How Prohibition Shaped The Progressive Era

The banning of alcoholic beverages, also known as Prohibition, was a significant reform movement during the Progressive Era in the United States. Lasting from 1920 to 1933, Prohibition aimed to address societal issues associated with alcohol, such as alcoholism, domestic violence, and political corruption. The movement was driven by drys, who advocated for public morality and health, and found support among progressives, women's groups like the Women's Christian Temperance Union, and religious organizations. The Eighteenth Amendment, ratified in 1919, prohibited the production, importation, transportation, and sale of alcoholic beverages, marking a pivotal moment in the Progressive Era's efforts to shape American society.

The Temperance Movement

The movement was driven by concerned citizens who warned others about the effects of alcohol. In 1826, the American Temperance Society was founded to promote abstinence from drinking. Soon after, the Woman's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) was established with the aim of not only banning alcohol and drugs but also improving public morals. The WCTU, led by Frances Willard, sought to unite women from all denominations to educate the youth, reform drinkers, and remove alcohol from streets by law. The WCTU provided women with a platform to enter politics and advance progressive issues such as prison reform and labor laws.

The Anti-Saloon League, formed in 1893, became a powerful force in passing a national ban on alcoholic beverages. They combined propaganda, religion, and political coercion to make alcohol a pivotal issue in elections. The movement gained support from factory owners who sought to instill new work habits, such as early mornings and long nights, in industrial workers. By the early 20th century, prohibition had become a national movement, with states imposing laws prohibiting the manufacture and sale of intoxicating beverages.

The Eighteenth Amendment, passed in 1919 with overwhelming support, prohibited the manufacture, transportation, and sale of alcoholic beverages. However, the enforcement of prohibition proved challenging, with widespread bootlegging and organized crime. The Volstead Act, which set the rules for enforcing the ban, allowed for the home production of wine and cider but not beer. While Prohibition aimed to improve society, it faced controversy among medical professionals as alcohol was commonly prescribed for therapeutic purposes. Ultimately, Prohibition ended in 1933 with the ratification of the Twenty-first Amendment, which repealed the Eighteenth Amendment.

The Eighteenth Amendment

The temperance movement, which discouraged alcohol use, had been active and influential in the United States for many decades. It was supported by women, who saw alcohol as a destroyer of families, and by factory owners, who wanted to promote new work habits among industrial workers. The movement gained a national grassroots base through the Woman's Christian Temperance Union, which was formed in the mid-19th century and aimed to improve public morals and health. The Anti-Saloon League, formed in 1893, also played a crucial role in passing the Eighteenth Amendment, using propaganda, religion, and political coercion to make alcohol a wedge issue in elections.

By the early 20th century, prohibition was a national movement, and states began imposing laws prohibiting the manufacture and sale of intoxicating beverages. In 1917, the House of Representatives proposed making prohibition the Eighteenth Amendment, and it was ratified by 46 out of 48 states in 1919. The enabling legislation, known as the Volstead Act, set the rules for enforcing the federal ban and defined prohibited alcoholic beverages. However, it did not prohibit the consumption of alcohol or the production of wine and cider for home use.

Prohibition went into effect at 12:01 am on January 17, 1920, and almost immediately, there were reports of robberies of whiskey, grain alcohol, and whiskey-carrying trucks. While prohibitionists rejoiced, the challenge of enforcing the law soon became apparent, with widespread bootlegging and the rise of powerful gangs trafficking in alcohol. Prohibition also had unintended consequences, such as increased violence and organised crime, and it faced opposition from medical professionals, as alcohol was widely prescribed for therapeutic purposes.

The Anti-Saloon League

The League had branches across the United States and worked with churches to marshal resources for the prohibition fight. It concentrated on legislation and lobbied at all levels of government for laws to prohibit the manufacture, importation, and sale of intoxicating beverages. The League used pressure politics in legislative politics, which it is credited with developing. It also employed emotion-based tactics, leveraging patriotism, efficiency, and anti-German sentiment during World War I to mobilize public opinion in favor of a dry, saloonless nation.

The League was particularly successful in rural and Southern states, but made little headway in larger cities or among liturgical church members such as Catholics, Jews, Episcopalians, and German Lutherans. At the state level, it had mixed results, with varying degrees of success in different states. In Arizona, for example, League members pressured local police to take licenses from establishments that violated closing hours or served minors, and they provided witnesses to testify about these violations.

The triumph of the Anti-Saloon League was the nationwide prohibition locked into the Constitution with the passage of the 18th Amendment in 1919. After the adoption of this amendment, the League sought strict enforcement of the Prohibition laws. However, the effort to regulate people's behavior soon proved difficult, and the amendment was repealed in 1933, ending the League's influence in American politics.

The negative social impact of alcohol

Alcohol abuse can have a range of negative social impacts, affecting individuals, their immediate environments, and society as a whole. Here are some key ways in which alcohol can negatively impact society:

Health and Healthcare Costs

Alcohol abuse has significant health consequences, contributing to numerous medical and psychiatric issues. Alcohol is linked to an increased risk of injuries and accidents, with even a single episode of excessive drinking potentially leading to negative outcomes. Alcohol abuse can also cause long-term changes in the brain, affecting decision-making, emotional processing, and self-control, making individuals more susceptible to aggression and violence. These health issues result in substantial healthcare costs for individuals, their families, and society.

Violence and Crime

Alcohol abuse is strongly associated with violence, including intimate partner violence, child abuse, and neglect. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, alcohol consumption increases the frequency and severity of intimate partner violence. Alcohol-related violence can have devastating effects on families and communities, leading to psychological issues such as anxiety, fear, and depression. Alcohol also contributes to increased crime rates, including drunk driving accidents, placing further strain on law enforcement and the criminal justice system.

Economic Impact

Alcohol abuse has significant economic costs for individuals, families, and society. Heavy drinkers may experience lower wages, lost employment opportunities, increased medical and legal expenses, and decreased eligibility for loans. Alcohol can lead to financial problems within families, impacting their ability to provide for their children and meet their basic needs. The cost of excessive alcohol consumption in the U.S. is substantial, with binge drinking accounting for a significant proportion of these costs.

Social and Family Issues

Alcohol abuse can impair an individual's ability to function effectively as a parent or partner, leading to family dysfunction and instability. It can contribute to mental health issues within families, substance use disorders in children, and an increased risk of alcoholism among children of parents with alcohol addiction. Alcohol abuse can also result in less time spent at home, affecting family dynamics and the emotional well-being of family members.

Community and Workplace Impact

Alcohol abuse extends beyond the family unit, impacting communities, schools, and workplaces. It contributes to absenteeism and lost productivity in the workplace, with alcohol-dependent individuals taking more frequent sick leave. Alcohol-related accidents and violence can affect the wider community, and the resources required to address these issues can strain social institutions.

The medicinal value of alcohol

The temperance movement, which discouraged alcohol consumption, was active and influential in the United States from the 1830s. Temperance advocates associated alcohol with social ills such as poverty and insanity and, from the 1850s onwards, focused their efforts on Irish and German immigrants. By the late 19th century, the movement had evolved into a prohibition movement, which achieved initial successes at the local and state levels.

The Progressive Era, from 1900 to 1929, witnessed a nationwide push for prohibition in the United States. Led by Pietistic Protestants, prohibitionists aimed to address alcohol-related problems such as alcoholism, domestic violence, and political corruption. The movement gained support from progressive factions of the Prohibition, Democratic, and Republican parties, as well as a grassroots base through the Woman's Christian Temperance Union. The Eighteenth Amendment, ratified in 1919, prohibited the manufacture, importation, transportation, and sale of alcoholic beverages.

Prohibition was highly controversial among medical professionals because alcohol was widely prescribed by physicians for therapeutic purposes. Alcohol has been consumed for its perceived medicinal properties since the late Stone Age, often to "remember their misery no more" (Proverbs 31:6-7). Even during the Progressive Era, many physicians continued to advocate for the medicinal value of alcohol. Congress held hearings on the medicinal value of beer in 1921, and physicians lobbied for the repeal of Prohibition as it applied to medicinal liquors. From 1921 to 1930, doctors earned about $40 million for whiskey prescriptions.

While excessive drinking is a leading cause of preventable death and contributes significantly to the global burden of disease, moderate alcohol consumption has been linked to potential health benefits. Studies have found that people who regularly consume a small amount of alcohol have a lower incidence of heart disease, stroke, diabetes, and certain types of cancer compared to non-drinkers or occasional drinkers. Additionally, many alcoholic drinks contain antioxidants, which may have beneficial effects on vascular stiffness and oxidative stress. Beer, for example, often has lower alcohol content than other beverages, reducing the potential for intoxication and abuse. Light beers also tend to have fewer calories while retaining flavour and flavonoids.

It is important to note that the medicinal effects of alcohol are complex and not fully understood. While moderate consumption may be associated with certain health benefits, alcohol can also interact with medications and impact individuals with certain medical conditions. Additionally, self-medication with alcohol can be risky, and studies on community-level alcohol use for medicinal purposes are scarce.

Frequently asked questions