Alcohol: Why We Grow Wheat And Barley?

Alcohol has been a prime mover of human culture from the beginning, influencing the development of arts, language, and religion. While the reasons for the shift to agriculture remain unknown, one theory, the beer theory, argues that the desire for alcoholic beverages led to the domestication of wheat and barley. According to archaeologist Patrick McGovern, alcohol may have been the catalyst for early man's transition from hunting and gathering to farming. Evidence suggests that our ancestors were more interested in growing grain to make beer, and the mind-altering effects of alcohol played a pivotal role in the development of early human societies.

Alcohol's role in early human creativity and societal development

Alcohol has played a significant role in human creativity and societal development since the beginning of our species. While the reasons for the shift from hunter-gatherer lifestyles to agriculture remain unclear, some experts argue that the desire for alcoholic beverages may have been a motivating factor.

The "beer before bread" hypothesis suggests that early humans were more interested in cultivating grains, such as wheat and barley, for fermentation rather than for flour to make bread. This theory is supported by archaeological evidence, including the discovery of potential ancient beer-brewing tools and residues of ancient beer in prehistoric sites. For example, in a Neolithic village in China, chemical analysis of jars from 7000 BC revealed traces of a fermented beverage made from grapes, hawthorn berries, honey, and rice. Similarly, in a prehistoric burial site in modern-day Israel, researchers found 13,000-year-old traces of a wheat-and-barley-based alcohol, suggesting that alcoholic drinks may even predate agriculture.

Alcohol, with its mind-altering properties, is believed to have played a pivotal role in fostering creativity and societal development. University of Pennsylvania biomolecular archaeologist Patrick McGovern suggests that alcohol was "a prime mover of human culture from the beginning, fueling the development of arts, language, and religion." Alcohol also served as a social lubricant, breaking down barriers and fostering collaboration among early humans. It became a central part of feasts and social gatherings that facilitated bonding, inspired creativity, and even influenced political discussions and power structures.

The positive psychotropic effects of alcohol, such as increased cheerfulness and confidence, would have been attractive to early humans. Additionally, the process of fermentation happens naturally, and early humans may have stumbled upon naturally fermented fruits and grains, eventually learning to harness this process. The creation and consumption of alcoholic beverages would have been an important shared experience, motivating the domestication of crops and the establishment of settlements.

While the role of alcohol in early human creativity and societal development is intriguing, it is important to acknowledge that other factors, such as the reliability of grain as a food source, may have also contributed to the shift towards agriculture. The "beer before bread" hypothesis remains a subject of ongoing archaeological research and debate.

The 'beer theory' of human settlement and agriculture

The "beer theory of human settlement and agriculture" is a hypothesis that suggests that the desire for alcoholic beverages, specifically beer, was the catalyst for the transition from hunter-gatherer lifestyles to settled agriculture. According to this theory, our ancestors' urge to produce and consume alcohol led them to domesticate grains, settle down, and cultivate crops.

This theory challenges the traditional view that the development of agriculture was primarily driven by the need for reliable food sources, such as bread. Instead, it proposes that the motivation to create alcoholic drinks, particularly beer, was a significant driving force in early human settlements.

The beer theory has gained support from archaeological findings and cultural evidence. Archaeologists have found evidence of early beer-making practices, including ancient brewing tools and residues of wheat-and-barley-based alcohol in prehistoric sites. For example, the earliest chemical evidence of barley-based beer dates back to around 3500 BC, and some scientists believe that grain-based beer may be much older. Additionally, studies of ancient beverages in China, Africa, and Mexico support the idea that alcohol played a pivotal role in the development of early human societies.

Proponents of the beer theory, such as archaeologist Patrick McGovern, argue that alcohol provided the "initial motivation" for early humans to adopt agriculture. They suggest that the mind-altering properties of alcohol fueled creativity, social bonding, and the development of language, arts, and religion. The act of brewing and consuming alcohol together may have fostered collaboration and strengthened social connections within early communities.

Furthermore, the beer theory addresses the “puzzling inconsistencies" found in studies of ancient crops. For instance, teosinte, an ancient form of maize in Mexico, was better suited for brewing beer than for making corn flour or bread tortillas. This suggests that the motivation for cultivating certain crops may have been driven by the desire to produce alcoholic beverages rather than solely for food purposes.

While the beer theory provides interesting insights into the potential role of alcohol in human settlement and agriculture, it is important to acknowledge that it is just one of many theories. Other archaeologists and historians have differing viewpoints, emphasizing the reliability of grain as a food source as the primary motivation for early humans to settle down and raise crops. More research and evidence are needed to fully understand the complex factors that influenced the transition to agriculture in early human societies.

Alcohol as a motivator for early humans to domesticate crops

Alcohol has been a prime mover of human culture since its discovery, influencing the development of art, language, and religion. The desire for alcohol may have been a significant factor in early humans' decision to domesticate crops and transition from hunter-gatherer lifestyles to agriculture.

The idea that alcohol played a pivotal role in the domestication of crops was proposed by archaeologist Patrick McGovern, a biomolecular archaeologist at the University of Pennsylvania Museum. McGovern's research suggests that early man was making and consuming alcoholic beverages as far back as 9,000 years ago, with chemical analysis of jars from a Neolithic village in China dated to 7000 BC revealing traces of fermented beverages.

McGovern argues that the urge for alcoholic drinks provided the initial motivation for early humans to adopt agriculture. He suggests that the mind-altering properties of alcohol, its positive psychotropic effects, and its good taste would have attracted early humans to consume more. Additionally, alcohol may have acted as a social lubricant, fostering collaboration and strengthening social bonds within communities.

Supporting evidence for McGovern's theory comes from various sources. For example, in Mexico, teosinte, an ancient form of maize, was better suited for brewing beer than for making corn flour or bread tortillas. This suggests that the crop was initially used for beer production. Additionally, in the Neolithic period, about 40% of the wheat from Sumerian harvests was used for brewing beer, indicating the importance of alcohol in early societies.

Furthermore, the discovery of early brewing tools and the presence of potential brewing sites, such as the prehistoric brewery found in a cave near Haifa in modern-day Israel, provide additional support for the idea that alcohol played a significant role in early human societies.

While not everyone agrees that beer was the primary motivator for crop domestication, with some archaeologists and historians emphasizing the role of grain as a reliable food source, the importance of alcohol in early human societies cannot be overlooked. Alcohol has been integral to humanity's development, influencing cultural practices, social interactions, and even political discussions.

Alcohol as a central part of feasts and social gatherings

Alcohol has been a prime mover of human culture from the very beginning, playing a pivotal role in the development of early man. It has been used for rituals and medicinal purposes, and its mind-altering properties have fuelled the development of arts, language, and religion.

Once early humans understood the effects of alcohol, it became a central part of feasts and other social gatherings. Alcohol, often used to break down barriers between people, helped to forge bonds and inspire creativity. It also facilitated political discussions and the chiselling of power structures. For instance, in ancient Greece, the symposium was an all-male, after-dinner drinking party. In Germany and Persia, collective decisions of state were made after a few drinks, and then double-checked when sober.

Alcohol was also important in early civilisations, such as the Indus Valley civilisation, where it was in use between 3000 BC and 2000 BC. Sura, a beverage brewed from rice meal, wheat, sugar cane, grapes, and other fruits, was popular among the Kshatriya warriors and the peasant population. In ancient India, alcohol was also used by the orthodox population. The Hindu Ayurvedic texts describe both the benefits of consuming alcoholic beverages in moderation and the consequences of intoxication and alcoholic diseases.

The desire for alcoholic drinks may even have led to agriculture and civilisation. A growing body of research shows that early humans began cultivating grain around 10,000 years ago, not to make bread, but to turn it into alcohol. For example, the earliest chemical evidence of barley-based beer dates back to 3500 BC, but some scientists think grain-based beer has been around much longer. Traces of a wheat-and-barley-based alcohol were found in stone mortars in a prehistoric burial site in a cave near Haifa in modern-day Israel, dating back 13,000 years.

However, not everyone subscribes to the idea that beer was the primary motivation for the domestication of grains. Some archaeologists and historians argue that grain is easy to store and keeps for a long time, making it a reliable food source that may have been the primary incentive for humans to settle down and raise crops.

Alcohol as a catalyst for human civilisation

Alcohol has been a prime mover of human culture from the beginning, fuelling the development of arts, language, and religion. The desire for alcoholic drinks may have been the catalyst for the birth of agriculture and, in turn, civilisation.

The idea that beer, rather than bread, was the inspiration for our ancestors to domesticate grains was first proposed by botanist Jonathan D. Sauer in the early 1950s. The theory has gained support from archaeological evidence and has been revisited in recent years. The earliest chemical evidence of barley-based beer dates back to 3500 BC, but some scientists believe grain-based beer has been around much longer. Excavations have revealed potential ancient beer-brewing tools, and experiments have shown that a simple mortar and pestle can be used to make a low-alcohol drink.

University of Pennsylvania biomolecular archaeologist Patrick McGovern has found evidence that early man was making alcoholic beverages as far back as 9,000 years ago. His earliest sample, which dates to 7000 BC, includes pottery shards found in a Neolithic village in China. McGovern argues that the mind-altering properties of alcohol fuelled our creativity and fostered the development of language, the arts, and religion. He also believes that alcohol was a main motivation for early man to settle down and domesticate crops, stating that "people wanted to be closer to their plants".

There is also evidence to suggest that alcohol played an important role in social gatherings and political discussions in early civilisations. Hayden, an expert in the field, has pushed the idea that cultural factors, rather than environmental ones, fostered the domestication of grain. Hayden argues that once people understood the effects of alcohol, it became a central part of feasts and other social gatherings that forged bonds between people. Alcohol may have also played a role in decision-making, with some evidence suggesting that early brews were considered aids in deliberation.

While not everyone subscribes to the idea that beer was the primary motivator for the domestication of grains, there is significant evidence to support the theory that alcohol played a pivotal role in the development of human civilisation.

Frequently asked questions