The Truth About Alcohol In Cooking: Halal Or Haram?

Alcohol is considered haram in Islam, and Muslims are forbidden from consuming it. The Prophet stated: Every intoxicant is haram. However, the question of whether it is permissible to consume dishes cooked with alcohol if the alcohol has cooked off is a complex one. Some sources state that alcohol does not entirely evaporate during cooking, with studies showing that even after hours of cooking, some alcohol content remains. Other sources claim that if the alcohol has been fully absorbed into the food or drink and no trace of it can be detected, it is permissible to consume. Muslims are advised to avoid dishes cooked with alcohol and to inquire about the presence of alcohol when dining out.

Alcohol in food is haram if it can be tasted, seen, or smelled

Some studies have found that alcohol does not completely burn off or cook off during the cooking process. A 1992 study by the USDA, for example, showed that after flaming, about 75% of the alcohol remains in the pan. Other studies have found that even after simmering a dish for one and a half hours, 20% of the original alcohol content remains. It is only after simmering for two or more hours that the alcohol content decreases to 5-10%.

Therefore, it is not permissible to consume dishes cooked with alcohol if the alcohol is still detectable. However, if the alcohol has been fully absorbed and no trace of it can be detected, then it is not considered haram. This is supported by the hadith of the Prophet: "If alcohol falls into water and is completely absorbed in it, then someone drinks it, he is not regarded as drinking alcohol..."

It is important for Halal consumers to be aware of this information when cooking with or consuming food that contains alcohol. When eating at restaurants, they are advised to inquire about the presence of alcohol in the food and avoid dishes that contain it, regardless of claims that the alcohol has been cooked off.

Alcohol does not entirely burn off during cooking

Alcohol is considered haram in Islam, and Muslims are forbidden from consuming it. The Prophet stated:

> Whatever intoxicates in large amounts (wine, etc.) is haram (forbidden) in small amounts.

The question of whether it is permissible to consume dishes cooked with alcohol hinges on whether the alcohol content has been fully absorbed and disappeared into the food or drink, with no essence or trace of it remaining. If the alcohol is fully absorbed, it is permissible to consume the food or drink. However, if the essence of the alcohol remains or can be detected in terms of taste, colour, odour, or flavour, it is haram to consume.

According to a study by the USDA, flaming food, a common method used in cooking to burn off alcohol, only removes about 25% of the alcohol content. Other studies have found that alcohol burns off after hours of cooking. The length of cooking time affects the amount of alcohol burned off, with one source stating that simmering a dish for one and a half hours leaves 20% of the original alcohol content, while simmering for two hours or more reduces the alcohol content to 5-10%.

Based on the above information, it is clear that alcohol does not entirely burn off during cooking, and the remaining alcohol content can vary depending on the cooking method and duration. Therefore, consuming dishes cooked with alcohol may still be considered haram, especially if the alcohol content has not been fully absorbed and can still be detected. Halal consumers are advised to avoid dishes containing alcohol, even if they are told that the alcohol has been burnt off or cooked off.

Alcohol is haram even in small amounts

Alcohol is forbidden for Muslims to consume, and this includes when it is used as an ingredient in food. The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) stated that "whatever intoxicates in large amounts (wine, etc.) is haram (forbidden) in small amounts".

The presence of alcohol in food or drink makes it prohibited, even if the percentage of alcohol is very small. If the alcohol has been fully absorbed into what it has been mixed with and no trace of it can be detected, then it is permissible to consume. However, if the essence of the alcohol remains or its traces can be detected in terms of taste, colour, odour, or flavour, it is haram to consume.

Studies have shown that alcohol does not completely burn off or cook off during cooking. For example, if you add beer or wine to a boiling liquid and then immediately remove it from the heat, 85% of the alcohol content will remain. If the alcohol is lit, as in flambé dishes, 75% will remain. Even after simmering for one and a half hours, 20% of the original alcohol content will still be present. It is only after simmering for two or more hours that the alcohol content drops to 5-10%.

Therefore, it is not permissible to cook with alcohol or to consume dishes cooked with alcohol, as it is unlikely that all of the alcohol has been evaporated. Halal consumers are advised to avoid food that contains alcohol and not to bring alcohol into their homes for cooking.

Vinegar is halal despite being derived from wine

Alcohol is considered haram in Islam, and cooking with it is forbidden. However, the question of whether it is permissible to consume food cooked with alcohol if the alcohol has evaporated is more complex. According to some sources, if the alcohol has been fully absorbed into the food and no trace of it can be detected in terms of colour, taste, or odour, then it is permissible to consume.

Vinegar, despite being derived from wine, is generally considered halal in Islam. Wine vinegar is made from white or red wine, and the fermentation process turns the alcohol into acetic acid, which is the main constituent of vinegar. This change in composition means that wine vinegar is no longer considered an intoxicant, and therefore, it is halal.

However, there is some disagreement among Islamic scholars on this issue. Some argue that deliberately turning wine into vinegar is not permissible, as it is not considered pure. This is based on the hadith of Anas ibn Malik, who reported that the Prophet was asked if wine could be changed into vinegar, to which he replied, "No."

Nonetheless, other scholars argue that vinegar is a well-known basic foodstuff and that the Prophet praised vinegar as "good food." Additionally, 'Umar, one of the early Islamic leaders, is quoted as saying that there is nothing wrong with buying vinegar from non-Muslims as long as one knows that it was not deliberately processed from wine.

In conclusion, while vinegar is derived from wine, it is generally considered halal in Islam due to the transformation of alcohol into acetic acid. However, there are differing opinions among scholars regarding the deliberate transformation of wine into vinegar.

Muslims are advised not to bring alcohol into their homes for cooking

Alcohol is forbidden for Muslims to consume, and the Prophet made it clear that even small amounts are forbidden. According to a hadith, the Prophet said: "Every intoxicant is unlawful and whatever causes intoxication in large amounts, a small amount of it is (also) unlawful."

Some Muslims may wonder if it is permissible to eat dishes cooked with alcohol, especially since it is well-known that alcohol evaporates with heat. However, the answer is that not all the alcohol content is removed with heat; it depends on the type and time of cooking. For instance, if beer or wine is added to a boiling liquid and then immediately removed from the heat, 85% of the alcohol content will remain. If the alcohol is lit, as in flambé dishes, 75% will remain. Even after simmering for one and a half hours, 20% of the original alcohol content will still be present. It is only after simmering the mixture for two or more hours that the alcohol content drops to 5-10% of the original amount.

Thus, it is not surprising that Muslims are advised not to bring alcohol into their homes for cooking. When eating in restaurants, Muslims are advised to ask if the food contains alcohol and to avoid it. Servers may claim that the alcohol has been "burnt off" or "cooked off", but this is not accurate according to studies. A 1992 study by the USDA, for example, found that after flaming, about 75% of the alcohol remains in the pan. Another study by researchers at the University of Idaho, Washington State University, and the US Department of Agriculture's Nutrient Data Laboratory also calculated that alcohol added to boiling liquid and then removed from heat retained 85% of its alcohol content.

Therefore, Muslims who wish to strictly adhere to Halal dietary requirements should avoid recipes that call for alcohol.

Frequently asked questions