Why Methanol, A Primary Alcohol, Is More Acidic

Alcohols are organic compounds characterized by one or more hydroxyl groups attached to a carbon atom. They are classified as primary, secondary, or tertiary alcohols. Primary alcohols are those where the carbon atom of the hydroxyl group is attached to only one alkyl group. Examples of primary alcohols include methanol and ethanol. Secondary alcohols, on the other hand, have a carbon atom attached to two alkyl groups on either side. This classification is important because it determines the acidity of the alcohol. Primary alcohols are more acidic than secondary alcohols due to the presence of only one alkyl group, which makes them better nucleophiles. However, the difference in acidity between primary and secondary alcohols is not just due to the number of alkyl groups but also the stability of the resulting conjugate base.

Methanol is a primary alcohol

Primary alcohols are those where the carbon atom of the hydroxyl group is attached to only one alkyl group. Methanol meets this criterion, as the carbon atom in its hydroxyl group (–OH) is attached to just one alkyl group. Other examples of primary alcohols include ethanol and propanol.

Secondary alcohols, by contrast, are those where the carbon atom of the hydroxyl group is attached to two alkyl groups on either side. These two alkyl groups may be either structurally identical or different. Tertiary alcohols feature a hydroxyl group attached to a carbon atom, which is itself connected to three alkyl groups.

The acidity of an alcohol depends on the stability of its conjugate base, which in this case is an alkoxide (O–). The more stable the conjugate base, the more acidic the alcohol. Primary alcohols are more acidic than secondary alcohols because the extra alkyl group in secondary alcohols destabilizes the anion (the conjugate base). Alkyl groups are electron-donating, so donating electrons to an already negatively charged molecule makes it more unstable.

However, it is important to note that methanol is less acidic than water. This is because the solvation energy of hydroxide is larger than that of methoxide, which leads to water being more acidic than methanol.

Primary alcohols are more acidic than secondary alcohols

Alcohols are organic compounds characterised by one, two, or more hydroxyl groups (–OH) attached to a carbon atom in an alkyl group or hydrocarbon chain. They are classified as primary, secondary, or tertiary alcohols.

Primary alcohols are those where the carbon atom of the hydroxyl group is attached to only one alkyl group. Examples include methanol (propanol), ethanol, etc. Secondary alcohols, on the other hand, have a carbon atom in the hydroxyl group attached to two alkyl groups on either side, which may be structurally identical or different.

Primary alcohols are considered more acidic than secondary alcohols. This is due to the presence of an extra alkyl group in secondary alcohols, which destabilizes the anion that is left after deprotonation (the conjugate base). Alkyl groups are electron-donating, and donating electrons (negative charge) to an already negatively charged molecule makes it even more unstable. A more stable conjugate base, therefore, makes for a stronger acid.

The steric bulk of secondary alcohols also limits the hydrogen bonding to the alcohol's hydroxyl group, making it more difficult to deprotonate. This is because the anion is more stable when hydrogen-bonded to hydrogen in surrounding water molecules.

The acidity of alcohols is also influenced by solvation. Smaller ions are better stabilized by solvation, which leads to a larger solvation energy. This is why methanol is more acidic than t-butanol, as the smaller methoxide ion has a shorter radius of solvation, resulting in a larger solvation energy.

Steric hindrance and the inductive effect make secondary alcohols more acidic

Alcohols are classified as primary, secondary, or tertiary. This classification is based on the number of linkages between the -OH group and an alkyl group. Primary alcohols have only one linkage between the -OH group and an alkyl group. The carbon atom of the hydroxyl group (OH) is attached to only one alkyl group. Some examples of primary alcohols include methanol (propanol) and ethanol.

Secondary alcohols, on the other hand, have the carbon atom of the hydroxyl group attached to two alkyl groups on either side. These two alkyl groups may be structurally identical or different.

Now, coming to the acidity of these alcohols, two factors determine the acidity of alcohols. Firstly, electron-donating groups destabilize the anion. Secondly, steric bulk or steric hindrance hinders the solvation of an adjacent alcohol group. Steric hindrance refers to the spatial arrangement of atoms within a molecule, which can affect the reactivity of a functional group by impeding the interaction of potential reactants.

In the context of primary and secondary alcohols, the steric bulk of secondary alcohols limits the hydrogen bonding to the hydroxyl group, making it more difficult to deprotonate. This is because the Oxygen atom in a secondary alcohol is already satisfied with its electronegativity, and losing a hydrogen (proton) and gaining an extra electron would make the molecule more unstable. Hence, it is not as willing as a primary alcohol to give up its Hydrogen.

Additionally, the electron-donating methyl groups in secondary alcohols stabilize positive charges, making adjacent cations more stable with increasing carbon substitution. This is called inductive electron donation or the "+I" effect. The extra methyl groups donate electron density to the oxygen, making the alkoxide anion less stable with increasing carbon substitution.

Methanol is more acidic than t-butanol

Methanol is a primary alcohol. Primary alcohols are those where the carbon atom of the hydroxyl group (OH) is attached to only one single alkyl group. Methanol is CH3OH, with the OH group attached to one methyl group.

Primary alcohols are more acidic than secondary alcohols. This is because the steric bulk of the secondary alcohols limits hydrogen bonding to the hydroxyl group, making it more difficult to deprotonate. The steric hindrance of the secondary/tertiary alcohols makes the anion more stable when hydrogen-bonded to hydrogen in surrounding water molecules.

However, the relative acidity of different alcohols is not solely due to the intrinsic electronic effects of the substituents. Brauman and Blair showed that smaller ions are better stabilized by solvation, which is consistent with the Born equation. Therefore, methanol is more acidic than t-butanol because the smaller methoxide ion has a shorter radius of solvation, leading to a larger solvation energy.

The pKa of typical aliphatic alcohols is around 16-18, making them slightly more acidic than water. The pKa of water is 15.7 at 25°C. The pKa of methanol is 15.5 at 25°C.

Water is more acidic than methanol

Methanol is a primary alcohol. The carbon atom of the hydroxyl group (OH) in primary alcohols is attached to only one single alkyl group.

The acidity of alcohols is determined by two factors. Firstly, electron-donating groups destabilize the anion. Secondly, steric bulk hinders the solvation of an adjacent alcohol group. The steric bulk of secondary and tertiary alcohols limits the hydrogen bonding to the hydroxyl group, making it more difficult to deprotonate.

Water molecules solvated by water are anomalously acidic due to the unusual stabilization of the conjugate base by very strong hydrogen bonds. Water in a non-aqueous solvent, especially aprotic solvents, suffers a decrease in acidity.

Alcohols are very weak Brønsted acids with pKa values generally in the range of 15-20. All other aliphatic alcohols are less acidic than water.

Frequently asked questions