Alcohol In Dry Counties: Legal Or Not?

In the United States, a dry county is a jurisdiction where the sale and public consumption of alcohol are prohibited. While the 21st Amendment repealed nationwide prohibition, it gave state and local governments the power to regulate the alcohol industry within their borders. This has resulted in a mix of wet and dry counties across the country. While the laws vary, dry counties generally ban the sale of alcoholic beverages in stores and restaurants, but residents can still possess and consume alcohol in their homes. These laws are often influenced by religious beliefs or a history of temperance movements. While some argue that dry counties deter alcohol consumption and related crimes, studies suggest otherwise, indicating higher DWI death rates as residents travel to neighbouring areas to purchase alcohol and then drive back.

Dry laws and their variations

Dry laws refer to laws that prohibit the sale and purchase of alcoholic beverages in specific areas, typically at a county level. These laws can vary significantly across different states and even within a single state. For instance, some counties may ban all sales of alcohol, while others may only restrict sales at certain times or on specific days, such as Sundays.

The enforcement of dry laws is largely influenced by religious factors, particularly in states with a significant population of evangelical Protestant Christians, who traditionally discourage alcohol consumption. In addition, some states, like Alaska, implement alcohol restrictions to address issues related to alcohol abuse and alcohol-related crimes.

The specific variations of dry laws can be categorized into three main types:

• Dry laws: These are counties that completely ban the sale and purchase of alcoholic beverages. For example, Moore County, Tennessee, home to the Jack Daniel's whiskey distillery, is a dry county.
• Moist laws: These counties allow some sales of alcohol, typically in wet cities within the county. An example is Mississippi, which is wet by default, but has 36 out of 82 counties that were dry or moist before the state repealed alcoholic prohibition.
• Wet laws: In these counties, alcohol sales are allowed and regulated. However, there may still be restrictions on the types of establishments that can sell alcohol or the days and times when sales are permitted.

It is important to note that the violation of dry laws can result in legal penalties, including fines, jail time, and the revocation of business or liquor licenses. These penalties can vary depending on the specific jurisdiction and the nature of the violation.

The impact of dry laws has been studied, and there are mixed findings. Some research suggests that residents of dry counties have to travel farther to consume alcohol, potentially increasing impaired driving exposure. On the other hand, a study in Arkansas found that wet and dry counties had similar proportions of alcohol-related crashes. Additionally, the shift from dry to wet laws can bring economic benefits, but it may also lead to increased crime rates, according to certain studies.

Religious influence on prohibition

The Twenty-first Amendment to the United States Constitution repealed nationwide Prohibition in the US. However, prohibition under state or local laws is still permitted, and many states have a mix of restrictions. For instance, Mississippi has several dry counties but no law against having open containers of alcohol while driving.

The religious influence on the prohibition of alcohol in dry counties is evident. A 2018 study of wet and dry counties in the US found that religious composition following the end of Prohibition strongly predicts current alcohol restrictions. The reason for maintaining prohibition at the local level is often religious in nature, as many evangelical Protestant Christian denominations discourage alcohol consumption by their followers. For example, in 1906, 54 of Arkansas's 75 counties were completely dry, influenced by the anti-liquor campaigns of the Baptists and Methodists.

Some states are dry by default, meaning counties must specifically authorize the sale of alcohol. These include Kansas, Tennessee, and Alabama. Other states, such as Mississippi, are wet by default, and local jurisdictions must choose to go dry via referendum.

The regulatory architecture for alcohol at the federal level has led to a dispersed business landscape. States have a mix of restrictions, and laws vary widely from state to state and even within a state. For example, a county may prohibit alcohol sales at night, while another may only restrict sales on Sundays, known as "blue laws." These laws are rooted in the Christian tradition of Sunday worship. While many blue laws have faded away, some states, like Arkansas, only overturned them recently.

The impact of dry laws on public safety is mixed. Some studies suggest that residents of dry counties have to drive farther to consume alcohol, increasing impaired driving exposure. However, one study found that a similar proportion of crashes occurred in both wet and dry counties. Another study found that dry counties in Kentucky had a higher rate of meth lab seizures than wet counties.

Legal penalties for violations

The penalties for violating dry laws vary depending on the jurisdiction and the nature of the violation. While some counties prohibit only the sale of alcohol, others may also ban possession and consumption. Here are the possible legal penalties for violations in dry counties:

Fines and Citations

Violating liquor laws in a dry county can result in fines or citations. These are typically imposed for minor offences, such as public intoxication, which is usually considered a minor offence and often results in a citation requiring the payment of a small fee.

Misdemeanour Charges and Jail Time

More serious violations of dry laws, such as liquor law violations or drunk driving, can lead to misdemeanour charges. These charges can result in jail time, with penalties varying depending on the jurisdiction and the specifics of the case.

Business Licence Revocation

Businesses that violate dry laws, such as by selling alcohol without the appropriate licence or selling to minors, may have their business licence or liquor licence temporarily or permanently revoked. This can be a significant penalty, impacting their ability to operate.

Mandatory Rehabilitation

In some cases, individuals caught purchasing alcohol in violation of dry laws may be subject to mandatory rehabilitation programmes. This is especially relevant when an individual is struggling with alcohol abuse or addiction.

Complicating Other Alcohol-Related Charges

Violating a dry law can also complicate other alcohol-related charges. For example, if an individual is charged with public drunkenness in addition to violating a dry law, they may face more severe legal punishments due to multiple violations.

It is important to note that ignorance of the applicable dry laws in a specific county is typically not a valid defence in court. Therefore, individuals and businesses must be aware of the local laws and regulations regarding alcohol in their jurisdiction to avoid legal penalties. Consulting with a local attorney or criminal defence lawyer is advisable to navigate these complex laws and potential penalties.

Alcohol availability in dry counties

The availability of alcohol in dry counties in the United States varies, with some prohibiting both the sale and public consumption of alcohol, and others allowing possession and consumption but banning sales. While dry counties typically have stricter laws surrounding alcohol, these vary widely between states and even between counties within a state.

Alcohol Sales

In dry counties, the sale of alcohol is typically forbidden, meaning there are no liquor stores, bars, or restaurants serving alcoholic beverages within the county limits. However, some dry counties may only prohibit certain types of liquor-selling establishments or certain types of alcohol. For example, beer and wine may be sold, but not hard liquor.

Alcohol Possession and Consumption

In some dry counties, it is legal for residents to possess and consume alcohol, as long as it is for personal use. This means that, although residents cannot buy alcohol within the county, they can still drink legally in their homes. However, public consumption of alcohol is often prohibited.

Exceptions

There are some exceptions to the restrictions on alcohol in dry counties. For example, Moore County, Tennessee, home of the Jack Daniel's whiskey distillery, is a dry county, but the distillery sells commemorative bottles of whiskey on-site. Additionally, the Supreme Court of the United States has held that states do not have the power to regulate interstate shipments of alcoholic beverages. Therefore, municipal, county, or state legislation banning alcohol possession by passengers of vehicles operating in interstate commerce, such as trains and buses, may be unconstitutional.

Penalties for Violations

Violations of dry law requirements can result in legal penalties, including mandatory rehabilitation for individuals and fines or jail time for business owners, as well as the revocation of business or liquor licenses. Dry counties often have additional local ordinances that can lead to harsher sentences on top of state-mandated penalties for alcohol-related offenses.

Effectiveness of dry counties

The effectiveness of dry counties in the United States is a topic of ongoing debate. Proponents of dry counties argue that restricting alcohol sales can deter consumption and reduce alcohol-related crimes and social issues. However, research and statistical data suggest that the impact of dry counties may be more complex and, in some cases, counterproductive.

One of the primary arguments in favour of dry counties is the potential reduction in alcohol-related harm and crime. Indeed, studies have shown that a 10% increase in drinking establishments is associated with a 3% to 5% increase in violent crime. Dry counties are also often motivated by religious beliefs and a history of temperance movements that disapprove of alcohol consumption. Additionally, some states, like Alaska, have implemented alcohol restrictions to address problems with alcohol use disorder and alcohol-related crime.

However, critics of dry counties point out several concerns about their effectiveness. Firstly, residents of dry counties may need to travel longer distances to access alcohol, resulting in increased impaired driving exposure and potentially higher rates of alcohol-related crashes and fatalities. Studies in Kentucky and Arkansas have supported this notion, finding higher rates of alcohol-related crashes and fatalities in dry counties compared to wet ones. This phenomenon may be due to residents driving under the influence on their way back from purchasing alcohol in neighbouring areas.

Secondly, the effectiveness of dry counties in deterring alcohol consumption is questionable. While some people may be discouraged from drinking due to the inconvenience of travelling, others may simply stock up on alcohol when visiting wet counties. Additionally, dry counties do not necessarily prohibit alcohol consumption, and residents can still possess and consume alcohol purchased elsewhere.

Lastly, the economic impact of dry counties can be detrimental. Restricting alcohol sales can result in a loss of tax revenue for the county, impacting funding for various public services.

In conclusion, while dry counties may be well-intentioned, their effectiveness in reducing alcohol-related harm and consumption is questionable. The potential increase in impaired driving and alcohol-related crashes, along with the loss of tax revenue, are significant concerns. Alternative approaches, such as limiting the days and hours of alcohol sales as suggested by the CDC, may be more beneficial in managing alcohol-related issues while also maintaining tax revenue and reducing the burden on residents who need to travel long distances for alcohol.

Frequently asked questions