Alcohol Vs India Ink: What's The Difference?

Indian ink, also known as China ink, is a carbon-based black ink that is commonly used in calligraphy, painting, and tattooing. It is made from pine soot and animal glue or a binding agent, and it can be found in both liquid and solid form. On the other hand, alcohol ink is a dye-based ink made by combining colourful dyes with an alcohol solution. It is known for its vibrant colours and interesting effects, as well as its fast-drying properties. While Indian ink is often used on paper or board, alcohol ink is typically applied to smooth surfaces such as glass, metal, or plastic. In terms of application, Indian ink is usually applied with brushes, pens, or nibs, while alcohol ink can be used with brushes, pens, pipettes, or eye droppers.

Chinese ink vs Indian ink

Indian ink, also known as China ink, is a carbon-based black ink that is commonly used in comic book inking, line art, and various other ink work. It is made from burning materials such as bones, tar, pitch, and other substances to create carbon black, which is then mixed with a binding agent and formed into sticks. This type of ink is often waterproof and can be found in both liquid and solid form. It is well-suited for creating fine lines and precise strokes, making it a popular choice for calligraphers, illustrators, and designers.

Chinese ink, on the other hand, is traditionally made from pine soot combined with animal glue or another binding agent. It is formed into sticks or blocks and takes a long time to dry, sometimes requiring several months. This process results in a dry, solid ink that can last for many years without losing its quality. Chinese ink is often used in oriental art and calligraphy and is known for its permanence and ability to create precise strokes.

Indian ink tends to be waterproof, while Chinese ink is typically not. Indian ink also has a slightly glossy finish, whereas Chinese ink is known for its lustre and superior quality. The process of making Chinese ink is described by Jean-Baptiste Du Halde, who observed the Chinese manufacturing process for lampblack from oil. This process involved lighting several wicks in a vessel of oil and collecting the smoke in a funnel-shaped iron cover.

In terms of usage, Indian ink is well-suited for calligraphy, resin work, and watercolour painting. It can be used on board or paper, and different paper textures can create varied results. Indian ink is also commonly used in comic book inking and line art. Chinese ink, on the other hand, is commonly used in traditional Chinese painting and oriental art. It can be used with brushes, pens, or nibs, and is often paired with watercolour painting.

Alcohol ink, which is not the same as Indian ink or Chinese ink, is highly pigmented and can create vibrant colours and interesting effects. It dries quickly due to the fast evaporation of alcohol, leaving only the coloured dye behind. Alcohol ink is transparent and can be revived by adding more ink or alcohol, making it possible to create new layers and add depth to the artwork. However, it is difficult to control and may require practice to achieve the desired results. Alcohol ink is not recommended for use on paper as it will sink into the surface; instead, it is better suited for smooth surfaces such as glass, metal, or plastic.

Alcohol ink's dye-based composition

Alcohol inks and India inks are two distinct types of ink. India ink, also known as Chinese ink, is commonly used in oriental art, calligraphy, and tattooing. It is made from pine soot combined with animal glue or another binding agent and formed into a stick. On the other hand, alcohol ink is a dye-based ink with a distinct composition and unique properties.

Alcohol inks are dye-based inks that consist of a combination of solvents, dyes or pigments, binders, and stabilizers. The solvent base is typically ethanol or isopropanol, making up 60%-70% of the ink. The dyes and pigments provide colour and make up 5%-15% of the ink's composition. Synthetic dyes offer a wide range of colours and a translucent quality, while pigments provide opacity and UV stability, crucial for longevity and colour retention. Binders, at 2%-5%, enhance the adhesion of the ink to surfaces and influence texture and durability. Stabilizers, at 1%-3%, maintain pigment distribution and prevent sedimentation, extending shelf life.

The composition of alcohol inks results in several unique properties. Firstly, they are highly pigmented and can create vibrant, translucent colours and interesting effects. Secondly, due to the fast evaporation of alcohol, alcohol inks dry within minutes, making them rapid-drying inks. However, this also means that they can be difficult to control and may require practice to achieve the desired results. Alcohol inks are also fully waterproof, which is a beneficial feature for certain artists. Additionally, alcohol inks can be revived by adding more ink or alcohol, allowing for unique effects and the ability to redo or alter a painting.

Alcohol inks are versatile and can be used on various surfaces, including glass, metal, plastic, ceramic, stone, leather, polymer clay, and non-porous surfaces like Yupo paper and ceramic tiles. They are well-suited for colouring epoxy resins and creating unique effects in resin art, jewellery making, and craft projects. The inks can be applied in different ways, such as using pipettes, eye droppers, or squeeze bottles, and can be manipulated with tools like palette knives, paintbrushes, or air blown through a straw.

In summary, alcohol inks are dye-based inks with a unique composition that sets them apart from India inks. They offer artists and hobbyists vibrant colours, rapid drying times, and the ability to create translucent effects and unique artistic creations.

India ink's calligraphy use case

India ink and alcohol ink are two different types of ink. Alcohol ink is made from dyed alcohol, while India ink uses pigments to get its colour.

India ink is ideal for calligraphy. It is carbon-based and black, and its body, due to the pigments, makes it hover slightly above the paper. India ink can be used with cheap brushes and pointed pens, although it should be washed off with water frequently to prevent it from drying and destroying the tool. India ink is water-soluble when not dry, so it can be diluted with water and used for water brush lettering. It can also be used in calligraphy to draw outlines for miniature paintings, versals, and design elements. However, India ink should not be used in fountain pens as it contains shellac, a non-water-soluble material that can clog the pen.

For calligraphy, India ink is best suited for dip pens, as the nibs can be easily swapped out when they corrode.

Alcohol ink's fast-drying nature

Alcohol inks and India inks are two distinct types of ink with different properties. Alcohol inks are created by combining dyes with an alcohol solution, resulting in a perfectly suspended ink with no sedimentation. On the other hand, India inks, also known as Chinese inks, are carbon-based black inks that use pigments instead of dyes to achieve their colour.

Alcohol inks stand out due to their fast-drying nature, typically drying within minutes. This quick drying time is attributed to the evaporation of alcohol, leaving only the coloured dye behind. The fast-drying property of alcohol inks offers both advantages and considerations for artists.

One advantage of alcohol inks' rapid drying is their versatility and ease of correction. Artists can take advantage of their fast-drying nature to create layers and add depth to their artwork. Additionally, if an artist is unhappy with their initial creation, they can easily re-wet the dried alcohol ink with additional alcohol or ink, allowing for corrections or the exploration of new artistic directions. This characteristic of alcohol inks provides a level of flexibility and experimentation not commonly found with other inks.

However, the fast-drying nature of alcohol inks also presents some challenges. Artists need to work quickly as the ink dries, which may require practice and skill to manage effectively. Additionally, the low lightfastness rating of alcohol inks means that colours may fade or dull over time, limiting their suitability for certain types of artwork or applications where long-term colour accuracy is crucial.

In contrast, India inks have a longer drying time, which can be advantageous in certain situations. For example, when creating intricate calligraphy or detailed illustrations, a slower drying time allows artists to work at a more deliberate pace without worrying about the ink drying too quickly. India inks are also known for their ability to create fine lines and precise strokes, making them a preferred choice for calligraphers, illustrators, and tattoo artists.

In summary, while alcohol inks offer the convenience of fast-drying times, allowing for easy corrections and experimentation, they also require a certain level of skill to manage their rapid drying process effectively. On the other hand, India inks provide a slower drying time, making them ideal for detailed work and creating precise lines in calligraphy and illustrations. The choice between alcohol and India inks ultimately depends on the specific artistic techniques, effects, and applications desired by the artist.

India ink's permanence

India ink, also known as Chinese ink, is a black or coloured ink that was once widely used for writing and printing. It is now more commonly used for drawing and outlining, especially in comic books and comic strips. It is also used in medical applications and tattooing.

The permanence of India ink depends on the formula used for the ink. Modern India ink products tend to stick to the traditional formula, but some have tweaks, and homemade India ink is becoming more popular. The permanence of India ink is also affected by the application process. For example, a binding agent such as gelatin or shellac may be added to make the ink more durable once dried. If a binder is used, India ink may be waterproof or non-waterproof.

Some commercially available India ink products on the market add additional additives to change the colour, which can also change its permanence. There are different levels of permanence, and an ink that lasts for four years can be marketed as a permanent ink. However, some India ink formulas, such as Winsor & Newton Liquid Indian Ink, can last for decades.

That being said, India ink is not as permanent as archival ink, which can last for over a century. Additionally, India ink tattoos can be permanent, but the detail and colouration of the ink can start to fade in as little as a year.

India ink is made from a variety of fine soot, known as lampblack, combined with water to form a liquid. The Chinese manufacturing process for lampblack involves putting several lit wicks into a vessel of oil and collecting the soot produced. The best oil gives a lustre to the black, making the ink more esteemed.

Frequently asked questions