The Mystery Of Native American Alcohol Intolerance

Alcohol abuse and alcoholism have had a long and devastating impact on Native Americans and Alaska Natives, leading to the stereotype of the drunken Indian. However, this stereotype is not based on fact. While it is true that alcohol-related deaths among Native Americans are about four times as common as in the general US population, and fetal alcohol spectrum disorder is seven times the national average, there is no evidence that Native Americans are genetically more susceptible to alcoholism. Instead, the high rates of alcohol abuse among Native Americans are likely due to the historical trauma of colonisation and the ongoing, multi-generational trauma of cultural genocide.

Alcoholism is common in many Native American tribal populations

Historically, the introduction of distilled spirits and wine by European colonists disrupted Native American communities. Alcohol was used as a trade item and in diplomatic negotiations, leading to economic instability, increased violence, and health issues within tribes. The sudden availability of alcohol left little time for the development of social and legal guidelines, contributing to its abuse. Additionally, the extreme intoxication observed among colonists provided a powerful model for inexperienced Native Americans, influencing their social drinking behaviours.

Cultural factors also play a role in the high prevalence of alcoholism. The "firewater" myth, rooted in racist ideology, blamed Native Americans' genetic inferiority for their susceptibility to addiction. This stereotype has burdened Native American communities and obscured the underlying causes of addiction, such as trauma and inequality.

Genetics may also contribute to the high rates of alcoholism in some Native American tribes. Studies have found evidence of heritability for alcohol dependence in certain tribal populations, such as the California Indians and Southwest American Indians. However, it is important to note that Native Americans do not metabolize or react to alcohol differently than other racial groups, and there is no single gene responsible for higher alcohol tolerance. The variation in tolerance is influenced by socioeconomic status, living situations, and domestic factors.

The high rates of alcoholism have led to the development of treatment programs specific to Native American communities. Organizations like the Society of TRUTH (Tribal Families, Rural and Urban, Together Healing) provide resources and support that incorporate tribal practices with traditional therapy, addressing the unique cultural and historical contexts of Native American communities.

While alcoholism is prevalent in many Native American tribes, it is essential to recognize that not all individuals within these communities struggle with alcohol abuse. The stereotype of the "Drunken Indian" is a generalization that ignores the vast number of Native Americans who maintain sober and productive lives.

Pre-colonisation, Native Americans consumed weak fermented beverages

Pre-colonisation, Native Americans did indeed consume fermented beverages, but these were weak and not widely consumed. Fermentation has always been a part of every culture, including those of Native Americans, as it is an indispensable preservation technique. Native Americans in Mexico and Central America prepared over forty different alcoholic beverages from a variety of plants and plant extracts. Traditional Mayan beverages included Balché, made from the bark of Lonchocarpus violaceus soaked in honey and water and fermented, and Xtabentún, made from honey produced from the nectar of a species of morning glory. Other beverages included Coyol wine or chicha de coyol, made from the sap of coyol palms, colonche, made with the fruits of Opuntia streptacantha (prickly pear), and Tepache, made from the peel and rind of pineapples.

However, these beverages were not widely consumed by all Native Americans. Fermented drinks were typically associated with sedentary populations, and not all Native Americans were sedentary. The beverages also had very low alcohol content compared to European drinks. Before European colonisation, the native population of the territory that would eventually become the United States was relatively naive to alcohol's effects. Some tribes produced weak beers or other fermented beverages, but these were generally used only for ceremonial purposes. The distillation of more potent and thus more abusable forms of alcohol was unknown.

When various European colonists made large amounts of distilled spirits and wine available to Native Americans, the tribes had little time to develop social, legal, or moral guidelines to regulate alcohol use. Alcohol was introduced as a medium of trade, often in exchange for highly sought-after animal skins and other resources. Traders also provided free alcohol during trading sessions, giving them a distinct advantage in negotiations. Extreme intoxication was common among the colonists and provided a powerful model for the social use of alcohol among the inexperienced Native American populations. Numerous historical accounts describe extremely violent bouts of drinking among Native American tribes during trading sessions and on other occasions.

Genetic predisposition to alcohol dependence

While some sources claim that there is a genetic predisposition to alcohol dependence among Native Americans, this idea has been debunked by several studies. The stereotype of the "Drunken Indian" is a harmful myth that has contributed to the stigmatization of Native American communities.

The notion that Native Americans are genetically more susceptible to alcoholism stems from the "firewater" myth, which has been discredited as a racist ideology that fueled colonialism. This myth blames Native Americans for their struggles with alcohol, ignoring the historical context and the role of trauma in addiction.

Research suggests that the high rates of alcohol abuse in Native American communities are not due to genetic factors but rather the result of historical and socioeconomic factors. When European colonists introduced distilled spirits and wine to Native Americans, they did so without allowing time for the development of social, legal, or moral guidelines to regulate alcohol use. The sudden availability of alcohol, often used as a medium of trade, disrupted Native American communities, leading to increased violence, health problems, and economic instability.

Additionally, the intergenerational trauma experienced by Native Americans, including forced relocations, cultural symbol destruction, and family separation, has been identified as a significant contributor to addiction. Studies have shown that adverse childhood experiences significantly increase the risk of alcoholism.

While there may be some genetic influence on alcohol dependence within specific Native American populations, such as the California Indian population, the evidence is mixed. Some studies suggest that certain symptoms of alcohol dependence, like withdrawal, may be more heritable than others. However, overall, there is no conclusive evidence that Native Americans are biologically more susceptible to substance use disorders than any other group.

In conclusion, the idea of a genetic predisposition to alcohol dependence among Native Americans is not supported by scientific evidence. The high rates of alcohol-related issues in these communities are better explained by historical, socioeconomic, and trauma-related factors. Addressing these underlying causes is crucial for developing effective and culturally sensitive treatments for alcohol abuse within Native American populations.

Alcohol-related deaths among Native Americans are four times the national average

Alcohol-related deaths among Native Americans are about four times as common as in the general US population, with men and Northern Plains Indians experiencing higher rates of alcohol-related deaths. Native Americans have the highest age-adjusted mortality rate (AAMR) among all racial and ethnic groups in the US, with a rate 3.6 times higher than that of Non-Hispanic Whites. This disparity is even more pronounced in certain age groups, with Native Americans aged 15-24 being 12.2 times more likely to die from alcohol-related causes than their Non-Hispanic White counterparts.

There are several factors that have contributed to the high rate of alcohol-related deaths among Native Americans. Historically, the introduction of distilled spirits and wine by European colonists disrupted Native American communities, as they did not have time to develop social, legal, or moral guidelines to regulate alcohol use. Alcohol became a medium of trade, often exchanged for valuable resources such as animal skins, and was used as a tool by European-American colonists to commit cultural genocide. The sudden availability of alcohol led to extreme intoxication and violence among Native Americans, as they lacked experience with its effects, and this behaviour was further modelled by the heavy drinking of colonists, traders, military personnel, and civilians.

Additionally, the stereotype of the "Drunken Indian" has burdened Native American communities, as it perpetuates the notion that all Native Americans struggle with alcohol abuse. While alcoholism is prevalent in many tribal populations, it is important to note that not all Native Americans are afflicted with alcohol problems, and many lead sober and productive lives. Furthermore, most studies on alcohol use among Native Americans have focused on those living on reservations or traditional Indian lands, who account for only one-third of the total Native American population in the United States.

The high rate of alcohol-related deaths among Native Americans has been linked to various health issues, including hearing and vision problems, kidney and bladder issues, head injuries, pneumonia, tuberculosis, dental problems, liver problems, and pancreatitis. Alcohol misuse during pregnancy has resulted in a high rate of fetal alcohol spectrum disorder in some tribes, with rates as high as 1.5 to 2.5 per 1,000 live births, more than seven times the national average.

To address these disparities, initiatives such as the Indian Health Service aim to develop support strategies and provide resources to prevent and treat alcohol and substance abuse within Native American communities.

The stereotype of the drunken Indian

The stereotype of the "drunken Indian" is a harmful and racist stereotype that has burdened Native American communities. It is often perpetuated by the idea that Native Americans are genetically predisposed to alcoholism or that they have a higher alcohol tolerance. However, there is no evidence to support these claims.

Native Americans have a diverse and long history of producing and consuming alcohol for ceremonial purposes before European colonization. For example, pre-Columbian Native Americans in Mexico and Central America prepared over forty different alcoholic beverages from various plants and plant extracts. However, the distillation of more potent and easily abusable forms of alcohol was introduced by European colonists, who also used alcohol as a medium of trade and a tool for cultural genocide. The sudden availability of large amounts of distilled spirits disrupted Native American communities, leading to an increase in violence and health problems.

The stereotype of the "drunken Indian" ignores the historical and socioeconomic factors that have contributed to the high levels of alcohol abuse in Native American communities. It also fails to acknowledge the impact of intergenerational trauma, which has been linked to a higher risk of addiction. Additionally, most studies on alcohol use among Native Americans have focused on those living on reservations or traditional Indian lands, representing only one-third of the American Indian population in the United States.

While it is true that Native Americans have high rates of alcohol addiction, with a 2013 survey showing that Native American adults had the highest alcohol addiction rate per capita at 14.9%blame Native Americans for their struggles with alcoholism, ignoring the role of European colonists in introducing distilled spirits and disrupting Native American communities. This stereotype has also led to the stigmatization and further marginalization of Native American communities, perpetuating a cycle of trauma and addiction.

Frequently asked questions