Why Is The Acetyl Group More Polar Than Alcohols?

The acetyl group, although polar, cannot form hydrogen bonds, which makes it a good group to attach to a polar molecule and make it non-polar. On the other hand, the hydroxyl group in alcohols is more polar than the acetyl group and can form hydrogen bonds. This makes the hydroxyl group more polar than the acetyl group. This difference in polarity between the acetyl and hydroxyl groups has significant implications in organic chemistry, such as in the conversion of morphine into heroin by replacing hydroxyl groups with acetyl groups.

Acetyl groups cannot form hydrogen bonds

The acetyl group, with the chemical formula C=O, is polar. However, it cannot form hydrogen bonds. This is because hydrogen bonding requires both donation and acceptance of electrons, and while the carbonyl group can accept electron density from an O-H bond, it has no O-H, N-H, or S-H bonds to donate electron density. The C-H bonds of the acetyl group are too nonpolar to act as H-bond donors.

To form a hydrogen bond, you need to have a hydrogen atom bound to a carbon, fluorine, or oxygen atom. This is why ketones and aldehydes cannot form hydrogen bonds—they lack the necessary H-O/F/N groups. On the other hand, acetic acid and amides can form hydrogen bonds because they have these necessary groups.

When an acetyl group is added to a molecule, the oxygen bound to carbon can act as a hydrogen bond acceptor, but only if there are H-O/F/N groups present in the mixture. This makes acetyl groups useful for making polar molecules non-polar or lipophilic. For example, morphine is hydrophilic due to its hydroxyl groups. Replacing these with acetyl groups makes the molecule more lipophilic because the acetylated structure cannot form hydrogen bonds, despite having a polar C=O bond.

Intramolecular hydrogen bonding involving acetyl groups has been observed in certain compounds, such as 1,3,5-triacetyl-2,4,6-trihydroxybenzene and related compounds. In these cases, factors such as steric compression and concerted bond localization of the aromatic ring due to hydrogen bonding contribute to the formation of strong hydrogen bonds. Additionally, in compounds like 1-acetyl-3,5-dinitro-2,4,6-trihydroxybenzene, an unusual hydrogen bond pattern is observed where two OH groups form hydrogen bonds with the same nitro group.

The hydroxyl group is more polar than the carbonyl group

The hydroxyl group (-OH) is considered more polar than the carbonyl group (C=O). This is due to the presence of both H-bond donors and acceptors in hydroxyl groups. The hydroxyl group donates electrons to the ring, making them ortho-para directing, which increases their polarity.

Hydroxyl groups are found in alcohols, which are polar due to the high polarity of the O-H bond. This bond is also responsible for the ability of alcohols to participate in hydrogen bonding. The carbonyl group, on the other hand, cannot form hydrogen bonds despite being polar. This is because, while the carbonyl group can accept electron density from an O-H bond, it lacks O-H, N-H, or S-H bonds to donate electron density.

The acetyl group, which contains the C=O bond, is an example of a carbonyl group. Although polar, it cannot undergo hydrogen bonding due to the absence of the necessary functional groups. The C-H bonds in the acetyl group are also nonpolar and cannot act as H-bond donors.

Morphine, for example, is hydrophilic due to its hydroxyl groups. Replacing these hydroxyl groups with acetyl groups would increase the molecule's lipophilicity, as the acetyl group can be attached to a polar molecule, effectively making it more lipophilic.

In summary, the hydroxyl group is more polar than the carbonyl group due to its ability to participate in hydrogen bonding and its electron-donating nature, which increases the electron density at ortho and para positions.

Hydrogen bonding requires both donation and acceptance

The acetyl group, although polar, cannot form hydrogen bonds. This is because, to form an H-bond, you need to have a hydrogen atom bound to a carbon, oxygen, or fluorine atom. The C-H bonds of the acetyl group are too nonpolar to act as H-bond donors.

On the other hand, hydroxyl groups, which are found in alcohols, are capable of hydrogen bonding. This is because the hydroxyl group has a hydrogen atom bonded to an oxygen atom, which is one of the requirements for hydrogen bonding.

The presence of two hydrogen bonding functions in a compound raises the boiling point. This is because hydrogen bonding creates stronger intermolecular forces, which increase the boiling point.

Acetyl groups are more lipophilic than hydroxyl groups

The acetyl group has a C=O bond, which is polar due to the difference in electronegativity between carbon and oxygen. Oxygen is more electronegative than carbon, resulting in a partial positive charge on the carbon atom. However, the C=O bond is shorter than the O-H bond in hydroxyl groups, and the electronegativity difference between hydrogen and oxygen is greater than that between carbon and oxygen. This makes the O-H bond in hydroxyl groups more polar and better able to participate in hydrogen bonding.

Hydrogen bonding is a type of electrostatic attraction that requires both donation and acceptance of electrons. In hydroxyl groups, the oxygen atom can act as an electron donor and acceptor due to its high electronegativity. The hydroxyl group can form strong hydrogen bonds with other molecules, making it more hydrophilic than the acetyl group.

The inability of the acetyl group to form hydrogen bonds makes it a good candidate for attaching to polar molecules, effectively making those molecules more lipophilic. This is because the acetyl group can provide some polarity without the ability to hydrogen bond, which is a stronger intermolecular force. By replacing hydroxyl groups with acetyl groups, the overall polarity and ability to hydrogen bond can be reduced, increasing the lipophilicity of the molecule.

Additionally, acetyl groups have C-H bonds that are nonpolar and cannot act as hydrogen bond donors. These C-H bonds are highly covalent and are characteristic of alkanes, which are very non-polar and do not mix with water. The nonpolarity of the C-H bonds in acetyl groups contributes to their overall lipophilic nature compared to hydroxyl groups.

The hydroxyl group increases water solubility

The acetyl group (C=O) is polar, but it cannot form hydrogen bonds. This is because, although the carbonyl group can accept electron density from an O-H bond, it has no O-H, N-H, or S-H bonds to donate electron density. The C-H bonds in the acetyl group are too nonpolar to act as H-bond donors.

On the other hand, hydroxyl groups (-OH) are more polar than C=O due to the presence of both H-bond donors and acceptors. The O-H bond is highly polarized and participates in hydrogen bonding.

Hydroxyl groups increase water solubility. This is because polar compounds tend to dissolve in water. The hydroxyl group's ability to participate in hydrogen bonding increases solubility. For example, common sugars, which are polyalcohols with multiple hydroxyl groups, are very soluble in water due to the formation of hydrogen bonds with water molecules.

The addition of hydroxyl groups increases the solubility of a hydrocarbon in water. As the length of the non-polar hydrocarbon chain increases, solubility decreases. However, with more hydroxyl groups, there are more possible interactions with water, increasing solubility. For instance, hexanediol, with two hydroxyl groups, is more soluble than hexanol, which has one hydroxyl group.

Frequently asked questions