Bagging Alcohol: New York's Unique State Law

Alcohol laws in New York State are a set of laws specific to manufacturing, purchasing, serving, selling, and consuming alcohol in the state. While New York State laws do not require alcoholic beverages to be packaged in a bag when taken out of a retail store, there are other laws that govern the sale and consumption of alcohol. For example, the Open Container Law prohibits having an alcoholic beverage in an open container in public, and New York City has a law against drinking in public. The state also has laws prohibiting the sale of alcohol to minors and intoxicated individuals, and establishments can be held liable for harm caused by intoxicated patrons.

New York is a licensing state, not a control state

New York has a complex set of laws governing the manufacture, purchase, serving, sale, and consumption of alcohol. These laws are designed to protect the health, welfare, and safety of the people of the state. While New York has strict regulations regarding alcohol, it is not a control state.

In the United States, states typically regulate the manufacture and sale of alcoholic beverages as either "licensing states" or "control states." A licensing state, like New York, issues licenses to entities that manufacture and sell alcoholic beverages. The New York State Liquor Authority (NYSLA) and its agency arm, the Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control (DABC), regulate the industry and enforce the Alcoholic Beverage Control Law (ABC Law). This law was established in 1934 to regulate and control the manufacture and distribution of alcoholic beverages within the state, promoting temperance and obedience to the law.

On the other hand, control states are directly involved in the distribution of alcoholic beverages. They often have a monopoly over the wholesale or retail sale of some or all categories of alcoholic drinks. While New York exerts significant control over the alcohol industry through licensing and regulation, it does not fall into the category of a control state.

The distinction between a licensing state and a control state is important because it determines the level of government involvement in the alcohol industry. In a licensing state like New York, the government's role is primarily regulatory, ensuring compliance with laws and promoting responsible consumption. Control states, however, have a more direct role in the distribution and sale of alcoholic beverages, giving them greater control over the industry.

New York's status as a licensing state means that the state government does not have a monopoly on the sale of alcohol. Instead, it relies on licensing and regulation to control the industry. This approach allows for a diverse market with a wide range of alcohol manufacturers, distributors, and retailers. While the state sets the legal framework, the industry operates within this framework with a degree of independence.

In conclusion, while New York has comprehensive alcohol laws and strong regulatory bodies, it is a licensing state rather than a control state. This distinction reflects the state's approach to managing the alcohol industry, prioritizing licensing and regulation over direct government involvement in distribution and sales.

The legal drinking age in New York is 21

Alcohol laws in New York are a set of laws specific to manufacturing, purchasing, serving, selling, and consuming alcohol in the state. The New York State Liquor Authority (NYSLA) and its agency arm, the Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control (DABC), were established under New York State Law in 1934 to regulate and control the manufacture and distribution of alcoholic beverages within the state.

New York has strict laws regarding drinking in public. The Open Container Law prohibits having an alcoholic beverage in an open container in public, with fines of $25 and potential jail time of up to 5 days. Drinking in public was outlawed in New York City in 1979, and similar laws have since spread to other municipalities.

New York also has strict laws regarding driving under the influence of alcohol. The maximum blood alcohol level for driving is 0.08% for those over 16, with a zero tolerance policy for those under 16. Minors caught with any alcohol in the blood are subject to license revocation for at least six months. Driving under the influence is a crime in New York and is subject to various regulations and penalties, including fines, license suspension, and possible imprisonment.

There is no law requiring alcohol to be bagged

Alcohol laws in New York are a set of laws specific to manufacturing, purchasing, serving, selling, and consuming alcohol in the state. New York is a licensing state, meaning it issues licenses to entities that manufacture and sell alcoholic beverages. The New York State Liquor Authority (NYSLA) and its agency arm, the Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control (DABC), were established under New York State Law in 1934 to regulate and control the manufacture and distribution of alcoholic beverages in the state.

The Alcoholic Beverage Control Law (ABC Law) is a set of policies regarding alcoholic beverages in New York State. The ABC Law was enacted for the "protection, health, welfare, and safety of the people of the state." It gives the DABC administrative jurisdiction over the manufacture and sale of alcoholic beverages, and the DABC is part of the Executive Department.

While the ABC Law regulates the sale of alcohol, there is no provision that requires a grocery store licensed to sell beer or a retail package liquor store to place a purchased alcoholic beverage item into a bag. This was confirmed by Leslie W. Trebby, an associate attorney in the NYSLA's Office of Counsel.

However, it is worth noting that New York has an Open Container Law, which prohibits individuals from having an alcoholic beverage in an open container in public. This law applies to both Long Islanders and New York City residents, and the fine for violating it in New York City is $25, with a potential jail sentence of up to 5 days. Many people believe that putting their alcoholic beverage in a brown bag will shield them from this law, but this is not the case. If a police officer has a reasonable suspicion that an individual has an open container of alcohol in a brown bag, the individual could still be in violation of the law.

Drinking in public is illegal in NYC

Drinking in public is illegal in New York City, and has been since 1979 when it was outlawed by Ed Koch. This law was pitched as targeting antisocial individuals who were drinking in parks and on sidewalks. The Open Container Law prohibits anyone from having an alcoholic beverage in an open container in public. This applies to both Long Island and New York City residents, who may be given a criminal summons if they break this law. The fine for violating the Open Container Law in New York City is $25, but there is also the possibility of jail time, with a maximum sentence of 5 days.

Despite the law, some people still drink in public in NYC. One Tripadvisor user reported seeing a pair of tourists drinking in public, who were advised by police officers to "put it away". The officers did not confiscate the alcohol or issue a ticket, but they were within their rights to do so. In crowded places like the Great Lawn or Sheep Meadow, police officers have been known to patrol specifically looking for bottles and issue tickets on the spot.

There is no requirement for alcoholic beverages to be packaged in a bag when purchased from a retail store for off-site consumption. However, if a restaurant has a license to sell wine and a customer has purchased and consumed a bottle of wine with a meal, they may take the leftover wine home with them. The bottle must be resealed and placed in a securely sealed transparent bag, along with a dated receipt.

While drinking in public is illegal in NYC, there are many outdoor spaces such as sidewalk seating, cafes, beer gardens, and event spaces where alcohol can be purchased and consumed on the premises.

Dry counties are prohibited by state law

Dry counties, or towns that have banned the sale of alcohol, are prohibited by state law in New York. However, individual cities and towns may choose to be dry, with the decision binding on any villages within them. This means that while New York State law does not allow for entire counties to be dry, individual towns within a county can be.

As of 2024, there are six dry towns in the state, all in lightly populated rural areas upstate, including Lapeer in Cortland County. Ten towns forbid on-premises consumption but allow off-premises purchases, while four allow both only at a hotel open all year round. Seventeen towns disallow only special on-premises consumption, such as the town of Spencer in Tioga County. Williamson, in Wayne County, bans on-premises sale of beer at race tracks, outdoor athletic fields, and sports stadiums where admission is charged.

The Alcohol Beverage Control Law (ABC Law) in New York regulates the manufacture, sale, and distribution of alcoholic beverages within the state. The ABC Law was enacted in 1934 to "foster and promote temperance in their consumption and respect for and obedience to law." The New York State Liquor Authority (NYSLA) and its agency arm, the Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control (DABC), were established under the ABC Law to regulate and control the alcoholic beverage industry in the state.

While New York State law prohibits dry counties, it specifically allows cities and towns to exercise a local option by public referendum to decide whether to go dry. This means that while the state does not allow entire counties to be dry, it gives individual municipalities the power to choose whether to allow the sale of alcohol within their jurisdiction.

There is currently legislation being considered in the state legislature that would prohibit municipalities from banning alcohol sales, effectively eliminating all current and future dry communities in New York State. Proponents of the bill argue that it would "broaden consumer choice, spur new business, and integrate outlier municipalities with the rest of the state in relation to the permitted sale of alcohol." Critics of the bill argue that it is a local issue and that small towns should be able to make their own decisions regarding the sale of alcohol in their communities.

Frequently asked questions