Illegal Alcohol: America's Dark Underbelly

Alcohol consumption has been a contentious topic in the United States since the colonial period. The country has a long history of attempting to control alcohol consumption, including through Prohibition in the early 20th century, which made the manufacture, importation, sale, and transport of alcohol illegal. Despite these efforts, illegal alcohol remains a significant issue in the US, with high rates of alcohol abuse, underage drinking, and alcohol-related deaths. The country also has a high prevalence of alcohol use disorder (AUD), with about 15 million adults struggling with the disorder, and excessive alcohol use is estimated to cost the country $249 billion annually.

The historical context of Prohibition in the US

As the temperance movement grew, so too did the push for prohibition. In the 1916 presidential election, neither the Democratic incumbent Woodrow Wilson nor the Republican candidate Charles Evans Hughes addressed the issue, as both parties had strong factions both for and against prohibition. However, when the 65th Congress convened in March 1917, the "dries" (those in favor of prohibition) outnumbered the "wets" in both parties. With America's entry into World War I in April 1917, German Americans, a significant force against prohibition, were sidelined, and a new justification for prohibition emerged: prohibiting alcohol production would free up resources, especially grain, for the war effort.

The Eighteenth Amendment, which enabled prohibition, was passed in 1919 with strong majorities in both the House of Representatives and the Senate and was ratified by 46 out of 48 states. The Volstead Act set the rules for enforcing the federal ban and defined prohibited alcoholic beverages, allowing some exceptions for religious use and home production of wine and cider. While the manufacture, importation, sale, and transport of alcohol were banned, private ownership and consumption were not prohibited under federal law, although local laws varied.

Prohibition had a significant impact on American society, although its overall effects are disputed. Some research suggests alcohol consumption declined, while other studies indicate that Americans found loopholes and illegal means to continue drinking, leading to the emergence of black markets and organised crime syndicates. Prohibition also negatively impacted the economy by eliminating jobs in the alcohol industry and reducing tax revenue. By the late 1920s, opposition to Prohibition grew, and it was eventually repealed by the Twenty-first Amendment in 1933.

The health implications of illegal alcohol consumption

Alcohol consumption, even at low levels, can carry health risks. However, most alcohol-related harm comes from heavy episodic or continuous drinking. Alcohol is a psychoactive and toxic substance with dependence-producing properties. Excessive alcohol use can have immediate and long-term health impacts, including liver disease, high blood pressure, alcohol use disorder, and injuries such as motor vehicle crashes, falls, drownings, and burns. It can also lead to violence, including homicide, suicide, sexual violence, and intimate partner violence. Alcohol poisoning is also a risk, where high blood alcohol levels affect vital body functions like breathing and heart rate.

Excessive alcohol use is a significant public health problem in the United States, causing about 178,000 deaths annually and reducing the lives of those affected by an average of 24 years. It also imposes economic costs, with a reported $249 billion in 2010. Binge drinking, heavy drinking, underage drinking, and drinking during pregnancy are all forms of excessive alcohol consumption that can negatively impact health.

Underage drinking and drinking during pregnancy can have severe consequences for the developing fetus, including fetal alcohol spectrum disorders (FASDs). FASDs are a group of conditions that can cause physical, behavioral, and intellectual disabilities in children. Additionally, excessive alcohol use increases the risk of developing non-communicable diseases, including liver disease, heart disease, and various types of cancer, such as breast, liver, head and neck, oesophageal, and colorectal cancers.

Alcohol consumption also impacts mental health and can lead to or exacerbate conditions such as depression and anxiety. It is essential to note that the risk of alcohol-related harm depends on several factors, including the amount consumed, drinking frequency, individual health status, age, sex, and personal characteristics. While illegal alcohol consumption specifically may be challenging to track, any alcohol consumption, regardless of legality, carries these inherent health risks.

The economic impact of illegal alcohol

Alcohol consumption has had a contentious history in the United States, with the Eighteenth Amendment of 1919 prohibiting the manufacture, importation, sale, and transport of alcohol. This amendment had a significant economic impact, with the closure of distilleries, breweries, and liquor stores, and a subsequent loss of jobs and tax revenue. The emergence of black markets and crime syndicates dedicated to distributing alcohol also contributed to the economic burden.

The economic effects of alcohol abuse are far-reaching and damaging to the nation, affecting families, communities, and individuals of all ages. The healthcare costs for families with an alcoholic member are twice as high as those without, and alcohol abuse contributes to high healthcare costs for the elderly. Alcohol abuse and alcoholism were estimated to cost the US $117 billion in 1983, with projected costs of $136 billion annually by 1990, mainly from lost productivity and employment. Alcohol abuse also interferes with children's development, impacting the nation's future economic prospects.

Excessive alcohol use is associated with an economic cost, which was estimated at $249 billion in 2010. This includes costs related to lost productivity, criminal justice, and healthcare. Alcohol taxes can be used to reduce consumption and raise revenue, but the impact of alcohol consumption goes beyond economics, with substantial social consequences. Alcohol outlet density, or the concentration of alcohol retailers, is associated with excessive alcohol use and related harms, including injuries and violence.

The economic impact of alcohol consumption has been studied worldwide, with the World Health Organization's global status report on alcohol contributing to the growing body of research. These studies provide evidence to support policies aimed at reducing alcohol-related harm. The economic burden of alcohol consumption is substantial, accounting for 0.45% to 5.44% of GDP. This burden is felt not only by individual drinkers but also by society as a whole.

The social effects of illegal alcohol consumption

Alcohol consumption has had a contentious history in the United States, with the Eighteenth Amendment, which was ratified by 46 out of 48 states, prohibiting the manufacture, importation, sale, and transport of alcohol. While the amendment did not prohibit the consumption of alcohol, it led to the emergence of black markets and crime syndicates dedicated to distributing alcohol.

Today, excessive alcohol use continues to have significant social effects in the United States. Firstly, it can lead to social problems within families and communities. Research has shown that alcohol misuse can have consequences not only for the individual but also for their family, friends, and society at large. Alcohol can increase aggression and impair information processing, leading to social responses that are more extreme or excessive. This can result in issues such as family problems, relationship issues, and conflicts within communities.

Secondly, excessive alcohol use can impact work and economic productivity. Alcohol-related absenteeism and reduced productivity in the workplace can have economic costs for individuals, businesses, and society as a whole. In the United States, the economic costs of excessive alcohol use were estimated at $223.5 billion in 2006, with much of this resulting from lost workplace productivity.

Thirdly, alcohol consumption is associated with increased injuries and violence. Greater alcohol outlet density, or the concentration of alcohol retailers in an area, has been linked to excessive alcohol use and related harms, including injuries and violence. This can have a detrimental impact on community safety and social cohesion.

Finally, excessive alcohol use can contribute to unemployment and financial problems. Alcohol consumption can affect an individual's ability to maintain stable employment, leading to financial instability and potential social issues such as homelessness and social marginalization.

Overall, the social effects of illegal alcohol consumption are complex and far-reaching, impacting not only the individual but also their families, communities, and society as a whole. While the specific dynamics may have evolved since the era of Prohibition, the social consequences of illegal alcohol consumption continue to pose challenges in the United States.

The legal status of alcohol in the US today

Today, alcohol is legal in the US, but there are strict regulations surrounding its production, sale, and consumption. For example, the production of distilled alcohols is regulated at the national level, and it is subject to an excise tax. Owning or operating a distillation apparatus without the proper paperwork and taxes can result in federal criminal penalties.

At the state level, there is variation in the specific laws, but some common themes include the minimum legal drinking age of 21, which is enforced in all 50 states and Washington D.C. since the enactment of the National Minimum Drinking Age Act of 1984. States may also regulate the number and concentration of alcohol retailers, with greater outlet density associated with excessive alcohol use and related harms. Additionally, states may limit the days or hours that alcohol can be sold or served.

Local laws can also come into play, with some localities regulating the number of outlets or their hours of operation. Furthermore, commercial host liability laws hold alcohol retailers liable for injuries or harm caused by illegal service to intoxicated or underage customers.

While Prohibition ended in 1933, its legacy continues to influence alcohol policies in the US. The issue of alcohol consumption remains contentious, with excessive alcohol use causing approximately 178,000 deaths annually and imposing significant economic costs. As such, policies aimed at reducing alcohol availability and accessibility, such as increasing taxes and regulating outlets, are recommended by the Community Preventive Services Task Force.

Frequently asked questions