Weed Vs Alcohol: Which Impairs Driving More?

Driving under the influence of any substance is dangerous and illegal. While alcohol is the most common substance associated with impaired driving, cannabis is the second most common. Studies have shown that cannabis impairs psychomotor and physiological functions critical to driving, such as attention, reaction time, coordination, and complex tasks requiring divided attention. Marijuana users tend to overestimate their impairment and may employ compensatory strategies, while alcohol users tend to underestimate their impairment. The additive effects of combining alcohol and cannabis can further increase impairment. The prevalence of driving under the influence of marijuana ranges from 6% to 32% of road traffic accidents, with the highest prevalence among persons aged 21–25 years. Understanding the effects of cannabis on driving performance is crucial for developing strategies to prevent drug-impaired driving and improving road safety.

Marijuana impairs attention, vigilance, perception, reaction time, motor coordination, and visual functions

Driving while under the influence of marijuana is illegal. Marijuana impairs attention, vigilance, perception, reaction time, motor coordination, and visual functions.

Several studies have been conducted to understand the effects of cannabis on cognitive functions. One study found that adult cannabis users who started smoking before the age of 17 had significant impairments in abstract reasoning, verbal fluency, and verbal learning and memory. Another study found that cannabis users had trouble with basic motor coordination and more complex tasks, such as planning, organizing, problem-solving, decision-making, memory, and controlling emotions and behavior.

THC, the primary psychoactive constituent of the cannabis sativa plant, is believed to be responsible for these cognitive effects. Performance tests conducted on recreational marijuana users showed that THC impaired performance in critical tracking tasks and decreased the number of correct decisions in problem-solving tasks. Additionally, THC increased stop reaction time and the number of errors in tasks requiring motor impulsivity.

Meta-analyses of multiple studies concluded that marijuana causes impairment in all performance areas critical for safe driving, including tracking, motor coordination, and visual functions. Marijuana also affects attentiveness, vigilance, perception of time and speed, and the use of acquired knowledge. While studies on the impact of marijuana on reaction time have shown inconsistent results, the overall evidence suggests that driving under the influence of marijuana can significantly impair driving abilities and increase the risk of accidents.

Studies show cannabis users are more likely to be responsible for crashes

Driving under the influence of cannabis is illegal and dangerous. Cannabis affects areas of the brain that control movement, balance, coordination, memory, and judgment. A meta-analysis of 60 studies concluded that marijuana causes impairment in every area connected with safe driving, such as tracking, motor coordination, and visual functions.

The National Highway Transportation Safety Administration (NHTSA) reported that in 25% of all motor vehicle crash fatalities, the driver had a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.01 g/dL or greater. In comparison, the percentage of road traffic accidents where a driver tested positive for marijuana ranges from 6% to 32%. While this data suggests that driving under the influence of alcohol is more prevalent, it is important to note that the contribution of marijuana to impaired driving deaths is not yet fully understood.

In 2018, approximately 12 million (4.7%) US residents aged 16 and above reported driving under the influence of marijuana in the past year. This is lower than the 8.0% (20.5 million) who reported driving under the influence of alcohol in the same year. The highest prevalence of driving under the influence of marijuana was among those aged 21-25, followed by the youngest drivers aged 16-20, who already have a heightened crash risk due to inexperience.

While the effects of driving under the influence of cannabis are similar to those of alcohol, there are some key differences. Impairment from alcohol often leads to overconfidence, impaired judgment, and increased risk-taking behavior. On the other hand, cannabis impairment can cause anxiety or paranoia, leading to overly cautious driving, slow driving, and overreaction to stimuli. Combining alcohol and cannabis amplifies the impairing effects of both substances, resulting in greater impairment than the use of either substance alone.

Driving under the influence of marijuana is illegal

Marijuana impairs several skills necessary for safe driving. It affects areas of the brain that control movement, balance, coordination, memory, and judgment. It slows reaction time and the ability to make decisions, and can cause anxiety or paranoia, leading to overly cautious driving, slow driving, and overreaction to stimuli. Marijuana also affects attentiveness, vigilance, perception of time and speed, and the use of acquired knowledge. A meta-analysis of 60 studies concluded that marijuana causes impairment in every performance area connected with safe driving, such as tracking, motor coordination, and visual functions.

The effects of marijuana on driving are not identical to those of alcohol, but there are undeniable similarities. Both substances negatively impact driving, and their effects present major risks on the roads. When combined, the impairing effects of both substances are significantly amplified. While marijuana smokers may be able to compensate effectively while driving under the influence of marijuana alone, combining marijuana with alcohol eliminates this ability to compensate.

It is important to note that the prevalence of driving under the influence of marijuana is not necessarily indicative of crash risk. While alcohol has been shown to increase crash risk, epidemiological studies on the relationship between cannabis use and accidents have been inconclusive. However, this does not mean that driving under the influence of marijuana is safe or legal. The safest option is to refrain from using any alcohol or drugs, including cannabis, if you intend to drive.

Marijuana and alcohol together have additive effects on impairment

Driving under the influence of marijuana is illegal and dangerous. Cannabis affects areas of the brain that control movement, balance, coordination, memory, and judgment. It also slows reaction time and impairs vision, compromising the ability to drive safely.

The National Highway Transportation Safety Administration (NHTSA) reported that in 25% of all motor vehicle crash fatalities, the driver had a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.01 g/dL or greater. This figure rose to 39% for 21-year-old drivers. In comparison, the percentage of road traffic accidents where a driver tested positive for marijuana ranged from 6% to 32%. While the exact contribution of marijuana to impaired driving deaths is unknown, an estimated 10,511 alcohol-impaired driving deaths occurred in 2018.

The effects of marijuana on driving are undeniable, and when combined with alcohol, the impairing effects of both substances are significantly amplified. Marijuana smokers may be able to compensate effectively while driving by using various behavioral strategies. However, combining marijuana with alcohol eliminates this ability and results in impairment even at doses that would be insignificant if either substance was consumed alone.

A meta-analysis of 60 studies concluded that marijuana causes impairment in every performance area connected with safe driving, such as tracking, motor coordination, and visual functions. When marijuana and alcohol are used together, their effects on impairment are additive or even multiplicative. This combination was the most common pairing found in 18% of impaired drivers arrested, with 75% of individuals with detected Delta-9 THC also having some other substance present.

The risk from driving under the influence of both substances is greater than the risk of driving under the influence of either alone. While the effects of marijuana and alcohol on driving are similar, they also have some differences. Alcohol often leads to overconfidence, impaired judgment, and increased risk-taking behavior, while marijuana can cause anxiety or paranoia, making drivers overly cautious and more likely to drive slowly or overreact to stimuli.

Marijuana is the second most common drug linked to impaired driving

Driving under the influence of marijuana is illegal and dangerous. Marijuana is the second most common drug linked to impaired driving, after alcohol. In 2018, 4.7% of U.S. residents aged 16 and above (approximately 12 million people) reported driving under the influence of marijuana in the past year. The prevalence was highest among those aged 21–25, followed by the youngest drivers aged 16–20, who already have a heightened crash risk due to inexperience.

Marijuana impairs several performance areas essential for safe driving, such as attentiveness, vigilance, perception of time and speed, motor coordination, and visual functions. It can also alter one's sense of time and distance, making it dangerous to navigate busy roads. Additionally, cannabis affects areas of the brain that control body movements, balance, coordination, memory, and judgment. The impairment caused by marijuana can lead to anxiety or paranoia, causing drivers to become overly cautious, drive slowly, or overreact to stimuli.

The effects of marijuana on driving are not identical to those of alcohol. Alcohol often leads to overconfidence, impaired judgment, and increased risk-taking behaviour, such as speeding and ignoring traffic signals. In contrast, marijuana impairment can make individuals overly cautious on the road. However, both substances negatively impact driving and have detrimental effects on reflexes, coordination, and decision-making abilities. Combining alcohol and marijuana amplifies their impairing effects, resulting in greater impairment than when using either substance alone.

The contribution of marijuana to impaired driving deaths is not yet fully understood. In 2018, an estimated 10,511 driving deaths were attributed to alcohol impairment. While the exact role of marijuana in these fatalities is unclear, studies have found that 75% of individuals with detected Delta-9-THC (the primary psychoactive component of cannabis) also had another substance present, most commonly alcohol. This lack of clarity around cannabis intoxication and impairment measurement presents challenges for highway safety and the public.

Frequently asked questions