Alcohol In A Water Bottle: Is It Safe?

Whether it is okay to store alcohol in a water bottle depends on several factors, including the type of alcohol, the type of water bottle, and the duration of storage. Some people suggest that alcohol should not be stored in plastic water bottles due to concerns about the leaching of chemicals like BPA and DEHP, alterations in the taste of the alcohol, and the potential ingestion of plastic particles. However, others have shared experiences of storing alcohol in plastic bottles without noticeable negative effects. Glass or stainless steel bottles are generally recommended for storing alcohol, and if plastic is used, certain types like HDPE, LDPE, or PP are considered safer options. The duration of storage also plays a role, with shorter periods being less likely to cause significant issues. Ultimately, the decision involves weighing potential health risks with the convenience of using a water bottle for alcohol storage.

Plastic water bottles are made of thinner plastic than liquor bottles

It is generally advised to avoid storing alcohol in plastic water bottles, especially for extended periods. One key reason is that plastic water bottles are made of thinner plastic than liquor bottles, which raises concerns about the alcohol's potential impact on the bottle's structural integrity.

Firstly, it is important to understand that plastic encompasses a wide range of materials with varying properties. Some plastics are better equipped to handle alcohol than others. Liquor bottles are typically made of a thicker, more durable type of plastic, such as PET or PETE, which is specifically designed for beverage bottling. On the other hand, plastic water bottles are often made of flimsier, less robust plastic.

The difference in plastic thickness between liquor bottles and water bottles is significant because alcohol is a solvent. This means that alcohol can dissolve certain substances, including some types of plastic. While whiskey or vodka may not be strong enough solvents to immediately break down a plastic water bottle, prolonged exposure could potentially lead to the alcohol interacting with the plastic. This could result in the plastic leaching chemicals, altering the taste of the alcohol, or even introducing harmful substances into the liquid.

The potential consequences of storing alcohol in a plastic water bottle are further emphasised by the common wisdom among whiskey collectors that plastic can significantly alter the flavour of the whiskey. While this may be less noticeable with lower-quality spirits, it can be particularly detrimental to the taste of high-quality whiskey. Additionally, there are valid concerns about the potential health risks associated with ingesting dissolved plastic or other chemicals that may leach from the bottle.

However, it is worth noting that some individuals have reported storing alcohol in plastic water bottles for short periods without any apparent negative effects. For example, one person shared their experience of storing vodka in a water bottle for about a month without any noticeable issues. Nonetheless, the general recommendation is to avoid using plastic water bottles for alcohol storage, especially for extended periods, due to the potential risks outlined above.

Alcohol can dissolve plastic, potentially leading to ingestion of harmful chemicals

Alcohol is a solvent, meaning it can dissolve other substances. The plastic used in disposable water bottles is flimsy and may not be suitable for storing alcohol. Certain types of plastics commonly used in beverage bottling (labelled PET or PETE) have been shown to leach trace amounts of BPA, DEHP, and other carcinogens when reused. Therefore, it is recommended to use an actual reusable water bottle made of materials like aluminum, stainless steel, or more durable plastic (HDPE, LDPE, PP). Alternatively, storing alcohol in a glass bottle is a safer option.

The primary concern when storing alcohol in plastic is the potential alteration of the alcohol's flavor. Common wisdom among whiskey collectors is that plastic significantly alters the flavor of the whiskey. For low-quality whiskey, this may not be a significant issue as the alcohol is likely to be mixed with other drinks to mask the flavor. However, for high-quality whiskey, preserving the original flavor is crucial.

Moreover, there is a valid fear that if alcohol dissolves the plastic, consuming the alcohol could result in ingesting plastic particles or other harmful chemicals. While this concern is justified, the degree of harm from drinking whiskey from plastic may not be significantly different from regularly consuming other beverages from plastic containers, such as water or milk. Nevertheless, it is generally recommended to avoid using plastic bottles for long-term storage of alcohol, especially if the storage duration exceeds a year.

It is worth noting that some individuals have shared their experiences of storing alcohol in plastic bottles without apparent issues. For example, one person shared that they stored alcohol in a plastic Coke bottle for a couple of years without noticing any taste degradation. However, others caution against this practice, emphasizing the potential health risks associated with ingesting toxins from the plastic.

In summary, while it may be tempting to reuse a water bottle for storing alcohol, it is important to consider the potential risks. Alcohol can dissolve plastic, leading to the possibility of ingesting harmful chemicals. To ensure the safety and quality of the alcohol, it is advisable to opt for reusable bottles made of materials like aluminum, stainless steel, or specific types of food-grade plastic.

Whiskey collectors believe plastic negatively alters the flavour of the whiskey

While it is not uncommon for whiskey to be sold in plastic bottles, especially cheaper varieties, whiskey collectors generally advise against storing whiskey in plastic bottles. The primary concern is that plastic negatively alters the flavour of the whiskey.

Whiskey collectors believe that plastic significantly affects the flavour of whiskey, especially high-quality whiskey. This is because whiskey is a solvent that can dissolve other substances. While whiskey is not strong enough to eat away at a plastic bottle, the alcohol in the whiskey may dissolve small amounts of plastic or other harmful chemicals, which can then be ingested. This fear is not unfounded, as certain types of plastics commonly used in beverage bottling have been shown to leach trace amounts of BPA, DEHP, and other carcinogens when reused.

However, it is important to note that the science behind how whiskey interacts with plastic is not yet fully understood. Most studies on plastics focus on how they hold up to various chemicals rather than taste. Additionally, the degree to which drinking whiskey from plastic is harmful is similar to drinking other beverages like water or milk from plastic bottles.

Some whiskey enthusiasts argue that the type of plastic used in whiskey bottles is better suited to handle alcohol than the flimsy plastic in disposable water bottles. They suggest that short-term storage in a plastic water bottle is probably safe, but long-term storage should be done in a proper plastic liquor bottle or, preferably, a glass bottle.

Ultimately, the consensus among whiskey collectors is to avoid storing whiskey in plastic bottles, especially for more than a year. This is to ensure that the flavour of the whiskey is not compromised and to minimise any potential health risks associated with ingesting dissolved plastic or chemicals.

Certain types of plastics commonly used in beverage bottles can leach carcinogens

The safety of storing alcohol in a water bottle depends on several factors, including the type of alcohol, the type of plastic, and the duration of storage. While it may be convenient to use a water bottle to sneak alcohol into a show or store it for a short period, it is generally recommended to avoid using plastic bottles, especially for long-term storage.

Certain types of plastics commonly used in beverage bottles, such as those labelled PET or PETE, have been shown to leach trace amounts of harmful substances like BPA, DEHP, and other carcinogens when reused. These plastics are designed for single use and are not intended for long-term storage. Alcohol is a solvent, and while it may not dissolve the plastic as quickly as a strong solvent like isopropyl alcohol, it can still interact with the plastic and cause the leaching of chemicals over time.

The concern is not only about the plastic bottle disappearing but, more importantly, about the potential alteration of the alcohol's flavour and the leaching of harmful chemicals into the alcohol. Common wisdom among whiskey collectors is that plastic significantly alters the flavour of the whiskey. Additionally, there is a valid fear that if alcohol dissolves the plastic, an individual could end up ingesting bits of plastic or harmful chemicals. While the degree of harm from drinking whiskey from plastic may not be significantly different from drinking other beverages from plastic bottles, it is still a health concern.

To minimise the risk of harmful chemical exposure, it is recommended to use alternative containers for storing alcohol. Reusable water bottles made of materials like aluminium, stainless steel, or more durable plastics (HDPE, LDPE, PP) are safer options. Glass bottles are also a better choice for storing alcohol and are preferred by many distillers and whiskey collectors. It is worth noting that even glass bottles can have plastic components, such as silicone seals, which may be soaked in alcohol and leach toxins, so thorough rinsing is essential before reuse.

In summary, while it may be tempting to reuse a water bottle for storing alcohol, it is important to consider the potential risks associated with certain types of plastics. The leaching of carcinogens and other harmful chemicals can negatively impact both the quality and safety of the alcohol. Therefore, it is advisable to opt for containers specifically designed for storing alcohol, such as those made of glass, stainless steel, or approved food-grade plastics.

Reusing isopropyl alcohol bottles for drinking water is generally not recommended

Firstly, isopropyl alcohol is a chemical solvent, and even in small amounts, it can dissolve certain plastics. This means that traces of the alcohol could remain in the bottle even after rinsing, potentially leaching into the water and affecting its taste and safety for consumption. Isopropyl alcohol has a distinct odour, and while it is unlikely to cause harm in small amounts, regular exposure to it or ingestion of it may have adverse effects.

Secondly, the type of plastic used in isopropyl alcohol bottles is typically not intended for food or beverage storage. Non-food grade plastics may contain chemical additives that are not suitable for human consumption. These additives could potentially leech into the water, altering its taste and potentially introducing harmful substances. Even if the plastic is similar to that of water bottles, it is challenging to determine if the exact type of plastic is suitable for reuse as a water container.

Additionally, the potential risk of altering the water's taste cannot be overlooked. Isopropyl alcohol has a strong odour, and even if it doesn't pose immediate health risks in trace amounts, it can affect the sensory experience of drinking water. This is a similar concern to that of storing alcoholic beverages in plastic bottles, where the flavour of the alcohol can be significantly altered.

Furthermore, the manufacturer of the isopropyl alcohol bottle should be consulted. In some cases, manufacturers explicitly advise against reusing their bottles for any other purpose, especially for storing drinking water. Following their recommendations is essential for ensuring safety and avoiding potential health risks.

While reusing containers may seem environmentally friendly, it is crucial to prioritize health and safety. Therefore, it is generally recommended to use dedicated water bottles, preferably made from materials like aluminum, stainless steel, or glass, which are safer and more suitable for storing drinking water.

Frequently asked questions