Water Vs. Ethyl Alcohol: Which Sticks Better?

Water and alcohol have different molecular properties, which affect how they interact with surfaces. Water is a polar molecule, meaning it has a slight negative charge at one end and a slight positive charge at the other. This polarity gives water strong cohesive and adhesive properties, making it an excellent solvent for ionic salts and polar covalent compounds. On the other hand, ethanol, a type of alcohol, has a different molecular structure with a mix of polar and non-polar regions. This difference in polarity affects how water and alcohol interact with surfaces and with themselves.

Water is polar, alcohol is mostly nonpolar

Water and ethyl alcohol have different chemical properties, which affect their behaviour and interactions with other substances. Water is a polar molecule, meaning it has a slight electric charge, with one end of the molecule being slightly negative and the other slightly positive. This polarity makes water attracted to other polar molecules or charged molecules, such as ions. On the other hand, ethyl alcohol, or ethanol, is composed mostly of nonpolar bonds. While ethanol can form intermolecular hydrogen bonds, it has fewer per molecule compared to water.

The polarity of a molecule is determined by the distribution of electrons in its bonds. In a polar molecule, the electrons are unevenly distributed, resulting in a small positive and negative polarity at the ends of the bond. These polar bonds can then interact with each other, with the positive and negative ends attracting each other, leading to stronger intermolecular forces. Water has strong intermolecular forces due to its polar O-H bonds, which are also known as hydrogen bonds.

Ethanol, despite being mostly nonpolar, exhibits stronger intermolecular forces than methanol because it has a larger molecular mass and is more polarizable. Polarizability refers to the ability of a molecule to form instantaneous dipoles when influenced by nearby charged molecules or ions. However, the polarizability of ethanol does not make it as polar as water. The nonpolar nature of ethanol allows it to flow more freely compared to water, which has higher viscosity due to its strong intermolecular attractions.

The difference in polarity between water and ethanol also affects their interactions with other substances. Water is an excellent solvent for polar and ionic compounds, such as alcohol and sodium chloride (NaCl). However, water struggles to dissolve nonpolar compounds like oils and fats. In contrast, ethanol, being mostly nonpolar, can dissolve nonpolar substances more effectively. This difference in solubility is why we often use ethanol as a solvent in laboratory settings and industrial applications when working with nonpolar compounds.

In summary, water is a polar molecule with strong intermolecular forces, making it attracted to other polar molecules and charged ions. Ethyl alcohol (ethanol) is mostly nonpolar, with weaker intermolecular forces, allowing it to flow more freely. The polarity of water makes it a versatile solvent, especially for polar and ionic compounds, while ethanol's nonpolar nature gives it an advantage in dissolving nonpolar substances. These differences in polarity and resulting behaviours showcase the unique characteristics of water and ethanol, which are essential to understanding their interactions with various surfaces and substances.

Water molecules are attracted to each other

Water molecules exhibit unique properties due to their polar nature. They have a partial positive charge on one side (hydrogen atoms) and a partial negative charge on the other (oxygen atom). This uneven distribution of charge occurs because oxygen is more electronegative than hydrogen, pulling the shared electrons closer to itself.

The polarity of water molecules also causes them to be attracted to oppositely charged ions of sodium and chloride. Water can dissolve ionic salts and polar covalent compounds such as alcohol. However, it is less effective at dissolving nonpolar covalent compounds such as oil because water molecules are more attracted to other polar molecules or molecules with a charge.

Ethanol, which is mostly composed of nonpolar bonds, cannot attract itself like water molecules. This is why ethanol flows more freely than water, which is more viscous due to its strong polarity and self-attraction.

Water has higher surface tension

Water has a higher surface tension than ethyl alcohol. This is due to the strong attraction between water molecules, which are polar and thus very attracted to each other. This attraction pulls the water molecules together into a tight arrangement, resulting in surface tension.

The polarity of water molecules gives them a positive and negative end, and these opposite ends attract and form hydrogen bonds. This polarity and resulting hydrogen bonding make water more viscous and able to attract itself into a compact form.

Ethanol, on the other hand, is composed of mostly nonpolar bonds, which means it cannot attract itself in the same way as water. While ethanol can form hydrogen bonds, it has fewer per molecule than water. The shape of ethanol molecules also impacts their ability to attract each other; because they are polar only at one end, they can meet in ways that do not result in attraction.

The difference in surface tension between water and ethanol can be observed through experiments. For example, when dropped onto a penny, water forms a dome shape due to its surface tension, while ethanol spreads more due to its lower surface tension.

The higher surface tension of water also has implications for its interactions with other substances. For example, when mixed with a nonpolar compound like oil, water molecules tend to hold onto each other and exclude the oil, resulting in two separate layers.

Alcohol has a lower viscosity

Water and ethanol (ethyl alcohol) have different behaviours due to the nature of their chemical bonds. Water molecules are polar, with an O-H bond, which means they are attracted to other polar molecules or molecules with a charge (like an ion). This polarity leads to strong intermolecular forces between water molecules, resulting in high surface tension and viscosity.

On the other hand, ethanol is composed mostly of nonpolar bonds. While ethanol can form intermolecular hydrogen bonds, these are fewer per molecule compared to water. The nonpolar nature of ethanol means it has weaker intermolecular forces between its molecules, resulting in a much lower surface tension and a more free-flowing liquid.

The difference in viscosity between water and ethanol can be observed in their behaviour when mixed with other substances. For example, when mixed with oils, water molecules tend to separate from the oil due to their polarity difference, forming two distinct layers. In contrast, ethanol, with its nonpolar nature, can mix more freely with nonpolar substances like oils.

Additionally, when water and ethanol are mixed together, the resulting mixture has a higher viscosity than either of the pure substances. This phenomenon is attributed to the formation of micelles of ethanol molecules in water due to hydrophobic attraction, leading to a positive deviation in viscosity.

In summary, ethanol has a lower viscosity than water due to its predominantly nonpolar nature, resulting in weaker intermolecular forces and reduced attraction between ethanol molecules compared to the strong hydrogen bonds between water molecules.

Water dissolves ionic salts, alcohol doesn't

Water and ethyl alcohol have different attractive forces, with water being more attracted to surfaces due to its polarity. This polarity also allows water to dissolve ionic salts, unlike alcohol, which is less polar and, therefore, less effective at dissolving ionic compounds.

Water molecules are polar, meaning they have a slight electric charge, with one side being slightly negative and the other slightly positive. This polarity makes water molecules attracted to each other and to other polar molecules. On the other hand, ethanol, a type of alcohol, has a molecular structure that is mostly non-polar, resulting in weaker intermolecular forces compared to water.

The polarity of water molecules enables them to dissolve ionic salts. Salt, or sodium chloride (NaCl), is composed of positively charged sodium ions (Na+) and negatively charged chloride ions (Cl-). When salt is added to water, the positive part of the water molecules attracts the negative chloride ions, while the negative part of the water molecules attracts the positive sodium ions. This process, known as solvation, results in the salt ions being surrounded by water molecules.

Alcohol, on the other hand, is less polar than water. While alcohols like isopropyl alcohol do have some polarity due to the presence of an oxygen atom bonded to a hydrogen atom, it is not enough to effectively dissolve ionic salts. The ionic bonds holding the salt crystals together require a highly polar solvent to provide sufficient solvation energy to break them apart. Water's polarity makes it a strong polar solvent, while alcohol's weaker polarity makes it less effective in dissolving ionic salts.

The difference in the ability of water and alcohol to dissolve salts can be observed through a simple experiment. By comparing the amount of salt dissolved in water and alcohol after swirling and checking at regular intervals, it becomes evident that water dissolves more salt than alcohol. This experiment demonstrates the impact of polarity on the solubility of ionic compounds in different solvents.

In summary, water dissolves ionic salts more effectively than alcohol due to its higher polarity. The polarity of water molecules allows them to attract and surround the oppositely charged ions of salt, leading to dissolution. Alcohol's weaker polarity results in a reduced ability to dissolve ionic compounds, as it cannot provide the necessary solvation energy to break the strong ionic bonds of salts.

Frequently asked questions