Religion Vs. Aa: A Conflict Of Interests

Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) is a fellowship that helps alcoholics achieve sobriety. The foundation of AA is based on the 12-step programme, which encourages members to relinquish themselves to a higher power. While AA does not push a specific religion or God, its traditional emphasis on spirituality and religion has been a point of contention for some. The organisation's roots can be traced back to the Oxford Group, which required religion, and AA's 12-step programme has been criticised for demanding a belief in a higher power. Despite this, AA has helped many people, and some members have shared that they felt spiritually awakened after attending meetings.

AA's 12-step programme encourages members to submit to a higher power

Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) was established in 1935 by Bill Wilson and Dr. Bob Smith, two American men who were significantly influenced by a Christian organization called the Oxford Group. The Twelve Steps, which are central to AA, stress belief in and dependence on "God" or a "Higher Power" in achieving recovery. While AA endorses belief in "God," it is one "of your own understanding". This has been interpreted to mean that members are not forced to believe in God per se, but rather a higher power of their own interpretation, which could be science or the universe, for example.

The 12-step programme encourages members to submit to a higher power, which has been criticised as lacking scientific credibility and being irrational. This has led to a wave of criticisms targeting AA's religious components, with some arguing that it is a religious practice. In defence of AA, some members have stated that the faith aspect is just a small portion of the programme, and that one's higher power could be anything. The point is to get over the addiction for reasons greater than oneself, which is necessary for people to overcome their addiction.

The AA concept of powerlessness over alcohol differs from the Oxford Group's belief in the possibility of complete victory over sin. The Oxford Group also required more stress on religion, which Dr Silkworth advised against, suggesting that Wilson place more emphasis on the science of treating alcoholism.

AA has been described as a spiritual rather than religious program, with members saying that they came to the program to stop drinking but stayed to grow spiritually. This has been interpreted as evidence of cultish brainwashing or a symptom of a disenchanted world. While AA has traditionally emphasised religion, there has been a recent trend within AA that marks a departure from this, with a growing number of meetings appealing to nonreligious people. These groups, which number about 150 nationally in the US, do not recite the Lord's Prayer but instead say together, "Live and let live".

AA's philosophy and core text are influenced by religion

Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) was established in 1935 by Bill Wilson and Dr. Bob Smith, two American men who were significantly influenced by a Christian organization called the Oxford Group. The Oxford Group stressed the possibility of complete victory over sin, while AA departs from this belief by asserting that alcoholism cannot be cured.

AA's philosophy and core text, "Alcoholics Anonymous", are influenced by religion. The text, published in 1939, introduced the Twelve Steps, which are central to AA and influenced by the Oxford Group's six steps and various readings, including William James's "The Varieties of Religious Experience". The Twelve Steps stress belief in and dependence on "God" or a "Higher Power" in achieving recovery. While AA endorses belief in "God", it is one "of your own understanding", and members are allowed to use whatever "higher power" they want.

The AA concept of powerlessness over alcohol is also influenced by religion. The idea that alcoholism is a disease that cannot be cured, and that alcoholics must admit their powerlessness over alcohol, is a significant shift from traditional religious beliefs about sin and self-control. This idea of powerlessness is a common theme in AA meetings and literature, and it often involves surrendering to a higher power.

While AA has been criticised for its religious components, it is important to note that it does not push any specific religion or God. Instead, it presents itself as a "'spiritual' rather than 'religious' program". Many members describe themselves as spiritual seekers who came to the program to stop drinking but stayed to grow spiritually. This spiritual aspect is a key part of AA's appeal and effectiveness for many members.

In conclusion, while AA's philosophy and core text are influenced by religion, it does not require members to adhere to any specific religious beliefs. The spiritual aspect of the program is flexible and can be interpreted in various ways, allowing members to find their own path to recovery.

AA meetings have been described as having a religious feel

Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) was established in 1935 by Bill Wilson and Dr. Bob Smith, two American men who were influenced by a Christian organization called the Oxford Group. The Twelve Steps, central to AA, were influenced by the Oxford Group's six steps and various readings, including William James's "The Varieties of Religious Experience". The steps stress belief in and dependence on "God" or a "Higher Power" in achieving recovery.

AA has been described as a religious practice, with meetings having a religious feel. The organization has traditionally emphasized religion, and meetings typically end with the recitation of the Lord's Prayer. However, AA has also been described as a "'spiritual' rather than 'religious' program, with members encouraged to believe in a God "of your own understanding". This has allowed some members to interpret the "Higher Power" as something other than a monotheistic God, such as science or the universe.

The religious aspects of AA have been criticized by some, who argue that it lacks scientific credibility and is irrational. There has been a recent trend within AA to move away from religion, with the rise of secular groups that appeal to nonreligious people in recovery. These groups have been described as a manifestation of a more visible and confident humanist movement. While AA meetings have been described as having a religious feel, it is important to note that the organization itself has never been deemed a religion. Courts have ruled that attendance at AA meetings cannot be coerced, as it would violate the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment of the US Constitution.

Despite the religious aspects of AA, it is not a religion in the traditional sense. It does not promote a specific religious doctrine or require members to adhere to a particular set of beliefs. The "Higher Power" concept is open to interpretation, and members are free to choose what they believe in. This flexibility has allowed people from a variety of religious and non-religious backgrounds to find value in the program.

While some may argue that the religious aspects of AA are unnecessary or even harmful, others have found spiritual growth within the program. It is important to note that AA is not a one-size-fits-all solution and that there are other options for treating alcoholism. The program has helped many people achieve sobriety and has contributed to a worldwide conversation about addiction and recovery.

AA's success rate is low, yet it dominates the discourse on alcoholism

Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) is a fellowship founded in 1935 by two men, "Bill W." and "Dr. Bob S.", to help people of all ages, backgrounds, and ethnicities overcome their addictions. AA's core text, the Big Book, claims that AA has about a 50% success rate, with another 25% staying sober after relapsing once or several times. However, critics argue that the success rate is much lower, between 5% and 10%.

The AA program is based on a 12-step process that emphasizes the idea of powerlessness over alcohol and the need to submit to a higher power. This religious aspect of AA has been a point of contention for some, who feel that it goes against the organization's core value of honesty. The requirement to surrender to a higher power can be challenging for those who do not hold religious beliefs.

Despite its long-standing presence and the personal testimonies of those who credit AA with their recovery, the effectiveness of AA has been debated. Some critics argue that the 12-step program can be harmful to the majority of addicts and that it has one of the worst success rates in medicine. The low success rate of AA may be due to the fact that it does not address the underlying causes of addiction or provide individuals with the tools to understand and manage their addiction.

However, it is important to recognize that recovery from addiction is a complex and highly individual process. While AA may not work for everyone, it has helped many people achieve sobriety. The sense of camaraderie and community that AA provides can be a powerful motivator for those struggling with addiction. Additionally, AA's flexibility and willingness to adapt to changing societal needs are evident in the growing number of secular AA groups.

The dominance of AA in the discourse on alcoholism may be influenced by various factors, including media endorsement and the lack of awareness about alternative treatment options. AA's long history, international presence, and the personal testimonies of its members contribute to its prominence. However, as more individuals share their experiences and promote secular options, the conversation around alcoholism treatment is gradually becoming more diverse and inclusive.

AA's religious components have been deemed coercive and unconstitutional

Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) has faced criticism and legal challenges due to its religious components, with some arguing that these elements are coercive and violate constitutional rights. While AA has helped many individuals overcome alcoholism, its approach has been questioned and contested in recent times.

The Twelfth Step of the AA program, which involves finding a spiritual awakening through belief in a "Higher Power" or "God," is a central tenet of the program. However, this step has been criticised for its religious implications and potential coercion. The program's core text, "The Big Book," emphasises that alcoholism cannot be cured, and achieving sobriety requires belief in a higher power. This religious aspect has been a point of contention, with critics arguing that it lacks scientific credibility and is irrational.

In the United States, legal challenges have been mounted against AA, asserting that coerced attendance at meetings violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. Specifically, the Ninth Circuit of the US Court of Appeals ruled in 2007 that a parolee ordered to attend AA meetings had the right to sue their parole office. This ruling set a precedent, acknowledging that mandatory participation in AA can infringe on constitutional rights.

The Toronto coordinating body of AA, the Greater Toronto Area Intergroup of Alcoholics Anonymous, has also faced criticism. They asserted that belief in God was a requirement for membership in Toronto groups. While mediation led to a resolution, it highlighted the tension between the organisation's religious roots and the secular values of some members.

AA's religious components have been a source of debate and controversy, with some members and critics arguing for a more secular approach to recovery. While AA has helped many, the organisation has had to navigate legal and societal shifts regarding the separation of church and state and changing beliefs.

Frequently asked questions