulting in an alkene. On the other hand, hydration of an alkene molecule involves the addition of a proton or acid, leading to the formation of an alcohol. These reactions are influenced by factors such as temperature and the presence of catalysts or other reactants.

The interconversion of alcohols and alkenes can also occur through oxidative dehydroxymethylation, which involves the oxidation of an alcohol to an aldehyde, followed by dehydroformylation to produce an alkene. The selectivity between alkene and alkane products can be influenced by the presence or absence of specific acceptor molecules. Additionally, the type of alcohol, such as primary or secondary, can impact the rate of oxidation during this process.

It is important to note that the oxidation state of a molecule is determined by the number of bonds to hydrogen atoms. While alcohols and alkenes are both one step above alkanes on the oxidation scale, the interconversion between alcohols and alkenes does not always result in a change in oxidation state. This is because the oxidation and reduction processes occurring within the molecule counteract each other, resulting in an overall neutral effect on the molecule's oxidation state.

The reversibility of these reactions has been demonstrated in hydrothermal experiments, where alkanes, alkenes, alcohols, and ketones were found to interconvert under specific temperature and pressure conditions. These experiments contribute to our understanding of the stability and reactivity of these functional groups and provide insights into the mechanisms of hydrothermal organic reactions.

Furthermore, the interconversion of alcohols and alkenes has practical applications, especially in the construction of olefins. Olefins are versatile building blocks for materials and medicines, and the ability to transform alcohols into alkenes through oxidative dehydroxymethylation offers a mild and selective approach to generating these valuable compounds.

Oxidation ladders

For example, alkanes can be oxidized to alkenes, and alkenes can be converted into primary or secondary alcohols. However, the oxidation state of the molecule remains unchanged during this process. This is because when an alcohol is dehydrated to form an alkene, one of the two carbons loses a C-H bond and gains a C-C bond, resulting in oxidation. Conversely, the other carbon loses a C-O bond and gains a C-C bond, resulting in reduction.

The reverse reaction, where an alkene is hydrated to form an alcohol, is also possible. Alcohols can be oxidized "up" to aldehydes, and aldehydes can be reduced "down" to alcohols. This is a crucial process, as sugars (alcohols) in our bodies are oxidized to become carbon dioxide, releasing energy.

Pyridinium chlorochromate (PCC), a milder version of chromic acid, is an example of a reagent that can oxidize primary alcohols to aldehydes and secondary alcohols to ketones. However, PCC cannot oxidize aldehydes to carboxylic acids. "Strong" oxidants, such as chromic acid, can convert primary alcohols to carboxylic acids.

It is important to recognize when an organic molecule is being oxidized or reduced, as this indicates the participation of a corresponding redox agent. Oxidation and reduction always occur in tandem.

Hydrogenation and dehydrogenation

Alcohols and alkenes can be interconverted through the addition or removal of water. When an alcohol is dehydrated to form an alkene, one of the two carbons loses a C-H bond and gains a C-C bond, resulting in oxidation. However, the other carbon loses a C-O bond and gains a C-C bond, resulting in reduction. Therefore, the net change in the oxidation state of the molecule is zero.

Dehydrogenation of alcohols can be achieved through reactions with protic acids, forming alkenes. This process, known as dehydration or dehydrogenation of alcohols, is an example of an elimination reaction. The rate of dehydration varies for primary, secondary, and tertiary alcohols, with tertiary alcohols exhibiting the highest rate due to the stability of the generated carbocation. Dehydrogenation reactions can be endothermic and equilibrated, such as cyclohexane dehydrogenation, and are influenced by temperature and the presence of catalysts.

Catalytic dehydrogenation plays a significant role in the production of olefin light, detergent range, and styrene. For instance, during World War II, butane was dehydrogenated over a chromium-alumina catalyst to produce butenes, which were then hydrogenated to yield high-octane aviation fuels. Dehydrogenation can also be employed for energy storage, particularly with the use of liquid organic hydrogen carriers (LOHCs) that offer high hydrogen content and compatibility with existing fuel infrastructure.

In summary, hydrogenation and dehydrogenation are crucial reactions in organic chemistry and energy storage, facilitating the interconversion of functional groups and enabling the synthesis of various compounds.

Frequently asked questions