Alcohol In Cooking: Safe For Kids?

Many people enjoy cooking with alcohol to enhance the flavor of their dishes. However, when it comes to feeding these dishes to children, concerns about the safety of consuming residual alcohol arise. While some believe that cooking completely burns off the alcohol, leaving only the flavor behind, others argue that it is impossible to know if all the alcohol has evaporated. This uncertainty, along with varying cultural norms regarding adolescent alcohol consumption, leaves parents questioning whether it is appropriate to serve their children food prepared with alcohol.

Alcohol in food: safe for kids?

Alcohol is often used in cooking to intensify the flavour of a dish. However, when it comes to cooking for children, many parents are unsure if it is safe to include alcohol in the recipes. So, is it safe for kids to consume food cooked with alcohol?

The answer is, it depends. While cooking with alcohol can enhance the flavour of a dish, it is important to exercise caution when serving these dishes to children. Alcohol does evaporate at a lower temperature than water, and a significant amount of alcohol will burn off during the cooking process, especially if the dish is cooked for a long time after the alcohol is added. However, it is impossible to know exactly how much alcohol has evaporated and if all of it has been removed. A Danish study found that there was still alcohol left over in each dish they tested. The amount of alcohol that remains depends on various factors, including the type of food, the temperature, the amount of alcohol added, and the cooking time.

To ensure that most of the alcohol burns off, it is recommended to reduce it alone in a pot by 50-75% before adding it to the dish. If added directly to a larger amount of liquid, much less will evaporate. It is also important to note that certain ingredients, such as vanilla extract, contain high levels of alcohol, so it is important to be mindful of these when cooking for children.

While some parents may be comfortable with their children consuming trace amounts of alcohol in food, others may prefer to avoid it altogether. If you are concerned about the alcohol content in a dish, there are a few alternatives you can consider. You can substitute alcohol with alcohol-free wine, fruit juice, broth, or other suitable alternatives. You can also set aside a portion of the dish before adding the alcohol and serve that to your child.

In conclusion, while cooking with alcohol can add flavour to a dish, it is important to be mindful of the alcohol content when serving these dishes to children. It is recommended to let the dish cook for a sufficient amount of time after adding the alcohol to ensure most of it burns off, or to use alcohol-free alternatives if you are unsure.

How much alcohol is left in food after cooking?

It is a common misconception that alcohol completely evaporates or dissipates during the cooking process. However, this is not entirely true, and the amount of alcohol that remains in a dish depends on various factors. Firstly, the type of alcohol used matters; different alcohols have different alcohol by volume (ABV) percentages. For example, beer typically has an ABV range of 3.5% to 9%, while rum usually falls between 40% and 75.5%. Therefore, a dish cooked with rum will generally have a higher alcohol content than one made with beer, assuming all other factors are equal.

The heat and surface area also play a role in how much alcohol evaporates. Higher temperatures and a larger surface area will result in more alcohol burning off. According to Harold McGee, author of 'On Food and Cooking: The Science and Lore of the Kitchen', alcohol is a volatile substance that evaporates not only when it reaches its boiling point but also whenever it is exposed to air. This means that the longer the cooking time, the more alcohol will evaporate. A study by the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Nutrient Data Lab found that food cooked in alcohol for 15 minutes retains 40% of the alcohol, while after an hour, 25% remains, and even after two and a half hours, there is still 5% alcohol present.

It is important to note that while the amount of alcohol left after cooking is usually negligible, it is technically impossible to remove all traces of alcohol from a dish unless it is cooked for an extremely long time, well beyond standard recipe requirements. For instance, one source mentions that it takes about 2.5 hours of cooking to completely remove alcohol, which is far longer than typical cooking times. Another source provides a helpful rule of thumb: for every 30 minutes of cooking, the alcohol content decreases by 10%.

Therefore, while cooking with alcohol does reduce its concentration, it is important to consider the various factors at play and use your discretion when serving such dishes to children or individuals who abstain from alcohol for any reason.

Alcohol-free alternatives

It is important to note that there is no specific amount of ethanol (alcohol) that is considered safe for children, and the old adage that alcohol "burns off" when cooking food containing alcohol is only partially true. The amount of alcohol remaining depends on various factors, such as the quantity used, the cooking method, and the duration of cooking. Thus, it is always better to be cautious and opt for alcohol-free alternatives when cooking for kids.

Alcohol-free wines, beers, and apple ciders can be excellent substitutes in cooking, adding flavour and depth to sauces, casseroles, and stews. De-alcoholised wines retain many qualities of the original wine and have more texture than fruit juice. When choosing an alcohol-free wine, opt for a product where the alcohol has already been removed, rather than a dealcoholised wine, which may still contain a small amount of alcohol. Alcohol-free spirits, such as Seedlip, are also becoming increasingly popular.

If you are looking for a substitute for white wine, grape juice is a natural choice, but you can also use pomegranate, cranberry, or lemon juice. To balance the sweetness, consider adding a splash of vinegar. For red wine, tomato juice, or coffee with a touch of honey or sugar, can be a good alternative. Chicken broth can be used as a lighter substitute for white wine, while beef broth can replace red wine in sauces, soups, or braises.

In recipes that call for beer, such as a British beef stew, chicken stock is a suitable alternative. For beer-battered recipes, sparkling water can be used instead of beer to provide the necessary carbonation.

The role of wine in cooking

Wine is a versatile ingredient that can enhance the flavour and aroma of a dish. It can be used in marinades, as an ingredient in sauces or stews, or as a base for desserts. Wine also has a tenderising effect on meat, keeping it moist during cooking.

The type of wine used in cooking is important. Generally, dry red and white wines are recommended for savoury dishes. Lighter wines, such as Pinot Grigio, are better suited for seafood dishes, while a full-bodied Chardonnay might be used in a coq au vin blanc or a beurre blanc sauce. Sweeter wines, such as Riesling, can be used for desserts or to poach fruit. When choosing a wine for cooking, it is best to avoid "cooking wines", which are often loaded with preservatives, salt, and sweeteners, and can negatively impact the flavour of the dish. Instead, it is recommended to cook with a wine that you would also be happy to drink. However, it is not necessary to use an expensive wine, as many of the subtle characteristics of a fine wine will burn off during cooking.

It is worth noting that while cooking with wine can enhance flavour and aroma, the alcohol in wine does not completely evaporate during the cooking process. The amount of alcohol that remains will depend on factors such as the cooking time and method. Therefore, when considering whether it is appropriate for children to consume dishes cooked with wine, it is important to recognise that some alcohol content may remain. While cultural attitudes towards adolescent alcohol consumption vary, healthcare professionals advise against assuming that even small amounts of alcohol are safe for children.

Other sources of alcohol in children's diets

Alcohol is a dangerous poison for children. It depresses the central nervous system and causes low blood glucose (sugar). Children who consume alcohol may stagger when they walk, slur their speech, seem sleepy, and vomit. Their breathing and heart rate may slow down to a dangerous level, and they may pass out and even die. Even small amounts of alcohol can harm children.

There are other sources of alcohol that children may unknowingly come into contact with besides beverage alcohol, such as ethanol, which is found in beer, wine, and liquor. Ethanol is also present in mouthwash, facial cleansers, hair products, hand sanitizers, and some cosmetics and cleansers. Vanilla extract, which is commonly used in baking, contains 35% alcohol. It is important to supervise children's access to these products and to educate them about the dangers of alcohol consumption.

The amount of alcohol that is poisonous to a child can vary depending on their age and weight. Even small amounts of alcohol can be harmful to children, and it is essential to seek medical help if a child has consumed alcohol. Locking up alcoholic beverages and storing mouthwash and other alcohol-containing products out of sight and reach can help prevent accidental ingestion.

Parents play a crucial role in influencing their children's attitudes and behaviors towards alcohol. It is recommended that parents set a good example by drinking responsibly or not at all, being active, and eating healthily. Regular and honest conversations about alcohol with children as they grow up can help them make informed decisions and understand the risks associated with alcohol consumption.

Frequently asked questions