Fountain Pen Ink Vs Alcohol Ink: What's The Difference?

Fountain pen inks differ from one another, and they are not the same as alcohol ink. Fountain pen inks can be described as wet or dry, referring to an ink's flow and how quickly it comes out of a nib. Wet inks feel smoother to write with, whereas dry inks are better for ordinary copy paper and offer faster drying times. Fountain pen inks can be pigment-based or dye-based, and they should not be substituted with inks meant for dip pens or calligraphy, such as India Ink or Lawyer's Ink, as these can clog or damage fountain pens.

Fountain pen inks are not interchangeable with calligraphy or dip pen inks

Fountain pen inks are designed to be used with fountain pens, and calligraphy or dip pen inks are designed for their respective tools. Calligraphy ink is thicker and pigment-based, while fountain pen ink is dye-based and has no solid matter, so it doesn't clog up the pen. If you put calligraphy ink in a fountain pen, it will clog the feed.

The two types of pens and inks differ in many ways. Dip pens are fussier than fountain pens, requiring the user to hold the pen a certain way, adjust the viscosity of the inks, and choose the right nib for the project. Fountain pens, on the other hand, offer convenience and come in a variety of colours, allowing users to personalise their writing experience.

Fountain pen inks can be considered "wet" or "dry", referring to an ink's flow or how quickly the ink comes out of a nib. A wet ink feels smoother to write with and can make lines appear thicker, while a dry ink is better for ordinary copy paper and offers faster drying times, making it ideal for left-handed writers as it reduces the chance of smudging.

While some inks can be mixed with other inks from the same line, mixing inks can be risky. Inks are chemically complex, and incompatible inks can react to form gases and sediments that can clog or damage a pen.

Fountain pen inks can be described as wet or dry, referring to their flow

Fountain pen inks differ from alcohol inks. The former should not be substituted with inks intended for calligraphy, drawing, or inkjet printing as they contain resins and other binders that will not flow properly through fountain pen feeds. Fountain pen inks are also not the same as alcohol inks, as the latter are typically used for painting and creating art.

On the other hand, dry inks have a more conservative flow, making them a good choice for ordinary copy paper. They dry faster, reducing the chances of smudging, which is ideal for left-handed writers. Dry inks are also preferable for flex or stub nibs that put down a lot of ink at once.

The wetness or dryness of an ink can be adjusted by diluting it with water. Adding water to the ink can improve its flow and lighten its color, while also extending the lifespan of the ink bottle. However, it is important to note that highly saturated inks may require longer drying times, even on fountain pen-friendly paper. Therefore, users should experiment with different ink-to-water ratios to find their preferred consistency.

Some popular wet inks include Pilot Iroshizuku Yama-Budo, a smooth-flowing pinkish hue, and Diamine Autumn Oak, a rich autumnal orange that shades well with any nib size. In contrast, Herbin Vert Empire is a dry ink with a delightful muted green tone and a flow that works well on all types of paper. Pelikan 4001 inks are another dry ink option that won't spread greatly when writing.

Dye-based inks are the most common type of fountain pen ink

Fountain pen inks differ from each other and from other inks in several ways. They can be described as "wet" or "dry", referring to how quickly the ink flows out of the nib. Wet inks feel smoother to write with and are ideal for pens that need more ink to make consistent marks, such as calligraphy pens. Dry inks are better suited for ordinary copy paper and offer faster drying times, making them a good choice for left-handed writers.

Fountain pen inks also come in a wide range of colours, allowing users to personalize their writing experience. Inks can be mixed to create new colours, but this should be done carefully as incompatible inks can react to form gases and sediments that can clog or damage the pen.

Other types of fountain pen inks include pigment-based, iron-gall, and bulletproof inks. Pigment-based inks consist of fine solid particles of colourants mixed with water, but the colourants are not water-soluble, so they require regular pen cleaning to prevent clogging. Iron-gall inks will corrode a pen's metallic innards if left inside too long, so they should only be used in a fountain pen that is regularly used and cleaned. Bulletproof inks are also dye-based but achieve waterproofness by binding with the paper's cellulose fibres, combining the benefits of pigment-based and dye-based inks.

Pigment-based inks are less common and require more maintenance

Fountain pen inks differ from alcohol inks in several ways. Firstly, fountain pen inks can be considered ""wet" or "dry", referring to the ink's flow rate and how quickly it comes out of the nib. Wet inks flow more smoothly and produce thicker lines, while dry inks are better suited for ordinary copy paper and dry faster, making them a good choice for left-handed writers to prevent smudging. Fountain pen inks also come in a wide range of colours, allowing for a personalised writing experience.

In contrast, alcohol inks are typically made with a dye or pigment base and a high concentration of alcohol. They are known for their bright, vibrant colours and are often used in art and craft projects. Unlike fountain pen inks, alcohol inks are not designed for writing or everyday use.

Now, let's focus on the statement, "Pigment-based inks are less common and require more maintenance."

Pigment-based inks, such as those used in certain inkjet printers, are indeed less commonly used than dye-based inks. This is partly because pigment inks are often more expensive and may require a machine with more colours to print. Additionally, pigment inks have a narrower colour gamut, resulting in lighter colours that are not as vibrant as those produced by dye inks.

However, pigment inks offer superior UV resistance and are highly water-resistant. They are known for their exceptional lightfastness, durability, and long-lasting quality, making them ideal for applications where labels need to withstand many years of indoor use or up to two years of outdoor life without significant fading.

Due to their unique properties, pigment-based inks do require more maintenance and special considerations. For example, when switching from dye-based to pigment-based ink in a printer, it is recommended to store the dye ink in an airtight container to prevent it from drying out. Additionally, pigment inks may need to be used with specific types of paper, such as plain paper, matte paper, or specialty fine art papers, to achieve the best results. Proper handling, storage, and adherence to the manufacturer's cleaning and maintenance guidelines are crucial to ensure optimal performance when using pigment-based inks.

Iron-gall inks will corrode a fountain pen's innards if left too long

Fountain pen inks are not the same as alcohol inks. Fountain pen inks come in a variety of colours and can be described as "wet" or "dry", referring to the ink's flow rate and how quickly it comes out of the nib. Wet inks, which tend to feel smoother, can make lines appear thicker and can showcase effects like shading. Dry inks, on the other hand, are better suited for ordinary copy paper and are a good choice for left-handed writers as they dry faster and are less likely to smudge.

Iron-gall inks, in particular, have historically been the standard for writing ink from the 5th to the 19th centuries due to their deep penetration into paper fibres, making erasure difficult. However, traditional iron-gall inks produced an acidic mixture, which was not ideal for long-term archival or storage in fountain pens. Modern iron-gall inks have been formulated to be more stable and fountain pen-friendly, but they still require careful handling.

One key consideration with iron-gall inks is that they should not be left in a fountain pen for an extended period. If a pen with iron-gall ink is not used regularly and is prone to drying out, it can lead to corrosion and damage to the pen's innards over time. This is because the evaporation of water triggers reactions that form water-insoluble iron complexes, resulting in darkening and sedimentation. Therefore, it is crucial to maintain a routine cleaning schedule and ensure that pens are not left inked for months to prevent potential corrosion and clogging issues.

While some users have reported successful experiences using iron-gall inks in stainless steel nib pens for months without issues, others have noticed increased toothiness or corrosion in their nibs. Gold nibs are generally recommended for iron-gall inks as gold does not corrode like other metals. However, gold plating can still be susceptible to galvanic corrosion.

To mitigate the risks associated with iron-gall inks, it is advised to follow a thorough cleaning process when switching to or from these inks in fountain pens. This involves disassembling the pen, cleaning it under running water or using an ultrasonic cleaner with detergent, and ensuring proper drying before reassembling. Additionally, it is recommended to test inks by mixing small amounts in sample vials to observe any grit or gunk formation, indicating incompatible inks that could damage the pen.

Frequently asked questions