Water-Alcohol Mix: Positive Or Negative Azeotrope?

Azeotropes are a type of mixture with unique properties that make them distinct from other solutions. They can be classified as positive or negative, depending on their boiling points relative to their constituents. A positive azeotrope has a lower boiling point than any of its individual components, while a negative azeotrope has a higher boiling point. This classification is important because it determines whether the constituents of the azeotrope can be separated through distillation. In the context of water and alcohol, specifically ethanol, understanding their azeotropic behaviour is crucial for processes such as distillation and evaporation. So, is the water-ethanol mixture a positive or negative azeotrope?

Water and ethanol form a homogeneous azeotrope

An azeotrope is a mixture that boils at a temperature that is different from that of its constituents. Azeotropes can be positive or negative. A positive azeotrope boils at a lower temperature than any other ratio of its constituents, while a negative azeotrope boils at a higher temperature.

The formation of this azeotrope can be explained by the different intermolecular bonding patterns of the two components. While ethanol strongly dominates the surface, water penetrates to the surface. The addition of surface water increases the relative vapour pressure, resulting in azeotropic behaviour.

Distillation cannot separate the constituents of this azeotrope. However, an entrainer can be added to modify the azeotropic composition and exhibit immiscibility with one of the components. For example, the addition of calcium oxide to the water/ethanol azeotrope results in the formation of the non-volatile compound calcium hydroxide, which can be separated by filtration to obtain 100% pure ethanol.

The water-ethanol azeotrope is an example of a binary azeotrope. However, it can be combined with a third component to form a ternary azeotrope. For example, adding cyclohexane as an entrainer to the water/ethanol azeotrope results in a mixture that is 7% water, 17% ethanol, and 76% cyclohexane, and boils at 62.1 °C.

The boiling point of an azeotrope is different from its constituents

Azeotropes are a mixture of at least two different liquids. Their mixtures can have either a lower or higher boiling point than their individual components. An azeotrope is formed when the fraction of liquids cannot be altered through simple distillation. During distillation, the more volatile component tends to vaporize and is collected separately, while the least volatile component remains in the distillation container. Eventually, the result is two pure, separate solutions.

The boiling point of an azeotrope is either less than the boiling point temperatures of any of its constituents (a positive azeotrope) or greater than the boiling point of any of its constituents (a negative azeotrope). For instance, hydrogen chloride boils at −84 °C and water at 100 °C, but the azeotrope boils at 110 °C, which is higher than either of its constituents.

Azeotropes are classified into five categories: homogeneous azeotrope, heterogeneous azeotrope, binary azeotrope, maximum boiling azeotrope, and minimum boiling azeotrope. A mixture of alcohol and water is an example of a homogeneous azeotrope. A minimum boiling azeotrope is an azeotropic mixture in which the constitutions of mixtures show a positive deviation from the ideal solution and boils at a constant temperature slightly lower than that of the pure component. An example of a minimum boiling azeotrope is a mixture of 95.5% ethanol and 4.5% water by mass. Conversely, a maximum boiling azeotrope is an azeotropic mixture in which the constitutions of mixtures show a negative deviation from the ideal solution and boils at a constant temperature slightly higher than that of the pure component. An example of a maximum boiling azeotrope is a mixture of 68% nitric acid and 32% water by mass.

Ethanol and water form an azeotropic mixture at an ethanol molecular percentage of around 91% (around 96% by volume), which prohibits ethanol from being further purified via distillation. The best that can be produced by simple fractional distillation is 95.6% ethanol.

Negative azeotropes have a higher boiling point than their constituents

Azeotropes are a mixture of at least two different liquids. They can be either positive or negative azeotropes. A negative azeotrope is a type of azeotropic mix that demonstrates a notable negative divergence from Raoult's Law at a certain composition. Raoult's Law states that the partial vapour pressure of the liquid of any component in any solution is precisely equal to its molar concentration. However, a negative azeotrope shows a reduction in vapour pressure compared to the solution.

The term azeotrope is derived from the Greek words "ζέειν" (boil) and "τρόπος" (turning) with the prefix "α-" (no) to give the overall meaning, "no change on boiling". This is because azeotropes have a constant boiling point, and the vapour composition is exactly the same as the liquid. This makes it extremely difficult to separate the components of azeotropes through distillation.

Negative azeotropes are important in various applications, including chromatography, sensor evaluation, and column evaluation. They are also used to isolate the constituents of zeotropic mixes. For example, it is challenging to separate the constituents of acetic acid and water, but a negative azeotrope can be used to achieve this.

It is important to note that not all mixtures are azeotropes. For a mixture to be an azeotrope, it must deviate from both Raoult's Law and Dalton's Law. Raoult's Law states that the equality of compositions in the liquid and vapour phases must be the same, while Dalton's Law states that the equality of pressures for the total pressure is equal to the sum of the partial pressures in real mixes.

Positive azeotropes have a lower boiling point than their constituents

Azeotropes are a mixture of at least two different liquids. Their mixtures can either have a higher boiling point than either of the components or a lower boiling point. Azeotropes occur when the fraction of the liquids cannot be changed by distillation.

Azeotropes are classified as positive or negative. A positive azeotrope, or minimum-boiling azeotrope, has a boiling point lower than that of any of its constituents. On the other hand, a negative azeotrope, or maximum-boiling azeotrope, has a boiling point greater than that of any of its constituents. For instance, a mixture of ethanol and water in the ratio of 95.6:4.4 boils at 78.5°C, which is lower than the boiling point of pure ethanol (78.3°C). Hence, it is a positive azeotrope.

The best-known example of a positive azeotrope is the ternary azeotrope formed by 30% acetone, 47% chloroform, and 23% methanol, which boils at 57.5°C. Each pair of these constituents forms a binary azeotrope, but chloroform/methanol and acetone/methanol both form positive azeotropes, while chloroform/acetone forms a negative azeotrope. The resulting ternary azeotrope is neither positive nor negative. Its boiling point falls between the boiling points of acetone and chloroform, so it is neither a maximum nor a minimum boiling point. This type of system is called a saddle azeotrope.

The water/ethanol azeotrope is another example of a positive azeotrope. The addition of surface water increases its relative vapour pressure, giving rise to azeotropic behaviour. The azeotropic mixture combines ethanol and water in a ratio of approximately 96:4, prohibiting ethanol from being further purified via distillation.

It is important to note that the boiling point of an azeotrope is never equal to the boiling points of any of its constituents.

Azeotropic distillation is required to separate components

Azeotropic distillation is a specialized type of distillation that involves using specific techniques to break azeotropes. It is required to separate components that form azeotropic mixtures, which are mixtures of two or more liquids whose proportions cannot be altered via simple distillation. This is because the vapours formed from boiling azeotropic mixtures contain almost the same proportions of liquids as the original mixture.

Azeotropic distillation involves adding certain components to the mixture to improve separation. Water or benzene are commonly added because they can increase the volatility of a chemical. This practice is similar to extractive distillation. The addition of a material separation agent, such as benzene to an ethanol-water mixture, changes the molecular interactions and eliminates the azeotrope. The new component can alter the activity coefficient of various compounds in different ways, thereby altering the mixture's relative volatility. This is the most common method of breaking an azeotrope.

There are two main types of azeotropes: homogeneous and heterogeneous. Homogeneous azeotropes are single liquid phases in equilibrium with a vapour phase, and heterogeneous azeotropes are overall liquid compositions that form two liquid phases identical to the vapour composition. Heterogeneous azeotropic distillation involves the use of a liquid separating agent (the entrainer) that forms one or more azeotropes with the other components in the mixture, causing two liquid phases to exist. This immiscibility is key to making the distillation sequence work.

Azeotropic distillation can also be achieved through pressure-swing distillation, which relies on the fact that an azeotrope is pressure-dependent. It involves using a series of columns operating at different pressures to separate binary azeotropes. Reactive distillation is another method, where the separating agent reacts preferentially and reversibly with one of the azeotropic constituents.

Azeotropic distillation is required to separate the components of water and ethanol, which form an azeotropic mixture at an ethanol molecular percentage of ~91% (or ~96% by volume). This mixture can be separated using material separation agents such as benzene, hexane, cyclohexane, pentane, diethyl ether, and acetone. Historically, benzene was the most commonly used entrainer, but its use has declined due to its carcinogenic nature. In modern practices, the ethanol-water azeotrope is usually broken with the help of toluene.

Frequently asked questions