Alcohol Disinfection: How Strong Does It Need To Be?

Alcohol is a powerful disinfectant, effective against viruses and bacteria. It is often used to disinfect small surfaces and equipment in healthcare settings, such as stethoscopes, thermometers, and ventilators. The effectiveness of alcohol as a disinfectant depends on its concentration and the type of microbe being targeted. A concentration of 70% isopropyl alcohol (IPA) is widely recognized as an effective disinfectant, superior to higher concentrations like 99% isopropyl alcohol. This is because a concentration of 70% allows for more water content, helping the alcohol dissolve slowly, penetrate cells, and kill bacteria. The CDC recommends an alcohol concentration of between 60% and 90% for disinfection purposes, with 70% isopropyl alcohol being particularly effective.

Isopropyl alcohol is more effective at 70% than 99%

Isopropyl alcohol (IPA) is a colourless, flammable liquid widely used for cleaning and disinfecting. It is available in different concentrations, with 99% and 70% being common variants.

The main difference between the two is the concentration of alcohol in the solution. Isopropyl alcohol 99% contains 99% alcohol and 1% water, while isopropyl alcohol 70% contains 70% alcohol and 30% water. The higher concentration of alcohol in the 99% variant makes it a stronger and more concentrated solution, which is more effective at killing bacteria, viruses, and other microorganisms on surfaces. It is often used in industrial and medical settings where a fast-acting solvent is required.

However, despite being less concentrated, isopropyl alcohol 70% is considered more effective for disinfection in most cases. This is because the water content in the solution helps the alcohol penetrate cell walls and denature proteins more thoroughly. The increased water content also slows down the evaporation rate, increasing the contact time with the surface being disinfected. In contrast, 99% IPA evaporates too quickly, which may cause it to dehydrate microbes without killing them.

The choice between 99% and 70% isopropyl alcohol depends on the specific application. While 99% IPA is useful in industrial and manufacturing settings where a strong solvent is needed, 70% IPA is more suitable for household and consumer applications. It is commonly used for cleaning and disinfecting skin, wiping down surfaces, and cleaning electronic devices.

Overall, while isopropyl alcohol 99% is a stronger solution, isopropyl alcohol 70% is generally a more effective disinfectant due to its slower evaporation rate and enhanced protein denaturation.

Ethyl alcohol is superior to isopropyl alcohol

Ethyl alcohol and isopropyl alcohol are both used as disinfectants and antiseptics and can be effective at killing germs. However, ethyl alcohol is considered superior to isopropyl alcohol for several reasons. Firstly, ethyl alcohol is a powerful broad-spectrum germicide, effective against a wide range of viruses, including the influenza virus, while isopropyl alcohol is not as effective against non-enveloped viruses. According to the WHO, 70% ethyl alcohol is more efficient against the influenza virus than isopropyl alcohol.

Secondly, ethyl alcohol may be preferred over isopropyl alcohol due to its lower skin irritation potential. A 2017 study found that isopropyl alcohol caused significant damage to skin condition and function, whereas ethyl alcohol did not. This makes ethyl alcohol a better choice for hand sanitizers and products that come into contact with the skin.

Thirdly, ethyl alcohol is generally safer for use, especially around children. Isopropyl alcohol is toxic if ingested and can cause severe health issues, including vomiting, dizziness, headaches, respiratory failure, and even death. On the other hand, ethyl alcohol is the type of alcohol found in alcoholic beverages and is safe for consumption in regulated amounts.

Finally, ethyl alcohol is more commonly used in hand sanitizers and medical wipes, while isopropyl alcohol is more prevalent in industrial settings and for cleaning electronics. Ethyl alcohol's effectiveness, safety profile, and versatility make it a preferred choice in various applications, including healthcare and personal hygiene.

In summary, while both ethyl and isopropyl alcohol have disinfectant properties, ethyl alcohol is superior due to its broader germicidal activity, lower skin irritation, enhanced safety profile, and versatility in various applications. It is important to follow product instructions and use each alcohol type as intended to ensure effectiveness and safety.

Alcohol is flammable, so it's not suitable for large areas

Alcohol is a powerful disinfectant, particularly ethyl alcohol (ethanol) and isopropyl alcohol (isopropanol). Ethanol is chemically the same as drinking alcohol, and isopropanol is often referred to as "rubbing alcohol". Both are effective at eliminating bacteria and viruses on the skin and on surfaces.

The CDC recommends an alcohol concentration of between 60% and 90% for disinfection purposes. A minimum concentration of 50% isopropyl alcohol is recommended, but 70% is preferable. Indeed, 70% isopropyl alcohol has been demonstrated to be effective in disinfecting reusable transducer heads in a controlled environment. However, isopropyl alcohol is not considered a "high-level disinfectant" because it cannot eradicate bacterial spores and hydrophilic viruses such as polio.

Alcohol is flammable and must be stored in a cool, well-ventilated area. It should only be used to disinfect small surface areas, and prolonged and repeated use can cause discolouration, swelling, hardening, and cracking of rubber and certain plastics. Therefore, alcohol is not suitable for disinfecting large areas.

Other disinfectants, such as bleach, can be used for larger areas. Bleach is a strong and effective disinfectant, particularly against bacteria, fungi, and viruses, including the influenza virus. However, it should be handled with caution as it irritates mucous membranes, the skin, and the airways, and can react with other chemicals. It should be diluted and used in a well-ventilated area.

Alcohol can damage some plastics and rubbers

While alcohol is a great disinfectant, it is important to note that it can damage certain plastics and rubbers. Alcohol is a powerful solvent that can dissolve or degrade some materials, causing them to become brittle, swollen, or discoloured. This is because alcohol can break down the polymer chains that make up these materials, altering their structural and mechanical properties.

The types of plastics and rubbers that are most susceptible to damage from alcohol include polycarbonate, acrylic, and polystyrene. These materials are often used in products such as eyeglass lenses, car headlights, and disposable food containers. Exposure to alcohol can cause these items to become cloudy, cracked, or distorted.

Natural rubbers and some soft plastics, such as polyvinyl chloride (PVC), can also be affected by alcohol. Alcohol can degrade the flexibility and elasticity of these materials, making them harder and more brittle. This is why alcohol-based hand sanitisers, for example, are often packaged in foam or silicone-coated bottles.

Additionally, alcohol can react with certain plastics and rubbers to release chemicals that may be harmful to humans. For instance, when polyvinyl chloride (PVC) is exposed to alcohol, it can release plasticisers such as phthalates, which have been linked to potential health risks. Therefore, it is important to be mindful of the types of materials that come into contact with alcohol to avoid any potential damage or health hazards.

Alcohol is not recommended for sterilising medical equipment

Alcohol is an effective disinfectant against many bacteria and viruses. A minimum concentration of 50% Isopropyl Alcohol is required for disinfecting, with 70% being preferable. Ethyl alcohol (70%) is a powerful broad-spectrum germicide and is considered superior to isopropyl alcohol.

However, alcohol is not recommended for sterilising medical and surgical materials. This is because alcohol lacks sporicidal action and cannot penetrate protein-rich materials. Alcohol is a fixative, which means it increases the attachment of soil to instruments, making it harder to clean them effectively. This can lead to sterilisation inefficacy and, in the case of contaminated surgical instruments, fatal postoperative wound infections.

Furthermore, alcohol is flammable, so its use as a disinfectant should be limited to small surface areas and well-ventilated spaces. It can also cause discolouration, swelling, hardening, and cracking of rubber and certain plastics over time.

For sterilising medical equipment, steam sterilisation using an autoclave is a widely used method due to its affordability and effectiveness. There are two main types of autoclaves: gravity displacement autoclaves, which should be set to 250 degrees Fahrenheit, and high-speed pre-vacuum sterilisers, which should be set to 270 degrees Fahrenheit.

Frequently asked questions