Alcohol-Cooked Food: Safe For Kids?

Alcohol is often used in cooking to enhance the flavour of dishes. However, when it comes to feeding children, many parents are unsure if it is safe to serve them food cooked with alcohol. While some believe that the alcohol burns off during cooking, others suggest that traces can remain, depending on the cooking method and preparation. So, is it safe for kids to eat food cooked with alcohol?

Alcohol evaporates when cooked at a high enough temperature

Alcohol has a much lower boiling point than water, at 172°F or 173°F (78°C or 78.5°C), compared to water's 212°F (100°C). This means that alcohol will evaporate at a lower temperature than water. Therefore, when cooking with alcohol, as long as the temperature is above 78°C, the alcohol will evaporate.

However, it is important to note that not all alcohol will evaporate when cooked, and the amount of alcohol that remains depends on various factors, including the cooking method, the severity of the heat, and the cooking time. For example, a study found that after flambéing, where alcohol is poured onto food and set alight, approximately 75% of the alcohol remained. On the other hand, baking or simmering a dish with alcohol for 15 minutes will retain about 40% of the alcohol, while cooking for an hour will leave around 25%. Even after 2.5 hours of cooking, 5% of the alcohol will still be present.

The amount of alcohol remaining in a dish is also influenced by the surface area of the pot or pan used. A larger pan provides a bigger surface area, allowing more alcohol to evaporate. Additionally, the ratio of alcohol to other compounds in the dish matters. Alcohol binds with water to form an azeotrope, a mixture where the ratio of components cannot be changed by simple distillation. As a result, when boiling an azeotrope, the ratio of alcohol remains unchanged throughout the process.

Considering the potential presence of residual alcohol in cooked dishes, it is generally considered safe for children to consume food prepared with alcohol in small amounts and infrequently. The alcohol content is typically diluted and further reduced by the other ingredients in the dish. However, parents should exercise their discretion and consult with a pediatrician or medical professional if they have concerns or specific considerations regarding their child's health.

The amount of alcohol that burns off depends on cooking time and temperature

The amount of alcohol that burns off during cooking depends on the cooking time and temperature. Alcohol has a lower boiling point than water, so it doesn't need to be at a rolling boil for the alcohol to evaporate. The longer a dish is cooked at or above the boiling point of alcohol, the less alcohol will remain in the food. For example, simmering a pasta sauce containing alcohol for 15 minutes can reduce the alcohol content by about 60%, bringing the alcohol concentration to less than 1%.

Cooking methods and preparation techniques can also affect the amount of alcohol that evaporates. For instance, using a wide, uncovered pan can increase the surface area and allow for more alcohol to evaporate. Additionally, flaming or flambéeing the alcohol before adding other ingredients can help burn off some of the alcohol contents while still imparting the desired flavour.

However, it's important to note that even with proper cooking techniques, some alcohol may remain in the dish. The type of dish and the amount of alcohol initially added can also play a role in the final alcohol content. Dishes with a large volume of alcohol or a short cooking time after adding the alcohol, such as fondue or flambéed desserts, are more likely to retain higher levels of alcohol.

Therefore, it is essential to consider the cooking time, temperature, and preparation techniques when cooking with alcohol to ensure that the majority of the alcohol burns off, especially when preparing food for children.

Some cultures don't think twice about letting kids sip wine

While some cultures frown upon giving children alcohol, others have no qualms about letting kids sip wine. In France, for instance, it is customary to offer children a sip à table, and French teenagers and young adults seem less prone to excessive drinking than their American peers. Similarly, during the Passover Seder, it is a tradition to allow kids to join in the ritual of drinking four cups of wine, even if it's just a sip.

There are differing opinions on whether it is a good idea to let children sip alcohol. Some people argue that it teaches kids to drink responsibly and de-stigmatizes the act, making them less likely to go overboard when they start drinking unsupervised. They also point to research that suggests people who grew up in households where alcohol was not allowed were more likely to develop alcoholism later in life. However, other studies indicate that early exposure to alcohol is correlated with potentially problematic drinking later on.

It's important to consider family history when making decisions about allowing children to sip alcohol. If there is a pattern of alcohol abuse in the family, it is probably best to avoid getting children accustomed to alcohol. Additionally, it's worth noting that in some places, serving alcohol to minors is considered a felony.

When it comes to cooking with alcohol, it's generally believed that the alcohol burns off during the cooking process if the dish is cooked at a high enough temperature for a long enough time. However, some people prefer to add the alcohol towards the end of cooking to retain its flavour, which could result in a small amount of alcohol remaining in the dish. While this is generally considered safe for children, it's always a good idea to consult a pediatrician, especially if there are concerns about the child's health or medical history.

Small amounts of alcohol in food are harmless to healthy children

Alcohol is often used in cooking to enhance the flavour of dishes. Wine, in particular, is a coveted cooking ingredient because it intensifies the flavours of a dish, which is why it is often used in sauces, stews, and marinades, as well as a basting liquid and to deglaze a pan.

The question of whether it is safe for children to consume food cooked with alcohol is a complex one, and opinions vary. Some people believe that small amounts of alcohol given infrequently are harmless to healthy children. For example, a child who eats very little would likely consume a negligible amount of alcohol in a dish cooked with wine. Additionally, the alcohol content of a dish can be reduced by cooking it for a sufficient length of time at a high enough temperature. For example, simmering a pasta sauce containing wine for 15 minutes can reduce the alcohol content by approximately 60%, bringing the alcohol concentration to less than 1%.

However, it is important to note that the amount of alcohol that evaporates depends on the cooking method and preparation. Dishes cooked with wine will have varying levels of alcohol content depending on factors such as the volume of wine used, the cooking time, and the temperature. Meals that include a large volume of wine or have a short cooking time after adding wine are not suitable for children due to the amount of alcohol that will remain. For example, desserts that are flambéd or fruit macerated in wine will still contain significant amounts of alcohol.

The decision to allow children to eat food cooked with alcohol ultimately depends on the parent's personal stance and the dish's preparation. While small amounts of alcohol in food may be harmless to healthy children, there is no specific amount of ethanol (alcohol) that is considered safe for children to consume. Parents should also be aware of other sources of alcohol in a child's diet, such as vanilla extract, which is 35% alcohol, and non-alcoholic beverages, which can contain up to 0.5% alcohol.

Consult a health professional for individual advice

The question of whether it is safe for children to consume food cooked in alcohol is a complex one, and it is always advisable to consult a health professional for individual advice. While some maintain that alcohol burns off during cooking, this is only true to a certain extent, and the amount of alcohol that evaporates depends on various factors, including the cooking method, preparation, temperature, and length of cooking time.

Health professionals, such as Dr. Jasmin Roman, a general practitioner in New York, advise that there is no specific amount of ethanol (alcohol) that is considered safe for children. The concerns surrounding children's consumption of alcohol go beyond acute intoxication and overdose to include neurophysiological risks such as sleep disturbances, confusion, and unsteady walking. Dr. Roman recommends avoiding cooking with alcohol for children as the only way to ensure complete safety.

However, it is important to note that the impact of alcohol consumption also depends on serving size and the child's body weight. Some argue that the small portions consumed by children and the dilution of alcohol across a dish result in negligible amounts of alcohol being ingested. Additionally, in some cultures, it is common for children to be served small amounts of wine, and these practices have not been linked to negative health outcomes.

When making decisions about feeding your children food cooked in alcohol, it is essential to consider your personal stance on the matter and the specific circumstances of your child. Consulting a healthcare professional can provide tailored guidance that takes into account your child's medical history and any relevant cultural and religious considerations. They can advise on safe cooking methods and offer specific advice regarding your child's age, weight, and overall health.

By seeking individual advice, you can make informed decisions about including alcohol in your cooking while ensuring the safety and well-being of your children.

Frequently asked questions